Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 30 · 27 July 1906
18printed page
scan 16 of 20

"Die Welt" — No. 30 — 18

London. On the occasion of the anniversary of Herzl's death a great public meeting was held last week in the Wonderland Hall by the united Shares Clubs in conjunction with the English Zionist Federation, over which Mr. Joseph Cowen presided. M. Cowen opened the evening with a short address. "We have assembled," he said among other things, "to commemorate the anniversary of Herzl's death. Perhaps it would be more correct if we said that we are here together to honour Herzl's life by our remembrance." Herzl's influence in life had been immense. But he hoped that his influence after his death would be no less. In his further remarks he spoke of the honourable memory in which all Jews today kept the name of Herzl.

Herr David Wolffsohn, who was very warmly greeted, moved a resolution in which the meeting, in memory of Theodor Herzl, expresses its indelible gratitude for the services he rendered to the Jewish people, and gives expression to the feeling of deep sorrow that it had not been granted to Theodor Herzl, who was snatched away in the prime of his life, to complete the great work which he had so successfully begun. "Two years ago," he said among other things, "when we buried our Herzl in the Döbling cemetery, we swore an oath, the oath that every Jew knows: "If I forget thee, O Jerusalem, may my right hand wither!" This vow was a comfort to us in our great sorrow, for it gave us hope and courage. If we strive to make this vow a reality, we shall be able to fulfil Herzl's last wish, the only one he laid upon us: to bring his bones to Palestine, to the land in which the confidence and the future of our people lie. Yes, we must often repeat this oath to ourselves, often raise our hands to confirm it solemnly. Ever think of it, ever work to fulfil it. If we do not rest, if we give up everything for our cause, then we shall be able to bring to Palestine not only the mortal remains of Herzl, no, but also all that was immortal in him, — his spirit, his ideals will go before us, as once the pillar of fire before our forefathers. What should I tell you of Herzl, the speaker continued? Shall I speak to you of Herzl the poet, the artist, of his rich gifts! You know him well enough. But better still you know Herzl the Jew. Herzl was not only the first Jewish politician, he was also the first successful Jewish politician, who created much, achieved much. . . " Passing on to the present time, the speaker said: "I would not remind you of the terrible streams of blood which we have seen flow. But this I would remind you of, that Herzl showed us the way by which we can come out of this sea of blood. . . No, Herzl is not dead; we must take up the great inheritance he left us, we must continue his work, enlarge it, enrich it, fulfil it. There is no way back for us, — only forward and straight on to the goal! (Applause). — One evening after a hard day's work — it was in London — I was speaking with Theodor Herzl about the progress of Zionism. Herzl said to me the prophetic words: "I shall not be with you much longer; I shall not lead you farther." No, I replied, he must not leave us, he stood only at the beginning of the work. And thereupon I received an answer which I will not withhold from you. "That is not how matters stand. The movement is founded; we have our organization, our Congress, our Bank. It is not I whom you now need to accomplish the work; no, everything rests with your will. You yourselves must summon up the will for the work. And so, ladies and gentlemen, it shall be, now that Herzl has left us. Not one may stand aside, not one be idle. All must help, all work, hand in hand. . . There are many roads that lead to Palestine. This evening is consecrated to Herzl, and of Herzl alone will I speak. So let me add one word more. If we earnestly and in truth wish to bring to completion the work that he began, it can be done only by our keeping ever before our eyes that he wished his bones to rest in the land after which his soul so greatly longed — in Palestine. (Lively applause).

After Herr Wolffsohn, Mr. Zangwill spoke; greeted with applause, he said: "The resolution which Herr Wolffsohn has proposed is of such a kind that I can agree with it, although it was in this very hall that, after my return from the last Zionist Congress, I subjected what happened there to criticism." But Herzl, the speaker went on, was a name which they both honoured and which brought them both together on this occasion. Many people were now saying what a wonderfully great and noble man Herzl had been. A person of consequence in the London Jewish community had lately remarked to him what a great loss Herzl's death was, after all. Mr. Zangwill had answered: Oh yes, but you helped to kill him, for you did not join his movement. But besides these there had been others who had contributed to Herzl's death. He preferred, however, to speak of those who had helped Herzl to live. The speaker then devoted warm words to the personal relations of the Chairman, Mr. Cowen, with Herzl, and continued: He could not resist the thought that some of their own Zionist friends, too, had helped to hasten Herzl's death. He recalled the scene at the Sixth Congress, where Herzl, at one o'clock in the morning, after a session that had lasted the whole day, stood on the platform and spoke to a howling crowd that shouted "Traitor!" at him, and how Herzl tried to convince the crowd that he was working for the welfare of the Jewish people. It was a great crime of the Jewish people not to trust the leader, not to leave him time to carry anything through completely. The policy of a leader must always be diplomatic, and he must have a free hand. . . . Herr Wolffsohn and he represented different ideas, but a great man leaves behind him not one but often several schools of followers, because the one school understands one part, the other another part, and both declare that their school teaches what the Master would have required. A great Jew had said that a man cannot serve two masters, but a master could have two servants. Dr. Herzl had two such disciples, Herr Wolffsohn and himself, who were both doing their best to carry out the great ideas which Herzl had brought into Jewish life. However much one had heard of the differences between him and Herr Wolffsohn, they were nevertheless both at one in this, that the Jewish problem must receive not a philanthropic but a political treatment, and that this could be done only through a great plan of colonization. . . . . . Herr Zangwill then dwelt at length on the present situation of the Jews, which made the founding of a commonwealth necessary. He closed with the following words: "Herzl came to raise up the dignity of the Jewish people, wherever it may be. He came to awaken the Jews with the sound of the trumpet, to awaken them in order to make them a free people. And therefore one should always, at the anniversary of his death, remember this sound of the trumpet and keep it in memory. (Lively applause).

Thereupon Mr. Greenberg spoke. He wished on this evening once more, if it were at all necessary, to bear witness to his fidelity to the principles of Dr. Herzl. The chief principle which Herzl had served above all was the principle of the unity and union of the Jewish people. Mr. Greenberg had endeavoured to further this principle when he moved among his colleagues in the A. C. that the Brussels Conference be convened. What was the result? Almost all without exception who had been invited to join the common organization had endeavoured to seek reasons, not for joining, but for refusing to join. A man learned in the law, the head of a Jewish organization, had discovered an old paragraph according to which joining was impossible for his organization. Another, the President of the Board of Deputies, found a stumbling-block in the fact that the travelling expenses of the delegate to Brussels would have to be paid. (Cries of indignation.) What could one expect of such men?. . . If anything could have further strengthened him in coming to today's meeting, it was the fact that Mr. Zangwill, too, was here today. He welcomed the opportunity of showing the world that, however much he and Mr. Zangwill might differ, every personal element was nevertheless excluded — and he wished that persons in other camps, too, might profit by this lesson. He had appeared on this platform together with Mr. Zangwill, not because the Zionists had changed their principles, but because they hoped that, in consequence of circumstances, they were now in a position to change their practice, and that they would find means to work together instead of seeking occasions for strife. That did not mean that the Zionists had given up one iota of their conviction; it meant only that they hoped to find a common platform, common means which would enable them to work shoulder to shoulder for the cause of the oppressed people. (Applause.)

Several more speakers spoke, whereupon the resolution was adopted with enthusiastic applause.

The meeting had a small unpleasant prelude. A number of Zionists were refused admission by a Territorialist steward to the memorial celebration arranged by Zionists. (!) Only the intervention of members of the Zionist leadership put an end to this quite singular scene.