Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 38 · 22 September 1905
11printed page
scan 11 of 20

No. 38. — "Die Welt" — Page 11.

(continued from page 10)

…were no Jews. Mr. Greenberg said from the tribune that one must not examine a victory too closely, for even the victories of history would come off very badly were we to view them through the ethical microscope. That may be true with regard to history in general, but how may we hold such lax views when it is a question of Zion, Zion from which righteousness is to shine forth? When I once said that we needed "money, muscle and morality," I was attacked and corrected: "morality, muscle and money," for "morality must come first." It is my most earnest wish that those who preach such things would also govern themselves accordingly.

The indignation which the minority had felt in the face of all these illegalities, which you have no doubt exaggerated, will serve as an excuse for their occasional want of restraint. But the chief blame for all that happened at daybreak on Sunday — for only at 3 o'clock in the morning did things occur such as do not usually happen in parliaments — falls upon the A.-C. of that time, which pasted together an extraordinary Congress in the middle of the Congress. As I had always been opposed to the idea of a special session, I was glad to hear that Dr. Nordau was of the same opinion, inasmuch as in his opening address he described the extraordinary Congress as a "completely mistaken interpretation of the wording and sense of a resolution of the Sixth Congress." But if there is a misunderstanding here, it was at any rate an intentional one. The East Africa project, the keynote of the whole Congress, the question which for two years had ceaselessly stirred men's minds, was degraded into a kind of side-issue. But the farce of a separate Congress was so great that the A.-C. had overlooked providing the extraordinary Congress with an extraordinary President. What, indeed, was this foolish manoeuvre meant to achieve? To show that it did not form the most important part of our proceedings, nay, that it did not belong to the Congress at all and had to be lodged in the back room like a poor relation. How childish! As though it were possible for Noah, in conveying the animals into the Ark, to overlook the elephant and pay attention only to the flies and frogs. And while the flies and the frogs claimed the great Congress for themselves, the elephant was allotted only a little Congress, only one day, a Friday, which was naturally curtailed by the Sabbath. The poor East Africa beast could not even move. The debates therefore naturally had to be continued on Sabbath evening and Sunday morning. As the sitting drew towards its end, towards 3 o'clock in the morning, I requested Dr. Marmorek, who was then in the chair, to dissolve the sitting without bringing any resolutions to the vote at that late hour. We are not English Members of Parliament, and night sittings are too exciting for us. Dr. Marmorek consented. Unfortunately, however, the debates were followed by the report of the Credentials Committee, which admitted cases of illegality and negligence, whereby such chaos had arisen that Mr. Marmorek could not possibly declare to the assembly that the sitting was in fact adjourned. What then took place happened in reality after the suspension of the sitting. It was, moreover, of a wholly harmless nature, nothing but clapping of hands and the singing of Russian songs. What was unbecoming was the conduct of the Territorialist guests in the gallery, who let rain down a flood of leaflets complaining of the manner of the Russian elections. They had admission to the Congress through its courtesy and had no right to take part in its proceedings in any way whatsoever. The scene was nevertheless most imposing — the great hall densely filled at that late hour, the gallery a surging sea of excited faces, and the air full of white fluttering papers and thrilling with the sound of Russian songs. Acts of violence, however, such as were reported by some journalists, existed only in their brains.

One sensational scene, however, is true, a scene which took place on the following day and in which I am personally involved; I mean the scene when I accused the President of the Congress of treason to the Jewish people. You will surely ask me how I, after the counsel I had given the Territorialists, could let myself be led into such an offence against all parliamentary decorum. But there are things which stand higher than any parliamentary etiquette; the fate of the Jewish people is more important than the dignity and the unity of the Congress. I have very often been violently attacked for this conduct of mine, and some of my English colleagues at the Congress hastened to express to Dr. Nordau their regret at this "unjustified and unspeakable insult." In order to defend myself and to show that this accusation was not so unjustified and unspeakable, I am compelled to reveal something which will indeed no longer remain a secret now, since it will be published in the Protocol of the Congress, but which has hitherto been unknown to the public. My resolution to accept a territory in East Africa was to have been seconded by Dr. Nordau; the signature of the President of the Congress is to be found on the formal resolution handed in to the Presidium, close beside my own. I had not even dared to hope for such support on the part of this great Zionist personality, although Dr. Nordau had at the Sixth Congress so powerfully championed the idea of a "night shelter." I felt that, in his state of health, he had already made a great sacrifice in appearing at the Congress at all. When, however, on the opening day of the Congress, I told him that I intended to bring in a resolution on the morrow to the effect that we accept the offer of England, but request of her a land large and fertile enough for our emigrants, Dr. Nordau at once offered to second this resolution. It was madness, he added, to reject the offer of England, and he would never consent to it. I was naturally beside myself with joy and begged him to tell no one that he was supporting me. My intention I had proclaimed openly and loudly, so that our opponents might have the opportunity of preparing their objections to it; but that the President of the Congress too was on my side would naturally, I told him, strike like a thunderbolt. His speech, even if it did not quite turn the scale in our favour, would at least prepare the ground for a victory at a future Congress, and perhaps even prevent the alteration of the Bank's statutes, so that this institution might not be paralysed in its activity. When the extraordinary Congress was opened and the time drew near for me to bring forward my resolution, to my astonishment Dr. Nordau and almost all the others who were on the platform, and who were in a state of terrible agitation, began to press me to desist. They declared to me that I stood before a wild majority, and that if I persisted, it would be impossible to take the responsibility for the consequences — riots might break out, acts of violence, and even revolver-shots. I replied