Die Welt · Vol. IX, Separate Edition 4 · 1 August 1905
8printed page
scan 8 of 16

Page 8 — "Die Welt" — Separate Edition No. 4

Fifth Day of Proceedings. (Morning Sitting.)

Report of the Palestine Commission

presented by Prof. Dr. Warburg.

As is known, on the motion of the German Landsmannschaft a Palestine Commission was set up at the VI. Congress, consisting of 3 experts, whose purpose was laid down in five paragraphs. Besides the establishment of an agricultural and technical experimental station, as well as of an agricultural and technical information bureau, a medical research station and the publication of a journal for the study of Palestine, the chief purpose laid down in § 1 was: the scientific and practical investigation of Palestine and of the countries coming into consideration for it, in economic, technical, legal and geographical respects.

As regards the organisation of the Commission, the most important provision was that it should carry out its tasks independently and report to the A. C., and further that it should be called in with a consultative voice to the deliberation and decision upon matters of the P. C. in the A. C. and at the annual conferences. Of importance also is the resolution that the Commission should receive for 2 years a budget of at least 15,000 Fr. annually, as soon as the indispensable current expenses are covered, but not before the shekel receipts suffice to cover the indispensable current requirements.

That considerable funds are needed, not only for the establishment of the various institutes and for the publication of a journal for the study of Palestine, whose self-support is all but out of the question for the foreseeable future, but also for the scientific and practical investigation of Palestine, etc., is obvious. For a study of books about Palestine cannot possibly provide the foundations for the economic inquiries which we require. We need exact investigations of the country in its geological, agronomical and meteorological aspects; we ought to study the conditions of sale in Palestine and the needs of the population there; we must find out the best markets for Palestinian products and become acquainted with the business usages customary there, in order to adapt the preparation of the harvest and the manner of shipment to the requirements of the individual markets; we wish to study the various products imported into Palestine with a view to whether they might not be produced there itself in a manner able to compete — all things which one can learn only by travel, by study on the spot, by conferences with people engaged in practical life, and above all by trials and experiments, but not at the writing-desk at home.

Thus in the year 1904 a member went over in order to make the necessary investigations into various burning questions in Palestine and the neighbouring countries, and in other respects too the Commission always remained in the most active connection with Palestine, founded meteorological stations there, and also occupied itself with the initiation of the great organisations demanded in our programme.

The activity of the Palestine Commission in Europe consisted essentially in studying a number of the suggestions supplied to us from Palestine, in initiating some new organisations and expeditions for the practical opening-up of Palestine, in studying the products, minerals, vegetable matter, etc., received from there, and in exercising a stimulating influence through lectures, the publication of a journal and the assembling of a small Palestine library. We hope that we have succeeded — particularly also through the fact that many of the articles in our journal were reprinted in Zionist papers — in substantially spreading knowledge of the real economic and colonising conditions of Palestine and of its neighbouring territories.

Dr. Soskin will presently give you a detailed picture of our labours; I should only like to remark here that the Palestine Commission was in a position to carry to completion only a part of the investigations and undertakings begun in these 2 years. In great part, it is true, this lay in the nature of the case, since these were protracted labours; in part, however, it was also a consequence of the financial position of the Commission, since it unfortunately received in the two years only two-fifths of the sum granted as a minimum, the shekel moneys, which came in exceedingly sparsely until the last month, scarcely sufficing to cover the indispensable current requirements of the Actions Committee, so that nothing remained over for the Palestine Commission.

Paralysing as the financial uncertainty of the Palestine Commission was in its effect upon its activity, it nevertheless worked on, in the expectation, now also fulfilled, that through the Congress the shekel moneys would flow more abundantly again. To our regret, it is true, the work had to be restricted, and much that was really important was not taken in hand, whereby we managed to make do with only three-quarters of the minimum sum set aside for our labours.

That this is no healthy state of affairs needs no proof; it would be exceedingly desirable if a mode could be found which would make the labours of the Commission independent of the accidental receipt of the shekel moneys. Let us hope either that the Congress will discover such a means, or at least that in future the shekel moneys will flow so superabundantly that a reservoir may be filled with them, from which the Palestine Commission may receive for its labours an inflow which, if modest, is yet secure. (Applause.)


Report on the Activity of the Commission for the Exploration of Palestine

presented by Dr. S. Soskin.

Ladies and gentlemen! Most honoured assembly!

Now that Professor Warburg in his introductory words has expressed himself in general upon the principles which underlie the activity of our Commission, I shall permit myself in what follows to lay before you a detailed report on the work of the Commission for the period from the last Congress up to the present.

Although we were appointed as a Commission for the Exploration of Palestine, the work itself nevertheless showed that theoretical exploratory work alone, without regard to the economic needs of the country, was impossible. The scientific labours which our Commission undertook had therefore for the most part an economic motive and basis.

After these introductory remarks I permit myself to enter upon the work of the Commission itself,