Vladimir Jabotinsky · On Jews, Russia, and Nationalism: Early Writings of Vladimir Jabotinsky · 1922
27printed page
scan 28 of 279

Each of us should be recognized as having the right, at the close of a certain period of history, in such days of calm as the present, to sit down at a table and sum up the results, to count up all the good and all the bad that has come from our people's participation in the revolution. I want to do this. I will attempt to do this exclusively with the help of sober reason, intentionally dryly, without any appeals to feeling. We are talking about a calculation, about a total sum, and I want to act like an impersonal and conscientious bookkeeper who, perhaps, does not have all the data at hand, but has only one direct goal—to obtain, as far as it is in his power, a correct balance sheet.

The common notion formulates the role played by the Jews in the liberation movement as follows:

There was no revolution. It had to be brought about. And the Jews took this upon themselves. They are a highly flammable material, they are the fungal ferment that was called upon to incite fermentation in the enormous, slow-to-rise Russia. And so on. All this has been said many times, written many times in black and white, and is considered a great truth. But I, the bookkeeper, pause over this expenditure of the Jewish people in difficult contemplation, and I do not know if it has paid off or will pay off.

Oh, without a doubt, it is an alluring task: to be the instigators of a great cause, to awaken the political consciousness of a 150-million-strong people, to raise the red banner over Lithuania, so high that Tambov, and Saratov, and Kostroma would see it—that they would see and say to one another: "Let us follow it." And, of course, all this was done, insofar as it depended on the Jewish revolutionaries: the banner was raised, and so high, and with such a noise, that Kostroma, undoubtedly, saw it. But what effect did this have on the political consciousness of Kostroma?

I recall, I note, I calculate, and I see clearly that the effect was twofold. On the one hand, Kostroma was, without a doubt, led into temptation. This struggle at the other end of Russia could not fail to evoke in her, in Kostroma, temptation.

27