Ze'ev Jabotinsky · The Doctrine of Beitar · 1930
147printed page
scan 150 of 155
Facsimile · scan 150 of 155
Scan of p. 147
English · AI translation, not yet checked

— 147 —

discipline of this kind, where a crowd is subject to the authority of one leader, and this one, to that of one higher than him, and so on. And this is not a matter of subjugation to the will of another. The commander is but the bearer of your own will, your representative, to whom you, of your own free will, gave the authority to conduct your “orchestra,” — for if not, you would not have joined Betar, or you would not have remained in Betar. The idea of Betari discipline is again based on that fundamental principle of “Monism”: we all have one will, we are building one building together, therefore we all answered the call of that architect whose building plan found favor in our eyes: and as long as he remains faithful to this building plan, we lay courses of bricks and wield hammers according to his instructions.

The “commander,” “conductor,” “architect” can be one person, or a collective — for example, a “committee.” Both slogans are equally “democratic,” as long as their mandate to lead stems from the consent of those who appointed them. In France, a collective rules — the “Cabinet”; in America, only the President rules alone; both are complete democratic republics: the American system is more suitable for Betar, because Betar is a combination of a “school” and a “military camp,” and a class of students, like a battalion of soldiers, is easier to manage by one teacher and by one commander than by a debating committee. However, the first and last command of the entire Betar hierarchy rests on the will of the Betari crowd, for it freely chooses the supreme commander of the movement – the Rosh Betar.

The structure of Betar and its search for government are a successful and healthy combination between the judge on the one hand and the monistic harmony on the other.

3. The main secret of the peoples who create kingdoms:

...Their order aroused astonishment of the most audacious kind. He could not understand their order; superiors and inferiors in a precise and insistent hierarchy, the division of roles in the enterprises, solid rules for every profession, all the authority – his mind could not tolerate this whole tangle. But he saw clearly that the result was not a tangle, but an extraordinary order. There existed fixed channels, in which