No. 50. — "Die Welt" — Page 9.
(continued from page 8)
…ism has laid. By uncovering the fact that Jewish labour is being displaced in the Golus, it showed the proletariat the way to Zionism. We Zionists of the earlier schools, who do not stand upon the exclusively materialist standpoint, who see the thousand threads binding the people to its historic home, who value the cultural treasures of the people, had soon to draw a line between ourselves and the proletarian Zionists. Many went away from us, but they will come to us. From Zionism they came, to Zionism they will return. And the attitude to be taken towards this group, too, is one of the tasks of this Conference.
The Russian Revolution has brought forth yet another important question. It has radically altered our relation to "work in the present" in the Diaspora. The time when work in the present was for us a work not organically connected with our programme, when abstention from questions of internal politics could be our principle, is past. Russia, with its many peoples, now stands before the supremely important and complicated question of creating the conditions for the peaceful living together of its various peoples. It is an enormously difficult task, especially for us, the only people in Russia that will in every case always form a minority. But even for us one thing is beyond doubt: the hour approaches when the Russian Jews will be freed from their fetters and will heal their wounds themselves. And of wounds there are very many. Our national "economy" is in the most wretched state imaginable. We must take our destiny into our own hands. And for that we need civil rights and national rights on the one hand, and an organisation on the other. For us Zionists of Russia this political activity, which is showing its first rays in Austria and in Germany as well, will be of particular importance, for it will give work to many among us who find no sufficient field of activity within our own framework. There will also arise the supremely important question of organisation, which has hitherto been the weak side of our party. These are the questions which the Conference has to solve; this is the development through which Zionism has passed. It has become complicated. Its tasks have become more numerous. Life has destroyed much, but it has given us an unshakeable basis. Let us try at this Conference to lay one more stone towards the strengthening of our edifice.
The Presidium proposes to elect an Auditing Commission and a Credentials Commission, and also a Commission for the preparation of the resolutions to be laid before the Conference. To this last Commission were elected, among others, Messrs. Dr. Pasmanik, Aleinikow, Sprinzak and Itzkowitsch.
The floor is given to W. Schabotinsky, who greets the Conference in the name of the Odessa Palestine Committee. He said: "The Committee which has empowered me sends the Conference its greeting. The Committee, one of the oldest standard-bearers of the national idea, of the love of Palestine, associates itself with political Zionism. Untrue and invented are the rumours that it wishes to supplant the Zionist Organisation. It is only an organ of Zionism and does not forget the place that is its due, and its happiest moment will be the one that lets it recognise in the Congress its centre, its leader."
Further, the numerous telegrams of greeting that had come in are read, whereupon Mr. B. Goldberg, in the name of the C. B. of the Russian Zionists, reported upon its activity, expressly emphasising that this report contained no survey of the position of Zionism in Russia, since that had not yet been sufficiently investigated.
Report of the Central Bureau of the Zionist Organisation in Russia
At the opening of its report to the Third All-Russian Zionist Conference for the period from October 1905 to October 1906, the Central Bureau considers it its duty to point out that the activity of the Bureau is to be regarded separately from that of the general Zionist Organisation. Despite the mutual relations existing between the two, we are far from placing the meritorious achievements of the societies and of individual party comrades to our own account, but at the same time we believe we must also decline responsibility for the shortcomings in the activity of the societies and of individual persons. Since, for reasons to be stated later, we are not in a position to lay before you a complete report on the state of the Zionist movement in Russia, we shall deal only with the activity of the Central Bureau proper. This quite peculiar institution was called into being by the College of the Russian members of the Greater A. C. The College, namely, at its sitting of the 2nd–3rd of August 1905 at Basle, resolved as follows: 1. To transfer the Financial Centre from Kieff to Vilna and to entrust its administration to Mr. J. Goldberg. 2. To found in Vilna a Bureau, consisting of Dr. Schw. Lewin, J. Goldberg, S. Rosenbaum (Minsk) and B. Jaffe (Grodno) and a salaried secretary, it being made the duty of Messrs. Dr. Schw. Lewin, Dr. E. Tschlenow (Moscow) and the other members of the Bureau to compose monthly circulars of an informative and agitational character for the societies, to publish proclamations, etc. The Warsaw Committee was charged with composing the circulars in the Polish language for Poland. 3. To transfer to Mr. B. Jaffe at Grodno the direction of the Information Bureau for the District Leaders.
If one now leaves aside the short-lived National Committee, which was founded in its day at the Sixth Congress and consisted of Messrs. Kohan-Bernstein, Temkin, Ussischkin, Jakobson and Sapir, the Central Bureau is an entirely new institution, which was created under very unfavourable circumstances. Its tasks and functions were, with the exception of the obligation to issue circulars, wholly undefined.
Just as little defined was its relation to the District Leaders and to the societies. The College of District Leaders gave it no very great powers — proof of which is that the composition of the circulars was placed under the control of Dr. Tschlenow. Later a College of Consultants was founded, consisting of Messrs. Idelsohn, Tschlenow, Ussischkin and Kohan-Bernstein, to whom the Central Bureau had to turn for instructions on every more or less important question of principle. In reality, however, neither Dr. Tschlenow's supervision nor the advice of the Consultants had any essential significance. The relations between the societies and the Central Bureau created by circumstances, a series of questions brooking no delay whose solution was made difficult by the lack of persons, and the slackening of the District Leaders' activity soon brought it about that the whole of the central Zionist work was laid upon the Central Bureau by a series of resolutions of the District Leaders. The state of affairs soon also required the meeting of the third conference of the Russian members of the A. C., which accordingly took place in January of this year at Vilna. This conference adopted the following resolutions: a) It is recognised that a centre is necessary for the whole Zionist Organisation in Russia, which must remain at Vilna as before; b) this centre receives the name "Central Bureau of the Zionist Organisation in Russia"; c) upon the Central Bureau devolves the work of agitation, organisation, information and financial administration. Likewise there is entrusted to the C. B. the carrying out of the directives worked out by the conferences of the District Leaders concerning the questions of "present-day policy" in Russia. As members of the C. B. there were co-opted, in November 1905 Mr. B. Goldberg, in April 1906 Dr. J. Lurje, and finally, on the strength of the resolution of the Russian members of the A. C. at the Annual Conference at Cologne, Messrs. J. Brutzkus, W. Schabotinsky and L. Jaffe.
It soon proved, however, that the assignment of the tasks was much easier than their execution. The Financial Centre, in the person of Dr. Mandelstamm, handed over to the new centre no sums of money and no list of addresses either. The societies, despite repeated reminders, sent no shekel moneys at all. Thus the C. B. had to perform work without possessing the most necessary precondition — namely money. And money was precisely what was needed. The Zionist Organisation, which had been shattered since the unhappy Uganda project and the disputes that followed, was struck by a series of fresh blows. The pogroms, political persecution and its consequence, the general depressed mood, the emigration of many active workers, the passing of some into other camps, and the diversion of general work into general Russian politics — all this threw our ranks into utter disarray. To this was added the circumstance that most of the elements of the party which had adapted themselves to the conditions of conspiratorial secret work became wholly estranged from the general party, or acted on their own account without keeping to the instructions of the general centre, and followed their own organs. General Zionists remained only those who can and will work only in a legal party. Our organisation, however, was not legally recognised. If in "pre-constitutional" Russia it was possible to work without danger even without legalisation, in "constitutional" Russia, with its laws on associations on the one hand and the state of extraordinary protection and the gubernatorial ordinances on the other, such work has become almost entirely impossible. For these reasons most of the societies, with the exception of the secret ones, dissolved; the connection of the District Leaders with their districts was a merely illusory one, and