Page 2. — "Die Welt" — No. 17.
(continued from page 1)
…has ever abandoned is the Basle Programme. I think we shall now resist fantastic plans of every kind, but also every restriction which, for example, would bolt the door with the little word "only" against all work in the countries adjoining Palestine.
For my own part — I wish here merely to express my personal opinion — I am indeed in favour of giving far greater consideration also to the work which has been designated by the quite wretched expression "work for the present." How I mean this I hope to be able to set out more fully hereafter; for our programme stands in no need of enlargement at the moment, but of a more intensive execution. We all know that only beginnings have so far been made towards this intensive inner work, because we were accustomed to leave most things to Herzl's initiative. That this inner work, in Palestine too, should in my opinion consist chiefly in economic work; that we should at last set energetically about the systematic permeation of all Jewish institutions with Zionist work; that, above all, provision ought to be made through Zionist intervention for an incomparably more thorough removal of the consequences of Jewish migration — this I wish to emphasise expressly even now, although I am fully aware of the difficulty and tediousness of this work.
If we succeed in reaching agreement on the basis of what is common to all Zionists — the meeting of the Greater A.-C., soon to take place, will, it is hoped, contribute to this — then it will also be possible for us at the next Congress not only to take over Herzl's legacy but also to preserve it from harm. To establish this common ground as exactly as possible, and to win our fellow Zionists, in a calm and by no means aggressive manner, for what I should like to call the Zionist minimum, must be our work until the Congress; for with noise, hatred and wild passion we shall attain precisely the opposite of what we wish to attain: to prove ourselves the truly rightful heirs of Herzl's legacy.
Dr. Werner.
Ussishkin's "Our Programme."*)
This pamphlet, which appeared in the series "Jüdische Zeitfragen" and whose introductory sections were also printed in "Die Welt," No. 3 of this year, has rightly attracted attention. It is, after all, the most sharply defined critical and programmatic development of Zionist work in Palestine that we possess so far. One may indeed object that this programme is too narrowly bounded; that it neglects many or essential fields of Zionist activity, or leaves them wholly untilled; that it clings too anxiously to the cornerstone of the Basle Programme: "to create for the Jewish people a home in Palestine secured by public law," instead of taking account likewise of the further, world-embracing phases of Zionism's development, of those endeavours which aim at a general nationalisation and at the economic and cultural uplifting of the Jewish people, and which even seek in part to create and proclaim a Zionist view of the world.
This disproportion in Mr. U s s i s h k i n's appreciation of cultural Zionism, political Zionism and colonisation Zionism appears clearly even on the surface, in that chapter A), The Organisation of the Jewish People, fills ¾ of a page of his pamphlet, chapter B), The Preparation of the Peoples and Governments for the Autonomous Settlement of Palestine by the Jews, 1½ pages, and C), The Colonisation of the Country by Jewish Farmers and Artisans, 20½ pages.
But it has long been known that the author is one of the most unshakeable and consistent leaders of the Palestine-only Zionists, and no one can therefore wonder that "Our Programme" is a pure programme of Palestine colonisation.
For me — I must say frankly — the chief charm of Ussishkin's pamphlet lies precisely in this restriction, in that the real foundation of our movement is here emphasised with all sharpness and consistency; after the many endeavours at uplifting and deepening of late, one here once more scents the wholesome smell of Palestinian earth.
It is not, of course, meant to be said hereby that the reviewer agrees with the author in all respects, or holds the practicability of all his ideas to be possible in the form in which Mr. U s s i s h k i n proposes them. The exclusion of the adjoining countries from the programme, for instance, I consider politically questionable and practically mistaken. It is even probable that it is precisely through vigorous work in the adjoining countries that we shall be able to advance our aims in Palestine quite extraordinarily.
But above all — and to this Dr. P a s m a n i k rightly drew attention in No. 14 of "Die Welt" — by the restriction to New Palestine one shuts oneself off from the prospect, very important for agitation, of an early large-scale or rapid colonisation, such as is excluded in Palestine but at least conceivable in the neighbouring countries.
That Mr. U s s i s h k i n lays the chief weight on agricultural colonisation is only to be acknowledged; but in a programme the industrial development too ought to be considered somewhat more thoroughly; the author here leaves everything to the Bank, while in regard to agriculture he gives quite detailed particulars. The intellectual and cultural conquest of Palestine, too, is touched upon only very briefly, although the treatment of precisely this question ought to be one of the most important tasks of "narrower" Zionism as well.
That in Mr. U s s i s h k i n's agrarian programme the unhappily all too modest funds of the "Geula" and the "Chovevei Zion" are disposed of is reasonable enough, only more is expected of these societies than they will be capable of performing; but as regards the "Ica" or Baron R o t h s c h i l d, I fear that a co-operation of the Zionists with them in the sense set forth by Mr. U s s i s h k i n will in practice meet with almost insuperable difficulties.
Likewise I do not quite believe in the practicability of a three years' compulsory service in Palestine for the Jewish youth abroad, nor can I in practice promise myself much from it, so long as only agricultural work is in question. It would be another matter entirely if great concessions could be acquired for which extensive public works would be necessary; but even then it would have to be weighed whether one would not do better to work with unexacting paid labour (Arabs and Italians) than with people who would not only occasion great costs of transport, but would certainly be very exacting in regard to board, treatment and hygiene, and would cause those in charge of the works much vexation. As regards agricultural work, however, young people from the cities of Europe will be of little use in the first years. The very grave labour question, the sore point of the agricultural colonisation of Palestine, which the
*) Verlag "Zion," Vienna, 8vo, 31 pages, price 40 h.