Die Welt · Vol. I, No. 11 · 13 August 1897
4printed page
scan 8 of 20

Page 4. — "Die Welt" — No. 11.

But alongside this analogy a whole host of differences springs up. The most significant is the poverty of imagination among the Prussians and the wealth of it among the Jews. Hence the Prussian is a man of reason en gros and en detail, the Jew only en detail, and even there the fancy sometimes intrudes. This difference expresses itself in commercial life. The Prussian is a sober, cautious merchant, the Jew a hesitating, venturing entrepreneur. It follows that the Prussian is at the very least a match for the Jew. The handful of Jewish millionaires whose throw has come off signify little. The Jewish middle class is no better placed than the Prussian and cannot raise itself above it as it does elsewhere. The Prussian burgher class has therefore no ground whatever to fear the Jews; and since in the lower strata of the bourgeoisie Social Democracy again predominates, in consequence of the rationalistic bent of the Prussians, there is from the outset little prospect for a political anti-Semitic movement of the Viennese kind.

That, however, would be only half the secret of the Berlin ex-anti-Semitism. For when one speaks of anti-Semitism, one must also speak of Jew-hatred. The two things are not the same, but they condition one another. The first is a revelation of the second. Unrevealed Jew-hatred is called, by an immemorial Hebrew word, Rischus. A self-evident proportion now runs: the less Rischus, the more anti-Semitism, and conversely. Or, more concretely: the Viennese anti-Semites are lesser Reschoim than the Berlin non-anti-Semites.

For herein the rationality of the Berliners shows itself with particular brilliance, that they master so well their feelings, of which one of the strongest is the aversion to everything foreign. It is only superficial observers who take this calm in earnest and imagine that hatred of the stranger has perished amid the traffic of the modern metropolis. No, it lives on beneath a thin covering. Every stranger who comes to Berlin has something to tell of the Berliner's want of amiability. But the strangest of strangers here too is the Jew. It scarcely ever happens that the Berliner insults a Jew unknown to him; even a gesture that a sensitive nature might construe as mocking he permits himself comparatively seldom. But he has the rigid, unapproachable look of strangeness, which thrusts itself between him and the man he beholds like an icy glacier. There is a matter-of-course non-intercourse between Jews and non-Jews in Berlin such as does not exist even in Vienna. Yet when they must after all have dealings with one another, be it in business, be it as neighbours, the Berliner takes his atmosphere of strangeness along with him. Milder, more distinguished natures then transmute it into urbane civility. The rabble is simply surly, and often concludes the acquaintance with an anti-Semitic outburst that puts the most famous Viennese models to shame.

With this relatively quiet Rischus of theirs the Berliners now get further than the Viennese with their spirited anti-Semitism. Without the short-sighted and hard-of-hearing Jews — whose senses react only to anti-Semitic firebrands and cannon-thunder — perceiving it, they are being made with Prussian thoroughness (and that is incredible) into citizens of the second class, who stand back everywhere and are notably left a good way to the rear in the hierarchy of officialdom. For I should not in the least care to ascribe the setting back of the Jews in the state service to anti-Semitism and its economic occasions. I am convinced that here the materialistic motives vanish altogether before the idealistic motive of a patriotic-national solicitude and defence. Here too Rischus, not anti-Semitism.

Whether anti-Semitism has any prospects at all remaining in Berlin is a question which, after what has gone before, offers at bottom little interest. I believe, moreover, that it stands upon the eve of a rebirth. There are signs of it. Political circumstances will create it anew. Perhaps it will then acquire a more lasting significance, in so far as it may bring the German Jews nearer to Zionism. For to expect of the German Jews in their present constitution that, without the rod-strokes of anti-Semitism, purely out of sensitiveness to the Rischus, out of a proud national individualism, they should join the Zionist movement — that would be foolish optimism. Perhaps it might yet come to pass, if only they had not such lamentable leaders! ...


The Mood in Russia.

You wish to learn the voice of the people in Russia ...

Among you in the West there is much discussion now for and against the Zionist Congress. Are there, here too, in the utmost East of Europe, in the Egypt of modern times, where by far the greater part of the Jewish popular mass dwells, opponents of the Zionist Congress? Do men come forward here also against you with demonstrations of protest? This question, I believe, is likely to interest the Zionists of the West above all. In what follows I shall endeavour to give the answer to it.

But will this answer profit you as well? I am convinced that it will be able only to lift your courage, to breathe into you new strength and endurance in the struggle for the holy and righteous cause of our people. For it holds within it the assurance that the people, the whole great mass of the Jewish people, stands upon your side, belongs to you, wherever and in whatever stations of life it may find itself. The people is for you, quite unconditionally, without much reflection or subtlety, because it cannot possibly be against you, because from the most ancient times down to the present day it has not ceased to feel itself One people, a peculiar and distinctive people. The people is for you because it has not yet at all thrown itself into the arms of that pseudo-liberalism which presupposed its assimilation, because the people is still far from thinking of assimilating itself.

Let one but ask a poor labourer in the open country, a porter in Odessa, a pedlar, a small shopkeeper, a tailor or a cobbler in any other town, who and what he is?

"A Jew am I!" will be the dumbfounded answer of the not a little astonished man. "I am a Jew, and I hope that my children will remain so too."

To the question whether he is not perhaps a Slav and belongs merely to the "Mosaic confession," whether the land in which he dwells does not belong to him, the answer will fall out differently according to the degree of the questioned man's faith. The strictly believing — and such are most of the Jews here — will declare decidedly:

"I am a Jew, as my parents were; I am as they were in the Goluß, until God shall one day have mercy upon us and redeem us once again ..."

The answer of him who is less believing, into whose heart scepticism has already found entrance, will on the other hand run:

"I am a Jew, I belong to an unhappy people, to whom sorrow and persecutions have from of old been allotted." But neither will he ever let himself be persuaded that he, who differs greatly from others in his thinking, his feeling and his whole life, could suddenly become a "Slav." The inward feeling of belonging to the Jewish nationality lives in his flesh and blood, manifests itself in his whole life. For only the man of a higher culture can out-