Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 35 · 1 September 1905
3printed page
scan 3 of 20

No. 35 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3

What Is to Be Expected from the Duma?

An Interview.

One of our contributors had a conversation with a personage who, by virtue of his position, is able to see into the present situation of Russian politics, but who is also able to render faithfully the mood of our Russian kinsmen.

The question of what Russian Jewry has to expect from the Duma naturally stood at the centre of the conversation, and our informant expressed himself upon it as follows:

Before the Manifesto came, our question ran: Who will be the representative of Jewry in the Duma? And therein the question whether Jewry would have representatives in the Imperial Diet at all was already answered in the affirmative. You will know that we were secretly quarrelling over the skin of the bear not yet killed, that we were already distributing mandates. We did it with a certain pride. Our men were not to be the worst in this review of the peoples of Russia. Were intelligence and learning to hold a rendezvous in the "High House" — well and good, then our representatives should show that all oppression had not been able to prevent us from heaping up intellectual treasures in high measure. Were business acumen and practical ability to turn the scale: there too we were in a position to send men of international repute. And even for the improbable case that wealth should make the chosen man, we were prepared. We were not prepared, it is true, for one — I might say: negative — case; namely, that the proverb "Knowledge is power" should be turned into its opposite by the whole design of the plan for the franchise. Those who in recent years in Russia fought the battle against reaction were naturally the "Intelligents" in the towns. This has, in a certain measure, physical reasons too: one can seize an opponent only in his presence, and therefore the part of the stormers and strivers fell to the urban population. Besides, in almost all ages the reforms of states have proceeded in the first instance from the towns. And this very year the report had already once appeared that the Russian bureaucracy wished to turn back the wheel of time and remove the universities out into the country. It sensed that the "Intelligence" holds in its hands the haft of the axe which strikes the trunk of reaction with heavy blows. What, then, was more natural, out of the instinct of self-preservation, than that those of Pobjedonoszew's spirit should seek to keep the Intelligence as far as possible from the Duma? And when the Intelligence is kept away, Jewry is naturally kept away as well. The franchise based upon the property qualification cannot compensate the Jews for this, because, although they belong in great numbers to the middle and lower merchant class, real great capitalists, and in particular people who pay the high house-rent fixed by the law as the standard of great wealth, are to be found among them in only a relatively small number. The question, then, since the appearance of the law on the Imperial Duma, has become quite another: we no longer ask who will enter Parliament as the representative of Jewry, but we have already grown modest and only worry whether anyone will get in as the representative of Jewry. The question is answered variously, and I should not wish to anticipate the facts. I should only like to draw attention to one anomaly, which on this occasion too shows once again how we are treated. For the border districts, that is to say for the non-Russian nationalities, special electoral laws are to be created. The nationalities will be placed less favourably than the Russians, but they will have some guaranteed representatives. Hitherto the Jews in Russia have always been treated as a separate nation and have had exceptional laws dictated to them. Now, when the consequence should follow according to which the Jews would have to receive representatives of their own, they are allowed to vanish in the superior numbers of the Russian electors. Equality of rights, then — in so far as it only does them harm.

The question now, therefore, is first and foremost: What shall we gain from the Duma in itself? Indirectly, as it were — or: in what measure shall we share in the gains of the Duma? I must confess I hold the possibility of this sharing in its gains to be very great. It has been asserted from the conservative side that the liberal majority will predominate in the Chamber. Nothing spoke out of this assertion, not yet quite proved — I wish it were proved already — but the fear of publicity. For the Russian bureaucracy secrecy alone is a guarantee of success. It was this fear of publicity, too, that brought it about that the sittings of the Duma can be closed to the eyes and ears of the world. The Liberals, just as they did not let themselves be forbidden to speak out of fear of the police truncheon, will all the less mince their words in the Duma: And this publicity is the hope of the Jews.

Above all: we shall have a forum. The law on the Duma expressly states that complaints against the administration may be brought forward in Parliament, and that with the naming of the concrete case. What is here meant as a restriction will possibly become a very beneficent institution. A great number of administrative acts of violence, indeed the whole system of bribery, rests upon its never becoming known. An official who must run the risk of seeing his doings illuminated in the Duma will take care not to carry things too far. The benefit for the Jews is here obvious. With every piece of corruption a piece of Jewish misery will disappear. If it be objected that the Jews have their active share in the bribery, one can only say that if the Jews lose advantages gained in such a way, Jewry can only rejoice at it. Certain it is that the system will be struck by the repeated exposure of individual cases.

Publicity before foreign countries, however, will not allow itself to be restricted in any way. Though a president may forbid the reporting of a debate in the Russian press, the liberal participants will inform the foreign press all the more thoroughly. In the case of Jewish riots this will have a quite direct consequence. Do you remember how they were denied at Kishineff and Homel? How in recent days the "Nowoje Wremja" was so impudent as to try to represent Kertch as harmless? How the Jewish papers said of Bialystok that they were not allowed to say anything, and this through no fault of their own? If in future a deputy in the Duma shall expose such infamies