Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 51 · 22 December 1905
7printed page
scan 7 of 20

No. 51. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 7.

(continued from page 6)


…fore are the gentlemen, otherwise so over-optimistic, so pessimistic? Who, pray, speaks of an emigration of all five to six millions of Russian Jews? We Zionists, perhaps? Must one really, in the tenth year of Zionism, still wrestle with this sham argument, which reaches the summit of folly in the question a thousand times flung at us by the wiseacres: whether we believe that a Rothschild would go to Palestine?

No, we do not believe it. We believe Rothschild will remain in London, where, as a truly distinguished Jew, he is an honour to his kinsmen. We believe he will remain in London, but not with his former Jewish policy; rather, sooner or later, he will let himself be converted by us, by the facts, and by Mr. Chamberlain, who also understands something of colonial matters and has found Herzl's plans practicable. Rothschild and his associates, however, hold that this can be attained only in the distant future, whereas help must be given now, quickly and without delay. Agreed! We will make the gentlemen a proposal of mediation. We shall help Rothschild in his philanthropic work for the present. Let Rothschild in return help us in our political work for the future. Jedua.

*

In a letter to the "Times" Dr. Nordau criticises the "Appeal" signed by Lord Rothschild and his associates, which we have made the subject of our consideration in the above article, and says among other things: "The Zionists have never forgotten that Palestine, that is, the country west of the Jordan, is not large enough to receive all the Jews who wish to return to the land of their fathers. We have always included in our scheme of colonisation the Sinai Peninsula, the plain of Pelusium, the Hauran district and the Euphrates valley, all of them territories now unoccupied. These territories, however, sufficiently irrigated and furnished with means of communication, can offer some 200 million people opportunity for work and livelihood ... We protest energetically against the insinuation that we have the open or concealed intention of founding a Jewish State in Palestine. We have always met the Sultan frankly, and he knows that we have never thought of any restriction of his sovereign rights. We need nothing more than local autonomy, permitting an undisturbed unfolding of all our economic and moral forces. . . . The signatories of the 'Appeal' place their sole hope in charity. But in the face of the demands of the situation this is absolutely insufficient. . . ."

The Situation in Russia.

The characteristic features of the revolution now taking place in Russia are — its elemental force and its lack of organisation. The social factors that have come to their development, and could no longer adapt themselves to the old social order, have declared war upon the latter and now strive to create new forms better suited to their interests and to their new outlook on life. The contending forces, however, are very unequal. On one side stand the representatives of the old régime, with its time-honoured organisation and its menacing armed power; on the other — the unarmed, unorganised mass, which is moreover split into categories and parties, each of which pursues its own, often mutually contradictory interests. That is precisely why society is not in a position to march straight towards the goal it has set itself; it is not in a position to fight decisive battles so as to wrest power by force from the hands of those who hold it; indeed, it is not even in a position to wage a party war, and merely gives expression to its discontent in various ways. Individual social groups, reduced to beggary by the preceding governments, proceed with elemental violence not against the representatives of power but against the neighbouring groups, which in most cases are just as much opponents of the old order as they. What is accomplished by some parties with elemental violence and unconsciously is carried out by other parties according to a plan long since worked out. All the steps of the revolutionaries are directed not immediately against the government, but against society, and only then, through society, against the government. The struggle is waged not against a particular government, but against government in general, that is to say against the principle of order and authority, which is at present upheld by the reactionary government by antiquated and unfit means. Since the revolutionary and oppositional elements are not in a position to wrest from the reactionary government the power from which it is not inclined to part voluntarily, nothing remains for the discontented parties but to weaken the government and bring it to complete decay; but since the government, as a group of individual persons, stands beyond the reach of the revolutionary elements' resistance, nothing remains but to spoil the machinery of government, which in itself is indispensable in every form of society, but which in the given case is in clumsy hands that turn it against society itself. The destruction of estates and the carrying-off of grain, the felling of State forests, the disordering of the finances and the like do not injure the government directly, but destroy above all the whole social order and weaken the authority of law and of power in general. An army torn out of its order is a danger to every society, even to the most democratic; but since we cannot tear the army out of the hands of the present government, we destroy it, and sympathise with such occurrences as those of Kronstadt, Vladivostok and the Black Sea. The political strike destroys above all the economic condition of the country and does enormous damage to the State treasury. Yet the Russian revolution has no other way out.

We Jews can expect great reforms of our life, and a complete liberation from the exceptional laws that so deeply shame and destroy us, only from the revolution. The revolution alone is able to break with the old order and to establish the order of society on entirely new principles. Various economic and national parties take part in the process of the decay and rebirth of society, and each of them strives to occupy in the society of the future that position which best corresponds to its interests. Given the great number and diversity of these parties, with their crossing and mutually contradictory interests, even such small units as the Jewish people gain importance, and if we know how to come forward in good time, to unite in good time and to act in good time, we shall be able to hope for a maximum of satisfaction of our wishes. The greater the exertion, the stronger the revolutionary energy, the more chances for the under-