Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · The Peace of Jerusalem · 1868
10scan
of 23

Tract: The Return to Zion

And it is a reply to the words of the Gaon, head of the rabbinical court of Altona, in his book Benei Tziyon, section 1, against the holy way which I set forth in my book Seeking Zion on the matter of the sacrifices, should the time of love come when the Master of causes, blessed be His name, brings it about that permission is given to engage in holy things on the Temple Mount, our Temple, which lies desolate on account of our many sins. And already the Gaon, head of the children of the Exile, our master Akiva of blessed memory, agreed with our way, he who asked his son-in-law whether one should ask the rulers of Jerusalem for leave to sacrifice; and likewise his son-in-law, the Gaon, head of the children of the Exile, agreed to it in the Hatam Sofer; and likewise the early authority our master Hayyim of Paris, and the author of the book Kaftor va-Ferah, and the Gaon author of Kappot Temarim, and the Gaon of the Sha'agat Aryeh, who relied on the words of the Jerusalem Talmud that they are trustworthy for us, and the Gaon, head of the rabbinical court of the holy community of Grätz; and the Gaon the Rishon le-Zion, of Jerusalem and of Constantinople; and the Gaon our teacher Rabbi Tzvi Chajes of blessed memory, and other faithful men. And he alone has gone out to be judged on a new matter, by a slight inference from "And I will not smell the sweet savour"; and we shall make clear that there is not even a scent of doubt in this. And let this be written for a later generation, who by the will of the Holy One, blessed be He, will be granted permission by the kingdoms.

I have already replied to the Gaon, may his light shine, in my letter, and I have also set out in my books Seeking Zion and First to Zion his reasoning and mine, as is proper for one who seeks the truth; and clear proofs will bring their witnesses and be justified.

A Reply to the Words of the Responsa Benei Tziyon

From the outset I have wondered at a Gaon, and a righteous man such as he, how he would not set aside his opinion before all the Gaonim whom I mentioned overleaf; and over their host, moreover, the chief provider for all the children of the Exile, our master the Beit Yosef, who wrote explicitly in these words, "Perhaps permission will be given us to sacrifice", at the end of chapter 6 of the Laws of the Chosen House, halakhah 2, in the passage beginning "And the condition"; and who is greater for us than the Jerusalem Talmud; and the Gaon of the Tosafot Yom Tov, on chapter 8 of Ma'aser Sheni, where it is written explicitly: while the nations still rule over us, and the Sanctuary will be built before David comes, see there; and not according to his opinion, with which he concluded his words there, that only Messiah son of Joseph and Messiah son of David will build the Sanctuary and afterwards they will offer sacrifices; and this is his own opinion, his alone.

And Now I Shall Reply to All His Words in Order

  1. On the first proof, which I brought from Eduyot chapter 8, from a law given to Moses at Sinai that Elijah does not come to remove and to bring near: for why was the law given to Moses at Sinai needed? Surely when Elijah comes he will know what to do, unless it is for the present time, when there will be permission to sacrifice. And on this the Gaon, may his light shine, wrote, concerning