Die Welt · Vol. II, No. 18 · 6 May 1898
2printed page
scan 2 of 16
Facsimile · scan 2 of 16
Scan of p. 2
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 2. — "Die Welt" — No. 18.

(continued from page 1)

…Disraeli, and, at a seemly distance from that great man, Claude Montefiore also have sprung. What do these Jews want with their cry for Zion, welling up out of the deepest breast? Do we not live already in the best of all conceivable worlds? Do we not play cricket with the sons of famous English families? Do we still wear the yellow badge? Do we not sit in the House of Commons as Whigs or Tories? Nay, do we not sometimes attain even to the Peerage? Do we not do good business? And if our mind is not set upon the acquisition of earthly goods, because we are without wants or well-to-do enough, may we not give ourselves up to learned pursuits?

Mr. Claude Montefiore is a learned gentleman. He occupies himself, as it appears, chiefly with Jewish science, delivers lectures for his own satisfaction, and he has presumably never soiled his hand with the earning of money. He is also a charitable man — of the old style. One finds his name in all the subscription lists; he stands at the head of various benevolent undertakings; and when Lady So-and-so sends him a collecting sheet, he assuredly enters himself for the highest amount. In all this there is nothing to blame. And the testimony of so perfect a gentleman will surely hold good in every matter — with the exception of Zionism, if the gentleman is against it. For with Zionism the case is a curious one. The higher a man stands, the better off he is, the less his opposition proves. Whereas, conversely, the adherence of a favourably situated man to the movement is a very strong proof. From this we may already to-day formulate a principle: in Zionism the value of adherence or of opposition stands in inverse ratio to the pecuniary position of the person concerned. Mr. Montefiore feels comfortable and desires no alteration of his present condition? That is quite charming, and may it be granted him in the fullest measure. But a normally constituted brain finds it hard to grasp what authority he thereupon claims for himself to pass judgment upon the sufferings and the needs of an enormous multitude whose distress is so undeniable that not even he denies it.

The subjective views of Mr. Claude G. Montefiore are therefore not decisive. At most it is to be regretted that by his example he influences a number of narrower minds, or draws after him those faint-hearted persons who like to be in such good company. A robust national movement such as ours can bear such losses. These lost ones will all of them join us as soon as we have been proved right, and we shall then welcome them with a smile.

But how is it with Claude Montefiore's objective reasons?

He sets forth quite clearly the causes by which one becomes a Zionist. He admits that orthodox Jews as well as Reform Jews and freethinkers belong to Zionism. We, for our part, will readily admit that the opposing camp likewise recruits itself from the same categories. From this alone it is plain that religious standpoints ought reasonably to remain reserved. Every man, as a Zionist too, believes and thinks what he pleases and as he pleases. Freedom of conscience, the full and equal freedom, is too precious a possession of modern civilized humanity for us to permit it even to be discussed in our movement. Mr. Montefiore's reflections are therefore idle; we do not enter upon them at all.

The kernel of his argument is the following:

“The Jewish State, it is said, is the only solution of the Jewish question. Let us grant for a moment that this were correct; it still seems to matter much in what manner one enters upon this solution. Is it a sad solution or a cheerful one? Is it a gloomy necessity or a glorious ideal?”

Having put the question to himself in this dilemmatic form, Mr. Montefiore answers it to his own satisfaction. One can read his dilemma and his compelling answers with growing merriment. A few years ago there was much laughter in France over the then Prime Minister Dupuy, who one day called out to the Socialists: “Je vous enferme dans un dilemme.” But those locked up in the dilemma of his logic continued to move about quite unhampered and briskly, and they do so still, while M. Dupuy has long since ceased to govern and to lock people up in dilemmas.

So then, the one horn of Montefiore's dilemma: “the glorious ideal.” If anyone regards Zion as such, he can no longer be a citizen of his present State. Good heavens, why not? Is there between present and future only so barren an option? Can one not exercise and fulfil the rights and duties of the present, and at the same time strive for and prepare better days? Why, how then did the whole civilization of mankind come into being? The logician Montefiore will say — and prove it too, for he proves everything — that a man cannot dwell in two houses. How true! But can one not build a new house while one is still living in the old one? No, he will say, one may not, for he is a methodical spirit who holds such leaps to be illogical and dangerous. To be sure, men would to this day still be dwelling in pile-dwellings or in holes in the earth if there had never been other heads than his.

But Zion as a “glorious ideal” has yet other faults: it must call forth anti-Semitism. Well, we have three years' experience in the most various countries behind us. Nowhere has Zionism excited or increased anti-Semitism. The contrary is true. The worst anti-Semites concede that this ideal tendency of the new Jewry deserves respect. Were Mr. Montefiore not so anxiously concerned for his present well-being, did he stand out in the struggle for existence as the vast majority of his brethren in race do, the thought of a worsening of the situation would hardly occur to him. No, that is not to be feared; rather is it clearly to be foreseen that in every land the worth and the standing of the Jews would rise if their number diminished. And when at last only the assimilated remain behind, they will be treated as the rarity that they are. Yet let us assume that he were right, that unpleasantnesses would grow for Mr. Montefiore and his like out of the Zionist movement — by what right does he demand of us that we, the Jewish people, should renounce our wishes for betterment, suppress our cry of distress, and keep silent about all the moral and material misery that torments us? This demand is grotesque. Whoever ventures to advance it gives himself a certificate of poverty. There are unhappily many men who think so, but prudence forbids most of them to speak so.

Thereupon Mr. Claude discusses the other horn: “the sad necessity,” and again “he assumes something.” What does he assume? “That anti-Semitism should cease to-morrow, that the Jews in Russia and Roumania should suddenly and completely be emancipated, that social ostracism and hatred, under which the Jews in Austria, Germany, and (mirabile dictu) even in the United States suffer, should suddenly melt away and vanish…” Then Zionism as a “sad necessity” would at once cease. Indeed, since he is once at assuming, why does he not assume straightway that we are on the moon or in the twenty-third century A.D., or that we can fly. Truly, if we