Die Welt · Vol. I, No. 21 · 22 October 1897
4printed page
scan 8 of 20

Page 4. — "Die Welt" — No. 21.

Today Herr Siegmund Mayer*) would define the matter thus: that the city of Rome is an organic and not a mechanical whole. By mechanical he presumably means a city that was founded with full deliberation and according to a definite plan. To be sure, it is not entirely clear to me whether Herr Mayer perhaps holds the view that a city so mechanically established cannot endure for long. At all events he is prudent enough to keep such assertions quietly to himself. St. Petersburg and Constantinople, Lima, the capital of Peru, Chicago and other cities of North America would be too drastic a contradiction, before which the representatives of the organic would have to fall silent in shame. "Well, yes, a city," Herr Mayer will answer me. "But a State, and a Jewish State at that — ah, my good man, that is quite another matter." But why? States too have more than once been founded with plan and deliberation. Rhodesia arose overnight, and so did Bulgaria. In the fifties California suddenly blossomed forth, and at present we hear how, in the northernmost part of North America, scarcely has gold been discovered than there is already talk of a new State and a new star in the banner of the Union. Oh, how inorganic; oh, how mechanical! But if only it be durable, one may well put up with such excellent mechanics. We live, after all — according to the assertion of those who must know — in an age in which everything is made artificially and nothing any longer develops according to nature. The humanity of Greek and Roman antiquity was of quite another structure. The ancient Hellenes were plain and naive, they lay upon the bosom of Nature, and their vigorous little States were no base contrivance of men, but resembled the leaves and boughs of a mighty tree. Organic, frightfully organic — so that every assimilationist Jew who will hear nothing of a Jewish State might have taken the purest delight in them. The ancient Hellenes themselves, however, appear not to have grasped this lofty assimilatory wisdom in full, as sundry facts of their history clearly prove. The Persians in their day carried war into Greece. They approached the city of Athens as well, and all resistance seemed wholly hopeless. Then Themistocles counselled the Athenians to go aboard the ships with wife and child and to abandon the city to its fate; for so long as the fleet still existed, so long might one hope for victory and deliverance. And after the victory the city and the State would rise again from the ashes richer and more beautiful than before. This Themistocles was a devil of a fellow. He had not studied natural science and therefore could not know that the Athenian State was an organic whole, while the Athenian ships were merely a contrivance of the human hand. Certain patriots accordingly refused to go along and entrenched themselves on the Acropolis, where they were duly slain by the Persians — those martyrs of the organic. Themistocles, however, remained as obstinate as before. The Peloponnesian fleet in the harbour of Salamis was afraid of the great superiority of the Persian ships, and the notion arose of withdrawing to the Peloponnesus. But then the Athenian commander threatened that the Athenians, who furnished the greater number of the ships, would take wife and child on board and steer for Italy, there to found a new home. Remarkably enough, this threat impressed the Peloponnesians most powerfully, and nothing whatever is known to me of any one of these gentlemen having said: "My dear Themistocles, one does not do such a thing. That is not organic." This may of course have been owing to the ignorance of the Peloponnesians, and especially of the Spartans, who could indeed fight well and eat black broth, but whose schooling was frightfully neglected. Herr Siegmund Mayer, on the other hand, lives in Vienna and in the age of natural science — by which I by no means wish to say that he is a great naturalist.

*) Owing to want of space we were unable to publish this reply to Herr Siegmund Mayer's article in the "Zeit" any earlier. Note of the Editors.

Themistocles, then, persisted in his inorganic principles, and so the glorious battle of Salamis was fought, which still to-day, after thousands of years, makes every heart tremble with joy that will not let itself be robbed of the faith that the force of a deeply felt thought overcomes at last the resistance of matter.

Theodor Mommsen once says that universal history can no more prevent the devil from citing it falsely than can the Bible, but that it refreshes everyone who will hear and see, and richly compensates him for false citations. The like may be said of the natural sciences. Herr Siegmund Mayer, whom I certainly do not wish to compare with the devil, has nevertheless — exempla docent — cited falsely. Let us now see whether, in Mommsen's phrase, we receive compensation for it. And indeed, the rightly understood conception of the organic need by no means terrify the national Jew; it is rather his mightiest ally. Again, since we are once at citing, I will call up the spirit of Themistocles. In the council of commanders the strategus of the Corinthians objected to him that a man without a city and without a State had no voice in the matter. Thereupon Themistocles merely pointed to the fleet and said laconically: "Here is Athens." Yes indeed, there was Athens. Attica's youth and its best manhood — the Athenian people — were assembled upon those ships. The hearts of these men were kindled and illumined by the still fire of a mighty patriotism, and from their eyes there shone a courage which proclaimed aloud that the Athenian would summon up the utmost of his intelligence and force of will to chain the goddess of victory to his ships in a terrible sea-fight — or to die. Above these ships, however, unseen — perhaps the commander alone could see her — there hovered with helmet and lance Pallas Athene. But whence came this goddess? Whence this people, whence this contempt of death and this immense patriotism? Here every answer fails us, for here we touch upon the organic, upon the development of centuries. The common history, the common race, an endless fusion and equalisation of heterogeneous elements, had at length created a peculiar, sharply marked nationality, which proved the stronger and the more enduring the more slowly it had grown and the more deeply it was rooted in the dark impulses of the subconscious. This Athenian people was assuredly an organic growth, and it would have been foolish and ridiculous had an ambitious captain of troops attempted to create a similar people artificially out of elements gathered at random. But the Athenian State was by no means identical with the Athenian people. When that State lay in ruins, this people overcame the Great King in bloody battles and then set about raising up the edifice of its State once more; and we all know well what a State the Athens of Pericles was. The State in all its splendour is precisely not something organic, something slowly grown, but the work of men, truly and verily nothing but the work of men. It is the house which a nationality, so long as it still lives and still hopes, raises up for itself ever anew. But has one ever heard of a house growing organically out of the earth, as a tree does? Only there must of course be people there to build — living, nature-born men in whose brain plans and thoughts germinate organically. Have we such men? Have we such a master-builder? Have we, in a word, an organically developed Jewish nationality?

To put this question is, for the Zionist, to answer it in the affirmative. The best proof that this nationality exists is precisely this, that it demands a State aloud, cries out for a State as the hungry man cries for bread. After more than a thousand years of the bloodiest oppression and of utter dispersion, this longing suddenly revives with elemental force. A violent jolt passes through the Jewry of the whole earth, and this electric shock,