No. 36 — "Die Welt" — Page 5
(continued from page 4)
…Russian questions express our views in company with the Progressives, or whether we take up a position on particular Jewish questions. It would be a political error to seek to answer the question whether the Jews should take part in the elections to the Duma solely with regard to the tactics that the Progressives might adopt. Even if these should resolve to put forward no candidates, it does not follow that the Jews must act likewise. On the contrary, the fewer progressive deputies there are in the Imperial Duma, the more must the Jews be intent upon securing a representation in it. For the Jewish question will after all come up for debate in the Duma, and even without any poetic fancy one may already picture to oneself the speeches that will be delivered there about the Jews from certain quarters, and which will decidedly call for a rebuttal. We do not give ourselves up to false hopes that the few Jews who will sit in the Imperial Duma will be able to convince the antisemites; nor do we believe that, if the Duma does not at once improve the condition of the Jews, there would be no further hope of improvement; but we do believe that in the Imperial Duma, besides antisemites, there will be no lack of such elements as do not know the Jews, and these would perhaps have occasion for the first time in their lives to hear of the want of rights and the wrongs under which we have suffered so long. Even if we had nothing to hope for from the Duma, as one of the bureaucratic institutions, it is of great importance that someone from our midst should bring to a reading the historic bill of indictment which is to make known to the public the conduct of the bureaucracy towards the Jews.
Among the first questions to come up for debate in the Imperial Duma will probably be, as is supposed, the Jewish question. To the Jewish deputies, if any are elected at all, will therefore fall the task of standing up for the equal rights of the Jews and for the repeal of the oppressive exceptional laws. In this anticipation the "Hazefirah" discusses the exceptional laws against the Jews, of which there are said to be four categories: 1. laws that restrict the right of residence of the Jews; 2. such as exclude them from attendance at school; 3. laws concerning their non-admission to public offices; 4. laws relating to military service.
As regards the restriction of the right of residence, the author of the article hopes that the Jewish deputies would meet with no resistance whatever on the part of the other deputies; at the dawn of a new era these would simply be ashamed to oppose so just a demand as the repeal of the prohibition of settlement, all the more since this prohibition rests upon false premises, upon prejudices such as that of the Empress Elizabeth, the daughter of Peter, who rejected a representation of the Senate that the Jews be granted free right of residence, since they brought benefit to the country, with the words: "From the enemies of Christians I desire to have no benefit!" This prejudice, moreover, has been combated many times. Besides, the right to dwell is no special privilege, but the natural right of every human being, which may be withdrawn only from dangerous criminals. Should antisemitic deputies nevertheless oppose this view, one might hope that they will remain in the minority. The majority will probably perceive the disadvantages of these restrictions, as many landowners have long since recognised, often expressing the wish that the Jews might be given permission to settle among them. Often, indeed, the bureaucracy itself, as can be shown from official documents, has made representations to the Government, in the interest of trade and industry, for the repeal of the prohibition of residence in certain districts.
It is likewise to be hoped that the question of Jewish education will meet with no serious resistance. It is out of the question that the Russian people should not have been brought by the Japanese war to the conviction of how high a value the education and intelligence of a people possess. Eighty years ago, after all, the Government itself conducted the education of the Jews by compulsory means, and for decades, until the notorious decree of June 6, 1887, promoted with ample means the school attendance of Jewish youth. The demand of the Jewish deputies that Jews be admitted to the schools without restriction will therefore probably be favourably settled, if they advocate this demand with circumspection and energy.
The matter stands otherwise with regard to admission to public offices; here the Jews would meet with violent resistance. It is well known that even with regard to the office of a Zemstvo delegate, which is moreover an insignificant public office, the ordinance of June 12, 1890, forbids the Jews to take part, actively or passively, in the assemblies of the Zemstvos. The reason given was: according to the reports of the Minister of the Interior, the Jews exercised a pernicious influence upon the administration of public affairs in the towns, being intent only on their own advantage, and the like. These representations, it is true, were given the lie by facts. The hereditary honorary citizen M. Rosenstein had been for twenty-five years a member of the Zemstvos in the district of Simferopol; and when the said law compelled him to resign his office, the Zemstvo resolved unanimously to express to him its thanks for his faithful, self-sacrificing and unselfish work.
It has also frequently occurred that the municipal administrative bodies petitioned the Government to grant the franchise to the Jews. These, surely, would be the strongest proofs against the antisemitic accusations. And yet one must prepare in good time all the evidence bearing upon it for the struggle, which will certainly be a very hard one.
Harder still for the Jewish representatives will probably be the struggle against the prejudices concerning military service. Here there are a host of greater duties and lesser rights. In addition, the view prevails generally that the Jews evade military service. It will now be the business of the Jewish representatives to collect facts and, armed with the experiences of reality, to enter the struggle where it will be needful to refute and repel the grave accusations. B.
Holiday Mood.
In a few weeks our holy days will be here, and from many pulpits of Jewish houses of worship proud words will rush over agreeably flattered congregations. The most highly taxed, the middling and the very small Jews will hear from learned gentlemen in gown and bands the assurance and the proof that their business and dealings on earth and in the land serve a sublime mission. They will hear that they do not, like their otherwise highly honoured fellow-citizens of other confessions, toil and drudge merely to win their daily bread for themselves and their families and to be good, upright, honest and decent withal — but that, in doing all this, they have quite incidentally the further task, as confessors of a sublime doctrine, as bearers of an immortal ideal, of being teachers of the nations.
One knows the beautiful song, the most beautiful that has ever been sung to a people. One knows, too, when and how the song arose and whence its authors drew their text. For its content they found points of support in a few passages of the Prophets; in particular the opening verses of the second caput of Isaiah have been distinguished by countless musical settings. The time of the song's origin coincides with the emergence of a new method of regarding Judaism merely as religion and ethics and of abstracting from its national content. That this is so could, if the historical connection were not in any case obvious, be inferred by anyone with a fine ear: the