Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 14.
(continued from page 5)
…amine. This view, that no end can be put to the Golus of the Jewish people, is indeed not new. What is new is only its appearance within the Zionist party. How could this curious opinion, which calls into question Zionism, the national rebirth, the becoming of Judah into a State, gain so firm a footing in our ranks that the Central Bureau of the Russian Zioni Zion could recommend in its leaflet an essay which is directed against Territorialism and which also contains the theory mentioned?
On the one hand, the whole theory contains nothing more than Achad-Haam's view of the cultural centre, though in a worsened edition. On the other hand, however, it is a good old acquaintance whom the anti-Zionists have so often introduced to us at meetings, namely the objection: Zionism is a Utopia, for one simply cannot bring the Jews to Palestine.
That a small minority can be settled in Palestine even the most vehement anti-Zionists have conceded. The objection of Utopia corresponds to the general Jewish faint-heartedness and despair, even when it drapes itself in reasons apparently ever so lucid. To Zionist faint-heartedness and despair corresponds the view that the Jews must remain for ever in the Diaspora; in Palestine, it is said, one will at most accommodate a minority of the Jewish people.
Against this faint-heartedness, which is already beginning — as is only natural with us Jews — to clothe itself in a most beautiful and well spun-out little theoretical cloak, front must be made from the very beginning with the utmost sharpness.
We political Zionists have emphasised from the beginning that the economic, cultural and national distress must be solved by Zionism, that our aim is therefore the solution of the Jewish question altogether. Only thus, by setting up the just and well-founded postulate of the solution of the Jewish question through Zionism, did we win public opinion and turn the attention of the Governments upon ourselves. For if Zionism concerns only the minority of the Jews, if the great mass of the Jews remains for ever in the lands of the Golus, what interest should the Governments, or the peoples, then have in regarding the Jewish question as an international affair whose solution lies in their own interest also? For with Dr. Pasmanik I attach an extraordinary value to this self-interest of the Powers as a real, political factor, all the more as I am of opinion that this self-interest will grow in the future, even if the "Russian spring" cited by Mr. Feiwel should bring the Jews in Russia certain alleviations.
That the view in question comes to us from Russia is not further surprising; for it is precisely there that the impulse to take part in present-day work prevails, and it must also be readily admitted that there a reasonable present-day work is absolutely necessary. But does one really need so absurd a theory for its justification in order to occupy oneself with present-day work? Is it not self-evident that we cannot let our people sink into misery, that we must not sacrifice the present for the sake of a fairer future? Moreover, it is a self-evident command that we must fulfil our duties as citizens, but also that we may under no circumstances neglect our rights as citizens, if we do not wish to sink to utterly rightless pariahs. For the justification of all these self-evident things, which comprise present-day work within themselves, there is no need, however, of the so absurd conception that the Jews in their great mass will remain in the Diaspora. Why do not these prophets also assert that the Jews have been in the Diaspora from all eternity?
In view of all the confusing views which are pressing forward to-day, it is more necessary than ever to emphasise, more than ever, political Zionism in its original form — the legacy of Theodor Herzl. The phalanx of the Zionist party will hold fast, now as before, to the principle that the Jewish distress in all its forms will be solved by political Zionism as it is laid down in the Basle Programme.
On the East Africa Question.*)
By Dr. E. Simonson.
Rightly has the Zionist press already begun the discussion of the East Africa project without awaiting the result of the Expedition; for only thus can the ground be prepared for the understanding which must of necessity be brought about at the VIIIth Congress. A sound agreement cannot, that is, be reached in such a way that the one tendency says to itself: The others have, after all, the stronger voice; a split is a misfortune; therefore we must give way and put the plan out of the world with decency. This mood of resignation appears, for example, to have been at work in the circular addressed by our German leader to the members of the D. C., in which he expresses the confident hope that the East Africa question will be finally disposed of for us in the course of this year. That is not the way which can lead to a lasting settlement. Rather, clarity and a sound peace can only be attained through ample discussion, by which accumulated misunderstandings are dispersed and each truly learns from the other what his real opinion is. Perhaps it will then turn out, to the joyful surprise of both sides, that the differences are not at all so fundamental as appeared under the dominion of party catchwords.
I wish to state at the outset that I shall speak to you as an advocate of the project, and that not merely out of "diplomatising" considerations, in order to secure for the offer of the British Government a first-class funeral befitting the importance of the one who made it, but because I believe that it will prove possible, on the 15,000 square kilometres offered, to root in the soil, within 15–20 years, half a million (?? Ed.) and more homeless Jews under the protection of English freedom, and so to preserve them for the Jewish people and for Jewish nationhood. Because, further, I live in the hope that the colony, under suitable direction on the principles of land reform, may become for us an economic experimental station, which would far surpass in importance the agricultural experimental station planned by the Palestine Commission, whose value and importance, for the rest, I well know how to appreciate to the full.
Thirdly and finally, because I am animated by the confident hope that this charitable action on a great scale, far from injuring Zionism, would rather bring a mighty furtherance of its material and spiritual resources of power, and with it an acceleration in the attainment of its final aim.
*) Address delivered before the Berlin Zionist Association on February 23rd, 1905.