Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 32 · 11 August 1905
6printed page
scan 6 of 20

Page 6 — "Die Welt" — No. 32

(continued from page 5)

…movement has itself created a number of new currents. A whole series of factions has formed, all of which look after certain special interests, and even all those who belong to no party nonetheless sympathize with one or another of them, and have in any case taken a position on the most important questions. What is more natural, then, than that in agitation each should justify precisely his own position, and seek to make of his interlocutor not merely a Zionist but also a partisan within Zionism! And yet nothing is more perverse than that! It is certainly understandable when a representative of the Misrachi turns to Orthodox circles, while the members of a radical-democratic faction are more inclined to transfer the scene of their agitational activity to the Café Monopol in Berlin; but in agitation directed outward, the Misrachist, the Ugandist, the Democrat or the Conservative, the Nay-sayer like the Yea-sayer, ought, strictly speaking, to say exactly the same thing. For our agitators have to preach solely and exclusively what is common to all Zionists. Only those already won for the organization, those already enrolled in our army, are the proper object of the agitation of the individual factions and tendencies. I should consider it a grave misfortune for our work if people were to join, not out of love for our programme, for our great idea, but merely as partisans of one of the special tendencies existing within Zionism.

Outwardly we are one and must appear as a unity; no one who acts as an agitator for our idea has the right to develop his private opinion or the programme of his party; he has solely and exclusively to expound the programme for whose execution we have all united — only to interpret the will of the whole.

I believe that, besides party passion and the natural inclination to subjectivity, yet another factor plays a part here, one with which we can never quite have done. It is, namely, at times merely a question of honesty carried too far. Honesty is a fine thing, but, as is well known, one should not make too far-reaching a use of it. Of course we should put forward what belongs to the matter honestly and clearly, unconcerned about the impression it may make. What I mean is something else. With us, for example, the following may still occur: at a large meeting a speaker delivers a brilliant and convincing address, which must inform the audience, inspire it and bring it nearer to us. Now somewhere in this address, say, a figure of speech is used or a Bible verse cited, quite in passing, or the speaker has, also quite incidentally, let fall a critical word about some not particularly important event. Scarcely has the storm of applause subsided than a member of the local group rises and delivers a half-hour speech in which he attempts to prove that there is something awry in that figure, that the Bible verse must be interpreted differently or even, from the standpoint of modern Biblical research, be struck out, or that the affair in question stood not quite as the speaker said but otherwise. And so this conscientious man contrives not only to blur the impression of the address, but also to bring about once more a hopeless confusion of ideas; for the debate now turns only on these trifles, and the visitor who went there to be enlightened will go away with the impression that the main thing is whether that verse stands in Deutero-Isaiah, or whether the National Fund stamps are badly gummed, or whether the rhythm of those verses really lets one feel the pulse-beat of a newly awakening Jewish high art.

In agitating, then, we should bear in mind that our hearers wish to hear what the Congress wants, and have no intention of receiving our personal confession. We must impose more self-discipline upon ourselves, here too think of the great and set the small aside.

One thing more must be said here: we should beware of operating with momentary successes. Certainly there is no better propaganda than that of the deed. By working, by proving our capacity for achievement, we convince the doubters who call us unpractical dreamers of their error in the most conclusive manner. But we do not want people who let themselves be dazzled by a success just achieved, by a good dividend, a flattering reception and the like; these people will faithlessly desert us as, in the changes of the times, our shares fall. If in agitation we lay too great stress on momentarily achieved successes, that is a two-edged weapon. Where expectations have been strung too high, disenchantment and slackening regularly follow when the further successes still awaited are long in coming. And the greatest danger is this: that such activity produces a reaction upon our policy, that the necessity of bringing about the promised successes leads us to work towards momentary successes. And that would be the most dangerous policy we could pursue; never, never may we work merely in order to be able to show the people a positive result. Whoever is with us must have patience and must have confidence.

I have already pointed out that this agitation from mouth to mouth must of necessity go hand in hand with the holding of propaganda meetings. The delivery of agitation lectures is one of our most effective means of agitation. Through speakers coming from outside, as already mentioned, the danger is avoided of breeding a local Zionism of its own peculiar kind. The unity of the movement is thereby assured. The worst of it is only that the speaker cannot stay several days in the place. And therefore the finest speeches often remain without lasting success if there are not capable people on the spot who know how to turn the effect achieved to account. Otherwise things stop at the famous "moral successes." For an effective meeting all manner of conditions must coincide. It is absolutely necessary that the meeting be well prepared and well conducted. Naturally the same things cannot be said at every meeting. When at first the Zionist doctrine has been sketched in its main outlines, the ground-plan will regularly have to be filled in at later lectures, special questions discussed, particular fields presented. In such cases it will above all be the business of the chairman of the meeting to make clear, in a manner intelligible to everyone, that what is offered here is not a lecture on the entire doctrine of Zionism, but only the presentation of a small part of it. He will do well to give a sketch of our whole edifice and to indicate the place to which the subject to be treated to-day belongs. In this way alone can the rise of misunderstandings and confusions be forestalled. The speaker himself will of course be able to do, if not everything, yet much towards this. To obtain a good speaker is not always easy. One who would acquit himself honourably before an assembly of scholars might for all that make a pitiful fiasco before a public of small artisans. Only think of the sad mishap which King Balak of old suffered with Balaam, known as an able agitation speaker, who spoke so altogether otherwise than his host