Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 38 · 19 September 1906
3scan
of 20

No. 38 — "Die Welt" — 5.

(continued from page 4)

…does one rack one's brains to count the victims and to reckon up the havoc wrought. It eludes all reckoning.

And yet another weary muse hobbles pitifully behind: historiosophy. She subtly devises some reason or other, but scarcely has she entrenched herself behind a motive when new facts break in and tear her from her tranquil contemplation. In a sober, barren speculation poor in imagination she ties the eternal misery to passing conditions and persons. She has laid down the dogma: in Podolia it is possible, in Lithuania, on the other hand, never. Now Bjelostok appears upon the stage, — and she is out of joint. Darkly admonishing, Bjelostok knocked hard at the gates of Poland, but she does not let herself be put out of countenance. Beside Poland, perhaps, but in Poland — never! — says the dreamer, lost in herself. And now she feels, disturbingly, the contradiction of the facts. With a secret co-operation of the military she could already come to terms, but surely no army can carry out a mass murder openly, — she told herself. But she is quickly taught better. So it is solely and entirely the official reaction, — runs her last verdict, when suddenly the calamity of a pogrom carried out by peasants breaks over the Jews in the South. She is always perceiving something new, because she has become estranged from the historical-Jewish way of seeing. At last, out of humour and disappointed, she turns her back upon the confused phenomena.

That she cannot collect herself into one thought, — that is the tragic thing. It is the evil, destructive, fatal thing in Jewish thinking: the principle of belittlement, the formula-mongering of invented pretexts, the revelling in theories which delights in serving many strange gods where in truth one fundamental motive rules: the Goluth! Only to the sense of general political speculation, turned away from the Jews, which has lost the intimate, the specific, is it congenial to inflate the accidental and to dub peculiar occurrences of the Jewish misery with political terms. The Jewish observer of historical feeling does not let himself be misled by this. He always sets the great question-mark against the general diagnosis; he confronts the current fashionable phrases in a mood that doubts everything. There may be something true behind them, too, but it is not the truth, the essential. The truth is not in the cask of the Danaids, in the wheel of Sisyphus, in the hunger of Tantalus, which are only the consequences of one fundamental cause, — the truth is in the existence on air, in the disinheritedness, in the impotence of the Jewish people, in the horrifying degenerations and excrescences, in the rotten ruins, in the impossibility of security and in the possibility of being lashed by all the winds, of being so crushed and annihilated by all the world's convulsions, as the latest experiences of our people have shown with a terrible vividness.

It is not a Russian question, but a Jewish one. Half — and in point of significance, the parent stock — of the Jewish people is given over to the caprice of murderers and robbers. No one hinders the drunken, raging riff-raff, the fellows of every sort who want to fish in troubled waters, the reckless bands of rabble who are bent on plunder unpunished. — No one hinders an organized army, which ought surely to be subject to the international laws of war, from cutting down the defenceless, from bombarding and setting fire to towns and plundering private houses. A hunt par force upon millions of human beings, such as has never yet occurred in the bloodiest times of savage barbarism, is played out before the eyes of an indifferent world, and no hand stirs and no cry of horror rings out! With a heroic stroke reaching towards the colossal, a force of this anguish-worn people, hounded to death, had roused itself against gangs of rogues: there arose an armed power worthy of respect, naturally not regularly organized and armed, but still so grouped and led that the wildest excesses of the mob could be warded off, were the military to remain neutral; with enthusiasm and fiery zeal the Jewish youth took up this sacred idea, — and now this noble band is not only violated and enslaved, but threatened with the headsman's axe for the self-defence it intended.

Black fly the banners of murder; nameless misery is brought upon countless communities; every day heralds a storm; the slightest accident — a provocative shot, a scrap of paper found, on which reproach, rancour and bitterness give vent to themselves, a word, nay, a grimace — is enough to conjure up Furies. Hundreds of thousands of human beings, who do not know where they are to sleep for the night, people robbed of bread and of home, wander about the world, — and we look on powerless. Men put themselves off with the excuse: these are consequences of the revolution. And what was there 25 years ago, and what — 50 years ago, and what will there be 10 years hence? And why then should the Jews bear the costs of the Russian revolution? Does this revolution not cost heavy sacrifices enough? And is all this really only the result of chance, of external circumstances, and would the Jews not be ground down by some other force too? Is all this not an outside without a kernel, and is the kernel not the woeful Goluth?

Is it possible that such fateful experiences should leave the soul of a feeling people untouched? Together with all the others we hasten up with meagre help, together with all the others we hurl the thunderbolt of protests into the unmoved world, and eke out this day-labourer's existence and do what the moment demands; but apart from the rough path of this fragmented practice, which is forced upon us by the excitements and experiences of the moment, there opens to us, in the appraisal of events, a wider horizon of historical-national vision, the only horizon in which these events can be set in their full extent in the right light, rightly grasped and felt. To this knowledge the soul of the people must struggle through.

N. Sokolow. To be concluded.