Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 35 · 1 September 1905
7printed page
scan 7 of 20

No. 35 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 7

We had overestimated its longing to free itself from the fetters of a merely communal life and to make a beginning of an ennobling national life. We had overestimated its capacity to disregard petty quarrels and personal considerations for the sake of the great opportunity lying so close at hand, of proving to the world, by something greater, higher and worthier of man than mere endurance under persecution and oppression, that we are entitled to remain an independent people. We had underestimated the deep brand which centuries of denationalisation had burnt into the soul of our people. We forgot that the age of miracles is past. We believed that Zionism had taken hold of the Jewish people and that the evil spirit of the Ghetto had been cast out. There remained to us, too, a hope that a favourable report of the Expedition would touch still other instincts of our people, and that these would then have helped us. But it was not to be. When, therefore, we came to the Congress, there was only the shadow of a spectre left to exorcise, and the majority did so with great success.

Holding the views that I profess, I have always spoken for the best political methods in our movement, and I saw at once that the first duty of those who share my views was to accept the judgment of the majority, the unmistakable majority. For to those who were in favour of the scheme, no great principle was at stake after all. We differed only as to the means; as to the end we were always agreed. I believe that the East African scheme would have brought us considerably nearer to that end, and that its rejection was the throwing away of a great opportunity. But it would have been fatal madness to do anything whereby the means of attaining our end would have been in any way weakened, simply because a single means, from which we hoped great things and on which we built houses, did not find favour with the majority. I fear that some who were in favour of the East African scheme are now turning to other paths and seeking to found some new organisation whose aims are not very clear. If they are Territorialists — and I am very anxious to be quite rightly understood here — if they declare themselves ready to leave Palestine wholly out of account and to strive to rebuild the Jewish nation in some other territory, then I say, let them by all means found their new organisation, for among the Zionists there is no place for them, and it would be better for us to know them as open enemies outside our ranks than to have them working within them as secret enemies against our cause.

If, however, they mean only to say that, while we strive towards Palestine as our final goal, they endeavour to obtain for the Jewish people some settlement with autonomous rights, then it seems to me that their place is within the ranks of the national body. By constitutional means they must convert those who stand opposed to them, but they must not turn away from us in order to found new associations in the spirit of "Shoolism," new associations which can only weaken Zionism. Let us, however, see what they propose. For the first time in two thousand years a Government has offered the Jewish people a territory for settlement; when will such an offer be repeated?

Do they wish to exert themselves for another? It seems to me that such a proceeding would differ very much from the offer of the English Government. Mr. Zangwill appears to be of the opinion that the English Government ought to be asked to modify its offer. The Government, however, has full knowledge of the report on the territory it offered; all the circumstances are known to it; the conditions it sought to relieve have not been altered. If the Government wishes to modify its offer, it may do so, and I am convinced that we should meet such a modified offer with our respectful thanks; even if we ourselves cannot act then, we shall take every means at our disposal that does not contradict the Basle Programme and is in accord with the resolutions of the Congress, so that such an offer may receive sufficient consideration. I even believe that not even Mr. Ussischkin would be against it. (Hear, hear.)

It is, however, quite another thing to seek after a territory outside Palestine or its neighbourhood. On this point I agree entirely with Dr. Herzl; he never wished to ask for any territory outside Palestine or its neighbourhood, and he never did so. We asked for the settlement in El Arish; we did not ask for East Africa. I have said elsewhere that with the loss of East Africa the circumstances of the Jewish people would require some other settlement before we can found our nation anew in Palestine. (Applause.) I believe this still to-day, although of course I hope that I am mistaken. If, however, this settlement is to lie outside Palestine or its immediate vicinity, then I say that we are not to obtain it by asking, but through the compelling circumstances of the Jewish question. For us Zionists — for all who adhere to the Basle Programme — our policy with regard to this subject is clear. We wish to found for the Jewish people a legally secured, publicly recognised home in Palestine. We want nothing less and we want nothing else. (Applause.)

Mr. Ussischkin is of the opinion that the Seventh Congress has left our movement where it was before the Sixth Congress. I hope that he is right, for within the limits of the Basle Programme there is room on our platform for all parties and all counsels, and no attempt must be made, by a narrow-minded interpretation of that programme, to thrust back opinions which do not enjoy the favour of the majority. If on the one hand our programme excludes those who exclude Zion, can it on the other hand include those who do not include a policy for Palestine? We do not wish our movement to fall back into Chowewe-Zionism, into the huckstering policy of buying land in Palestine without first having acquired rights there as Jews, or the smuggling of Jews into Palestine without taking steps to prevent them and their children from simply becoming Palestinians. Into the details of our work in the near future I cannot enter here, nor do I feel myself entitled to do so. You know the resolution which forms an outline of our work. It is evident, however, that our first great aim is to strengthen our organisation and to consolidate our ranks. For we have active enemies, common enemies, to combat, whatever our political views may be. No one