Ignaz Zollschan · The Racial Problem · 1912
39printed page
scan 91 of 568
Facsimile · scan 91 of 568
Scan of p. 39
English · AI translation, not yet checked

39 has now become a doctrine recognized by many researchers; for example, Ripley has shared and substantiated Krzywicki's hypothesis in his work. Thus, in the racial anthropology of the Jews, diametrically opposed views prevail, and between these opposing points, there is, moreover, a whole chain of different mediating theories. It was Judt's* merit to have brought clarity to this field through a critique of the historical data and an analysis of the anthropological results. His work is formally excellent, firstly because of its method, but also because of the large body of evidence that the author has gathered from the scientific literature of all peoples. In terms of content, the work is also excellent in those parts where the author is completely independent, that is, where he proves the racial unity of the Jews. Significant objections, however, we have against those sections in which he — relying on Maspero and v. Luschan — draws conclusions about the racial origins of the Jews. He examines skull index, skin, hair, and eye color, and the body height of the Jews, i.e., the most important characteristics with which physical anthropology has worked so far. Regarding the skull index, he establishes that brachy- cephaly (60—80%) is the main characteristic of the Jews, that there is no difference at all in the skull structure of the Sephardim and Ashkenazim, and that in general there is no similarity of skull structure between the Jews and the native population. The investigations conducted on hair and eye color show that there is a varying percentage (20—30%) of blond and light-eyed individuals, which, however, is by no means in analogy to the same characteristics of the native population, and that the number of brunettes among the Sephardim is not greater than among the Ashkenazim. The situation is different with body height. Here there is a similarity between the Jewish and native population.

  • Judt, The Jews as a Race. 1901.