Die Welt · Vol. I, No. 3 · 18 June 1897
6printed page
scan 9 of 19

Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 3.

But this would have to proceed gradually, quite generally and practically, and not by way of "constitutional right." For you must not begin by demanding "rights" from the Turks. There every word is weighed, and not without reason. Yet the idea is a very good one; it is only a question of finding the proper foundation for it. Then there would arise from it not only an immense advantage for the material welfare of Turkey, but the Jews of all countries, and of Russia in particular, would thereby be strengthened. With us in Roumania there are no persecutions of the Jews on religious grounds. Our motto is that of Frederick the Great: "Let every man be saved after his own fashion." But the continual influx of Russian Jews is economically oppressive for us, and for that reason we too should joyfully welcome the realisation of the idea: Palestine for the Jews!"

Reply of the Baroness Bertha v. Suttner.

We addressed our enquiry to the Baroness Suttner as well. Frau v. Suttner replies in an interesting letter which she had not intended for publication, since she believed herself insufficiently versed in the matter. But it is precisely this unconstrained, unaffected utterance of the amiable and magnanimous authoress that is valuable to us. We have therefore requested, and received, authorisation to communicate the letter.

The Editors.

Honoured Doctor!

The specimen number of "Die Welt," and indeed your whole undertaking, inspires me with great respect. There is heart in it; frankness, clarity, deep and firm resolve — the gaze directed upon what is great and helpful.

It is with me toward you and Zionism as it is with you toward me and the peace movement: esteem and doubt. "God speed you" one says to the boat — but one cannot sail with it, one may not, because on both sides our rowing requires the whole man. I should have to immerse myself in the matter before venturing to say anything about it. By uttering doubts that spring from a want of understanding one may indeed do harm — in any case only what is true and competent is of use. And I really do not know whether assimilation would not be better than the founding of a new state and nationality. For my part I should wish that all reasonable men might assimilate themselves to the higher type of the "European," the "man of culture," which is now in the making and which has risen above national, religious and social conceits and fanaticisms.

To this new type your kinsmen contribute a great many valuable elements — would it not be a pity to divert these into a bed of their own? — You see that even in this letter, not intended for print, I abandon myself to wholly useless expressions of doubt in addressing you, and for that very reason I did not wish to trumpet them abroad, since I tell myself that I may be entirely in the wrong, and that in the present stage of the world's affairs and of human development it may be precisely your plan that would prove the more blessed.

Bertha v. Suttner.

Rabbi Samuel Mohilewer

was born in the year 1824 in Hluboka, a small town in the Vilna district. His family was among the most respected of the neighbourhood. As a youth of eighteen he received ordination as rabbi from several rabbinical authorities, and at the age of 24 he entered upon the office of rabbi in his birthplace, which he held until 1856. Until 1860 he was rabbi in Szaki, whereupon he was called to Suwalk. Here he made himself so deserving of the community that the government distinguished him with a medal. In 1868 he was called to Radom. In the year 1873 he took part in the assembly of Jewish communal representatives and rabbis at St. Petersburg.

R. Samuel Mohilewer began his Zionist activity in the year 1875, when, on the occasion of Montefiore's 90th birthday, work was begun for the colonisation of Palestine; and ever since then the venerable rabbi has clung to the colonisation idea with body and soul.

After the bloody persecutions of the year 1881 he accompanied the Jewish emigrants from Russia as far as Lemberg, where, among other personages from the West, he became acquainted with Messrs. Montagu and Oliphant and sought to dispose them favourably toward the colonisation of Palestine. On the return journey to Russia he held a meeting at Warsaw, whereupon the first Zionist society came into being there in the year 1882. In the same year he betook himself to the West of Europe in order to win adherents for the colonisation of Palestine. In Germany he accomplished nothing on this occasion; in Paris, on the other hand, he succeeded, with the help of R. Zadoc Kahn and M. Erlanger, in winning Baron Rothschild for the idea. By him he was entrusted with the finding of capable, work-fit people. He found a number of such people, and these form the colony "Ekron." Having returned to Russia, he travelled through all the larger towns there and won numerous friends for the colonisation. Since 1883 he has been rabbi in Bialystok, and from there he unfolds a distinguished activity as a Zionist. At the first Zionist Congress at Kattowitz in 1885 R. Samuel Mohilewer was one of the leading personalities.

A year later he betook himself once more to the West, stayed in Germany, visited Paris and London, and everywhere unfolded a magnificent propaganda for the colonisation idea, this time crowned with greater success. When in the year 1887 disturbances arose in the colony "Rischon l'Zion" in consequence of the colonists' dissatisfaction with the administration, Mohilewer came forward as peacemaker, and through his mediation Herr Simmel of Berlin was despatched to the colony, who restored order. There came the year 1889, as a Sabbatical or fallow year, which, by the cessation of labour, might have gravely injured the colonists; and then a heated battle of pens broke out among the rabbis of Palestine and Russia as to whether the Sabbatical year was to be observed according to Biblical prescription. R. Samuel Mohilewer now had occasion to give effect to his noble disposition, borne up by the highest love for the Jewish working people, and came out with all decisiveness against leaving that year fallow. Since several eminent rabbis joined him, he succeeded in preserving the colonists from the impending misfortune. In the summer of 1890 Mohilewer set out at the head of a small,