Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 51 · 21 December 1906
9printed page
scan 9 of 28

No. 51 — "Die Welt" — 9

And for that reason the detailed programme adopted by the Conference was really more an example than a guiding rule, more an unfolding of energy than a political deed. . . Perhaps life will soon offer the occasion to put the programme to the test of fire, — and then we shall also have occasion to examine it for its weaknesses.

The Conference has marked the road of Zionism with a new milestone. It was no assembly calculated to impress, but a living one — and one that pointed the way. The masses? But in what and where are the masses really represented? Are they not perhaps a fiction? Is it perhaps always the individual will that creates and wills and suggests its will to the masses? . . . . .

Among the guests, numerous Jews from Helsingfors attended the Conference, splinters of the Jewish people cast away into the distant North. For many of them it was perhaps something new, — this assembly of genuine Jews. And one could read on the faces of these Finnish Jews astonishment and admiration and, at last, faith. What to us, spoiled as we are, sometimes seemed worn out, was for them a revelation. They believed in us and in our strength. And when we read in their eyes the longing to be one with us, the confidence that we are forging the future of the Jewish people, when we heard the echo that our words called forth in this wide, rocky and icy Helsingfors, then we could say to ourselves: Our work is not in vain!

The Conference sought to give a projection of the future. It has done its work honestly, even if for much it could give only outlines. Masters will come and create from the tints a picture, from the outlines a work of art. The latent energy of the Jewish people will bring them forth.

ST. PETERSBURG. A. CORALNIK.


On the Amendment of the Organisation Statute

by S. Kaplansky-Kaplan

I.

The Organisation Statute raised to a resolution at the Fifth Congress is generally acknowledged to be in need of reform. Understanding of organisational questions, however, is not so widespread in Zionist circles as would be desirable. So it comes about that even the few who turn their attention to this important question swing between extremes. Some display a shyness of incisive amendments; even the deliberations in the organisation commissions of the Congress are not without a certain uncertainty and timidity. Now, on the other hand, proposals of amendment appear, contrary to expectation, which leave nothing to be desired in decisiveness. For they aim at laying the axe to the root of the existing organisational form of Zionism, to the institution of the Shekel.

The Shekel does not come in regularly. Is this remedied by raising this voluntary contribution? That would be the strangest result of an increase in taxation! The consequences, we believe, can only be detrimental, since it might become impossible for many Zionists to pay their Shekel. Is the Shekel, then, not sufficient at all to maintain the executive organs of the Congress? In so difficult a time as the past year has been, about 50 000 K. (19 000 Rbl.) flowed into the Shekel treasury of the Russian territorial body. Had collections been diligently made in the other territorial organisations and, what is still more important, had the Shekel collections really been remitted to the Central Office, the Central Bureau would have to have an income of over a hundred thousand Kronen. With that the necessary expenditure could surely be met. It is not the Shekel institution that has failed to prove itself, but the territorial organisations that have failed. And it is at this point that the revision of the organisational provisions must begin. However high the Shekel might be, even were it raised indirectly by being bound up with the territorial contributions, the A. C. is little helped so long as the territorial organisations possess the charming quality of using Shekel moneys for their own purposes. A raising of the Shekel (the impossibility of which, moreover, many participants in this discussion have already aptly set forth from the most various points of view) would only enlarge correspondingly the portion unlawfully withheld by the territorial organisations. What needs reform, we repeat, is not the Shekel, but the relation of the general organisation of the Congress to the individual organisations of the countries.

We are not opponents on principle of raising the Shekel. We do not assert that one Krone (= 40 Kop.) is the highest permissible limit of the burden of taxation. Proletarian Zionists, too, could contribute more. Only, that is already the case. Let us take, for example, a bourgeois Zionist in Vienna and a Zionist workman organised in the "Jewish Socialist Workers' Party Poale-Zion" of Austria. The latter is obliged to pay to the trade-union organisation of the Poale-Zion (General Jewish Workers' Union of Austria) at least 25 Heller weekly, then an annual party tax of 5 (or 4) Kronen and 1 K. Shekel, thus 19 (or 18) Kronen a year, apart from collections for the National Fund, the Press Fund and the Strike Fund, and society dues. On the other hand, a member of the Zionist Central Society in the same city, Vienna, has satisfied all his obligations towards the Congress, the Territorial Committee and the society with a contribution of 4 (four) Kronen.

From the example cited it may be seen that the Poale-Zion must, as a matter of course, raise objection to a uniform increase of the Shekel contribution. But it is also evident from this example that it is as unjust as it is impractical to demand of a bourgeois Zionist the same Krone as of a workman. A progressive income tax is desirable, but impracticable in a voluntary organisation. There is therefore no purpose in throwing this catchword into the discussion. But the Organisation Statute may well be amended to the effect that the amount of contribution hitherto customary is designated as the minimum. It remains open to every territorial or district organisation, or to every individual society, to set this minimum higher. With that, however, the reform of the Shekel institution would be complete. Now the turn of the territorial organisations must come. Their relation to the A.-C. must be revised

In the Congress Statute there reigns in this respect a hopeless confusion of ideas. Thus federations are thrown together with their executive committees, the Territorial Committees. The competences of the members of the Territorial Committee and of the Actions Committee in the country concerned are not delimited. The Congress carefully avoided intervening in a determining or regulating way in the organisational questions of the federations. This course is, however, wholly unjustified in view of the fact that the territorial organisations, in so important a question as the franchise, have omitted to bring their organisational provisions into harmony with the Congress Statute. In America, until recently, the franchise for the Congress was not even direct,

3*