ON THE WRONG PATH
(1912)
The note "On a Strange Phenomenon" provoked a lively newspaper debate, but this debate, unfortunately, went along an absurd line. The impression was created that in my note I was asking the Russians: why do you, good people, not go to meetings? Is it not because you do not want to associate with Jews? And so, several esteemed Russian fellow citizens certified that they, on the contrary, are very glad to associate with Jews, but somehow it just never happened, — and several esteemed Jewish colleagues also frankly admitted that the true Russian intelligentsia is extremely fond of the Jewish one. Very pleasant, I read it with pleasure. But why all this was written — I do not know. I did not pose this question. Partly because there is no point in imposing and asking "do you love me?" where every child on the street knows the whole truth. And mainly because I am least of all interested in this question. By all appearances, it has no relation even to the dispute about whether it is necessary to "demarcate." The journalist of Jewish origin, about whom I spoke in that article, indeed arrived at the thought of the necessity of "demarcation" only because he noticed on the part of the Russians a clear unwillingness to "associate." But that is because he is an assimilationist. For people of my camp, the essence of the matter is not at all in how other nationalities relate to the Jews. If we were loved, adored, called into their embrace, we would just as steadfastly demand "demarcation." For we think that the mission of every nation is to create its own special culture; and
6* 83