Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 14 · 7 April 1905
9printed page
scan 9 of 20

No. 14. — "Die Welt" — Page 9.

(continued from page 8)

…mediate cure. A radical recovery is possible only in Palestine — on this Mr. Greenberg too agrees with us; but plasters must be laid upon the diseased places at once, otherwise we shall not be in a position to get as far as Palestine. In this Mr. Greenberg is right. The only question is which remedy should be chosen for this "raising up." We point to work on the spot. Mr. Greenberg recommends Uganda. In Zionist jargon this is called "work in the present"; not a particularly happy designation, but for brevity's sake we accept it, and let us try to settle the question whether Uganda is suited to "work for the given moment."

When we are told that the Jewish masses need a territory of their own as quickly as possible, the reference is chiefly to our emigrants, whose number is growing menacingly. The doors of the civilised countries are to be shut against the emigrants; they therefore cannot wait for Palestine, and only speedy help in the form of a territory of their own can save them. In other words, the masses who must now emigrate are to be settled upon this territory. And at once the old rejoinder is at hand: to an empty territory one can artificially transport some thousands of souls, but a great and natural settlement is, under present economic conditions, possible only when there exists in the land of immigration a certain demand for labour, that is, when the country has attained a certain industrial development. And therefore by purposeful colonisation one understands nowadays only one thing: to raise up in the country the industry that can attract emigrants. That, however, requires much time, and the more uncultivated the country, the more time. For the first period there can be no question of masses at all: in the course of many years much effort and sacrifice will be required of individual persons, while the real mass migration will begin only when the industrialisation of the country shall have reached a certain high stage. This has been repeated often already, and the Ugandists have not disputed it. On the contrary, the Odessa Ugandists even write as follows in their latest circular: "We know very well that after the receipt of the charter the country must first be prepared for the reception of the first settlers; we know that a mass immigration all at once is unthinkable, that it will cost much time and trouble; but we know also that for the lost one or two decades we shall gain a model Jewish commonwealth . . ."

The talk, then, is not of work for "the present moment," but of one to two decades, and that is a very modest reckoning. Our emigration figure is 100,000 a year; in 20 years it is wholly impossible to create out of an absolute wilderness — which is what Uganda is — a home that could receive and feed such masses. It would be in order, instead of one or two decades, to add a third and a fourth decade to them. And as the result of this "present-day" work the Ugandists count upon a model Jewish commonwealth. And are they content with that? No, by no means: afterwards they will still need Palestine, that is to say, there too a Jewish commonwealth, a real and final one, will have to be created.

But in that case the question is surely obvious: why not spend these same decades at once upon the preparation of the "commonwealth" in Palestine? "Why, very simply," — answer the Ugandists — "in Uganda it is easier, and we cannot wait."

Nevertheless, as we have seen, one will still have to "wait," and that for whole decades. And as to how far it will be "easier" in Uganda, Mr. Greenberg imparts to us interesting data upon which it is worth while to dwell somewhat longer.

When we ask in what Uganda actually differs from Argentina, and why we must expect something greater from Uganda than from Argentina, the Ugandists answer us: "In Uganda we are given an autonomy." At this answer one reflects that the difference, especially for the first period, is hardly very great. Argentina is a constitutional country, that is, the Jewish colonies there possess, like all other communities, the right of self-government, personal liberty, freedom of assembly, of association and of the press, in whatever language they will; they may found strictly national schools there, erect Jewish theatres, and in general develop their individuality in the best possible manner. Nor does anyone forbid them there to keep the Sabbath holy, a circumstance to which Mr. Greenberg attaches particular importance. They merely cannot wage wars with other nations, but that will not be permitted us in Uganda either. It is true that the civil and criminal codes of Argentina were not drawn up by us. But these codes are more or less alike in all liberal states, and this likeness increases more and more for the simple reason that the principles of justice are everywhere the same; and it is not in this field that one people must distinguish itself from another, but in the field of spiritual creation and of individual development, and precisely this field is in Argentina restricted by nothing. And would we, perhaps, create new constitutions and codes in Uganda? No, we should act as all nations do when they need a whole new legislative system: one takes a foreign constitution and foreign codes and adapts them to one's own needs. And in the result the difference between the laws of Uganda and of Argentina would be a very insignificant one, so that we absolutely fail to understand why Mr. Greenberg exclaims: "The plan connected with the Argentine colonies failed because sentiment had no voice in it; autonomy will form the sentimental element in East Africa!" One must suppose from this that "Jewish sentiment" yearns greatly for the independent recasting of the Belgian constitution and of the Code Napoleon, for it is in this procedure alone that the mighty difference consists between the autonomy of Uganda and the bondage of Argentina.

It is true, to be sure, that autonomy has one enormous advantage, and the Ugandists always exploit it against us adherents of practical work in Palestine. They say: "Very well, you will develop industry in the country, but what guarantee have you that it will attract Jewish, and not Italian and German, workmen, who likewise emigrate? In Palestine you cannot bar the non-Jews from entry. In Uganda, on the other hand, we shall have an autonomy and can be at ease as to competition! But Mr. Greenberg, the father of the Uganda project, who knows all its advantages and disadvantages, declares categorically and with authority — not, by the way, to those of like mind among the Ugandists, but to the assimilationist "Ica," which fears this very "autonomy" more than anything — that this bugbear of autonomy, from which so much profit has been sought, is in reality by no means so disquieting. All that is proposed is that the territory placed under the administration of Jews