No. 12 — "Die Welt" — Page 11
(continued from page 10)
…on his head looks curiously across the table. The "Purim players" have come. Clad in masks, they play Ahasuerus and Esther and Mordecai and Haman. And the children are delighted — the parents look on somewhat thoughtfully, yet contentedly. It is Purim. Soon spring will be here. A double reason to be glad. A pleasant historical remembrance and an enjoyment of the coming sun.
Now it is otherwise. The interests of modern times have made an end of the old remembrances and consolations.
And the old merriment, too, is gone. The earnestness of life has swallowed it up. There you have a group of Jews in Whitechapel. When they still dwelt in their eastern homelands, in the little towns of Poland and Lithuania — their life there was so primitive, so simple and unaffected, so ever the same, that this Purim week, too, always called forth the same old merry feelings. Now they have been banished from their homeland. They are in a new land, still strange to them in spite of their adaptability; they are not clear with themselves; the old has already become strange and comical to them, and a substitute they have not yet won. So the Jewish carnival, too, is in decline — the old merriment, the "old merriness" is gone ...
And we turn once more to the vexatious questions of politics. Of Jewish politics this time. To the questions that have arisen within Zionism. It is already known that the East African expedition has begun its return journey to Europe. A resourceful, nimble correspondent of the all-knowing "Reuter's Bureau" has already questioned Major Gibbons on the results of the expedition. What the Major told him has already become known. This too: that the "Wanandi" attacked the rearguard of the expedition. So these, too, are no Ugandists, no Yes-sayers. That the expedition is attacked is nothing new. Why, the vanguard was attacked, that is to say, before it had even set out. Moreover, the "Wanandi" will certainly not be the last to have attacked the expedition.
Whether in this way or in that — de gustibus non est disputandum. Zangwill, too, has returned from his American tour. Naturally he was at once interviewed, and that by a representative of the "Jewish Chronicle". "Zangwill said approximately: "I wished that the American Jews should not let the present crisis pass without having recognised it. The acceptance or the rejection of the East Africa project is a serious matter; but a far more serious situation would have arisen if it were not taken into consideration at all." He further censured the conduct of the opposition party among the English Zionists, with Bentwich and Doctor Gaster at its head. To the question how he conceived the colonisation in East Africa, he said: "An East Africa Company ought to be founded, whose shares would have to be brought on the market, and I believe that Jews would nevertheless buy these shares without thinking of immediate profit. The project would have to be built on a purely business footing, and precisely thereby it would differ from the earlier Jewish colonisation schemes. Support would of course have to be granted to the first pioneers. Sir Samuel Montague and his like are dreamers. They do not understand that the Jewish question must be solved on a business and not on a philanthropic basis. The "Ica", too, does not think politically about the matter. The people who go to East Africa would pay for themselves, but they would bring the same energy and the same enthusiasm as in their migrations to America and South Africa. Not a playground for refugees, but a settlement for enterprising men it is to be. If gold should be found in East Africa, then you may be sure that the Jews would very soon go there. The colony need not necessarily rest exclusively on agriculture. I have never pursued the idyllic dream of the general return to the soil. Only the foundation of life would have to be agriculture, but the people need not be transformed into a nation of peasants ..." Zangwill then expressed the view that the East African movement was a support of the Palestinian. "If we get East Africa, we should have a starting-point for the organisation of our forces for Palestine. The success of the settlement would be a message of hope for those who desire Palestine, which would show them that we can accomplish something in the world of deeds. The first building in East Africa would be the 'Zionist Hall.' But if the Congress should reject the project after the Commission has laid a favourable report before it — and the Actions Committee has already shown its weak and unconstitutional handling of the question — then a grave crisis would follow, and I would rather not say what I should do. But apart from myself, I feel that there are forces which would bring about a split in the movement. There is a strong party in the making which recognises the advantages of a possession of soil of our own, even though it be not Palestine ...." "Organise yourselves!" was Zangwill's closing word. Without regard to one's views otherwise — whether for or against East Africa — organisation above all!..." Of his successes in America Zangwill has not told much. Why? What are the reasons that made the propaganda in America not so fruitful as was to be hoped? If one were to believe certain publicists, the salvation of Israel lies not in "Old Europe" but in "New World", in America, "the land of unlimited possibilities". Why do these expectations make themselves so little manifest?
On the present political situation of Zionism Dr. Bodenheimer of Cologne also spoke, who was in London together with Dr. Kokesch of Vienna and Dr. A. Marmorek of Paris. "The East African question was merely an episode in the Zionist movement," said Dr. Bodenheimer, among other things, in his speech, which he delivered at a meeting in the "Jewish Working-Men's Club", at which Sir Francis Montefiore presided. He sought to clear Mr. Cowen and Mr. Greenberg of the suspicion that they had in any way departed from the Palestinian ideal. "They did not even think of straying by a hair's breadth from the one and only goal of the Zionist movement." Dr. Bodenheimer's speech was very hopeful. In the spirit of Dr. Herzl, he said, in the spirit of his political views, of his last wish, we must work on. "To overcome all obstacles, to master all difficulties, in order to plant the blue-and-white flag upon the walls of Jerusalem and to bury the bones of Doctor Herzl in the land of the fathers ..."
East Africa — an episode — East Africa — a support of the movement. And both opinions uttered by men who hold a prominent place in the movement. Which of the two is right? Of whom will one be able to say: "ceci tuera cela?" Perhaps I shall shortly be in a position to give an answer to that.
Spectator.