Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 14 · 7 April 1905
3printed page
scan 3 of 20

No. 14 — "Die Welt" — Page 3

(continued from page 2)

…doctrine, race shapes life," he says, and in this respect he is entirely in agreement with Renan, who likewise derives all the peculiarities of the Jewish people, its religion and its view of the world, from race. "As nature produces no general flowers and fruits, no general animals and plants, but only types of plants and animals", so the Creator in history produces only national types." (ib. 58). That is the creed of nationalism as Hess sought to ground it philosophically. A thought which had already been applied to German history before Hess, and which is likewise upheld by all the race theorists from Gobineau to Chamberlain. And in the sense of his whole view of the world Hess holds "that it is to-day a matter of letting the different national types come forth freely and develop". Is not that the modern grounding of the Jewish national movement as it is now offered? To develop freely — to what end?

This question a modern would answer by regarding the free development of the individual and of the national stock as an end in itself; Hess could not yet let go of the old constructions of history. To him Judaism was the cult of history; Judaism seemed to him called to offer new values. What these might be and of what nature they should be, he has not defined for us more closely. But one thing is clear to him, that "in exile" this development is impossible. As we thus see, Hess was not merely a forerunner. He was no stammerer of half-truths. On the contrary, he was more consistent, more many-sided, deeper than we modern Zionists. He understood every side of the question, took every side into consideration. And if, as had always been his habit, he conceived the Jewish question too not merely as a question of the stomach but also as a question of ideas, this was the striving after a unified view of the world, historically and philosophically grounded. He believed he had derived his nationalism from Spinoza; he had, however, derived it from Hegel. Nevertheless it was an attempt, after the Spinozist method, to regard the matter sub specie aeternitatis. Whether he succeeded is a question to which it is impossible to give an absolute answer. For views of the world are subjective views. One can fight against them with the means of logic and of science; refute them one cannot. Still less a construction of history such as that of Hess, which is poetic and profound, but arbitrary. The grounding of Hess's nationalism may fall or stand, the reasonings with which he accompanies his expositions may please us or not, the kernel of the question remains untouched. Hess was the first to declare in clear and precise form, to formulate in the form of a sociological law, that the Jewish nation exists, that it has a right to self-determination, that for this purpose it needs a land of its own, that this land must be Palestine, that the Jews can reach this goal by their own strength with the support of France — and these are indeed the principles of the whole of modern Zionism. That they were not heeded is the fault of circumstances, is Hess's fault, that he came too early. It is an indirect refutation of his sociological views.

Hess "hated and abhorred the Revolution," as he said in one of his writings, but he forgot that without the Revolution, without political freedom, the historical mission too, the social ideal of perfection, are absolutely unattainable and impracticable. Nor can the nationally enslaved, disfranchised Jews be true national Jews. For to be national means to love one's nationhood consciously, and not merely "yielding to necessity." Only a politically free people can think of the values of culture. Hess the national Jew has refuted Hess the social politician.

And Hess the national Jew also refutes the national Jews of to-day who fear evil consequences for the national movement from the liberation of the great masses in Russia, and refutes the expectation of those who hope from a change of the political régime in Russia for the denationalisation of the Jews. In both these cases Hess can serve us as counsellor. Not as a practical one, nor wholly and entirely in theory. Only in a certain sense, in a certain direction. In the direction of feeling. This too we can learn from Hess, that it is not the superstructure, the theoretical structure of every movement, and of ours too, that is the most important thing. Fundamentally different from Hess in philosophical respect, diametrically opposed to him, we too, that is, those who do not interpret history as he did, can go together with him on the question of the Jewish future and present. A hint for the present, a lesson for the future.

And if one seeks in the books where the names of the great and mighty are entered, his name one does not find. To the vanquished no quarter is given. But he long championed the cause of the vanquished. When we become victors — then Hess's name too will be entered in indelible characters in our book of the great — because he had the courage to be what he was.

A. Coralnik.


Questions of the Day and Points of Dispute in Zionism.

IV.

We come now to the most important point of dispute in Zionism. Charter Zionism or Chovevei Zionism? Legally secured guarantees, or simply work in Palestine?

It would be of great interest to follow more closely the evolution which many Zionists have gone through with regard to this question, but this is not the place for it. One thing we wish to establish: many, very many of those who formerly were not content even with legally secured guarantees, but absolutely demanded guarantees secured under international law, now raise "work in Palestine to a political height." On the other hand we find, conversely, that men who began with practical small-scale colonisation now energetically stress the standpoint of political Zionism, "proceeding from the recognition that for an economic development of Palestine political guarantees, to be acquired at the same time, are absolutely necessary, and moreover entirely possible." (Underlined by us.) So spoke a thorough authority on the question, Professor Warburg, at a meeting in Berlin on the 6th of February of this year.

On the other hand, however, we can by no means approve when the present "rage for work for Palestine" is described as "hysterical." In it lies a sound kernel; in it lies the recognition of the great road which must be travelled from the beginning of the work to the integral realisation of a social-political programme. The goal is nothing, the