Die Welt · Vol. II, No. 22 · 3 June 1898
2printed page
scan 2 of 16

Page 2. — "Die Welt" — No. 22.

(continued from page 1)

…designates it; or at most a private matter only so long as religion is prudently — not discussed by the labour party. It is doubtless out of such differences and sensitive antagonisms that we are to explain the fact that voices were raised demanding an independent organisation of the Jewish workers. Such a demand might well be regarded by the leading party as a kind of anomaly, especially as the Jewish workers, and the Jews in general, did not come into consideration at all as a nation, but counted rather as appendages of the various peoples. And if it was not mere euphemism when the same right of existence was conceded to the Jews, when they were given the name of the people in whose land they became resident — wherefore an independent organisation? Well, the course of development of the Jews down to the present moment, and notably its latest phase, has revealed that it is not merely the culturally still unadvanced masses of Jewry that feel nationally. It is precisely in the Zionism of the Jewish intelligentsia that the full justification of the national movement shows itself. We may without diffidence point to the difference between the consciously Zionist action and that portion of Jewry which is unconsciously national, by force of historical circumstances. These Jewish workers are the natural confederate of Zionism; but an actual, co-operating one they become only through independent workers' organisations. That such already exist, in America, in England, in Russia, is well known; known also that their class interest is thereby not in the least affected. When last year the Jewish workers in Manchester — bakers, tailors, shoemakers — came together for the formation of a trade union of their own*), they expressly declared that they wished to "make common cause with the other trade unions." The founding of an independent association sprang solely from the need "to remain among themselves." The history and the effectiveness of precisely the English Trades-Unions is a proof that the class question and the class interest of the workers can be very vigorously represented and defended in independent organisations, without a necessary agreement with certain theoretical and programmatic points of the general labour party. The Jewish workers, independently organised, would go together with the labour party in all the particular demands which the class interest dictates, but would be independent of it in all else. National as the Jewish workers plainly enough are in life, national by virtue of their peculiarities, their religious usages — why should they not be permitted to be so as a working class also? Do the workers of other nations, perchance, lay aside their nationality when they take up a position upon the social question? And do they divest themselves of their nationhood when they have done, for the moment, with the debate and the action? And only the Jewish workers are to renounce their nationality — they, who are not yet at all capable of taking a proper share in the culture of another nation? One may hold ever so high a conception of modern culture, and esteem the peculiarly Jewish culture or lack of culture ever so lightly: in the word Progress there lies a fair intimation that the best is to be attained only step by step, that the given facts are very well to be reckoned with, and that it is to them that one must attach oneself directly. Zionism has no need whatever to enter into an over-violent polemic with the general labour party — the more clamorous, the less fruitful — in order to win the Jewish workers to itself. These, though for the greater part they are not national for Zionism's sake, may yet in time become national in the Zionist sense as well. And that through the natural community of national interest, advancing from the unconscious to the conscious, which will establish an ever more intimate rapport between them and Zionism. Many a political event of recent times, and the position of the official labour party towards it — we recall the wavering attitude of the French labour party in the Dreyfus affair — should make it clear to the Jewish workers that they have many an unwelcome surprise to expect in this respect. Even in the event of the victory of the collectivist view, matters would hardly become otherwise with regard to the antagonisms of race. And when E. Bernstein remarks in the afterword to the translation of Webb's "History of the English Trades-Unions": "Class struggles express themselves but seldom so acutely as national ones," we may add further that the antagonisms of race will probably still subsist long after the antagonisms of class shall have disappeared.

It is evident of what extraordinary importance the Jewish working class is for Zionism. The workers, should they become Zionist, would furnish as it were the sure standing strength upon which one might reckon at any moment. On the other hand one may assume that the Jewish people will do as much justice as possible to the demands of the working class, and of the Jewish working class in particular. For here it becomes necessary to recall that with the attainment of the Zionist goal only the condition is as yet created for a flowering and a fresh unfolding of the national life; that Jewry, united as a nation, will stand before the very questions with whose solution the peoples of Europe are so anxiously labouring. But be the difficulties ever so great, let crises and storms break in from time to time — the peoples are not thereby permanently cast down, not paralysed. And we too are of good courage. Like the other nations, the Jews too have the unshakable faith in an ever-advancing betterment, in a prosperous development of all. Even that party which has built up the class antagonisms into a theory of society we see departing more and more from the revolutionary principle and doing homage to the evolutionary one. Before the positive practical demands the theory retires into the background. To the principle of evolution Zionist Jewry too holds fast, and, so soon as it is nationally consolidated, will assuredly not wish to lag behind the other peoples in respect of social legislation. Zionism as a complete theory may occupy itself with the particular demands of the several classes; here it suffices to indicate the general spirit of the Jewish national legislation. One would rather record it in a symbolic than in a positive sense when Dr. Herzl, in the "Judenstaat," fixes the daily duration of labour not at eight but even at seven hours. One would say: the Jewish people will treat its sons not worse, but always better, than another does. And if one may infer from the historical past of a people its shaping in the future, then in the modern Jewish commonwealth there will assuredly be felt a breath of that mild spirit which fills the Mosaic legislation.


The Second Basle Congress.

In Number 12 of the "Welt" we communicated the instruction according to which the elections of delegates are to be held. We again call attention to this instruction, in order that any delay or any incorrect conduct of the elections may be avoided.


*) Cf. Socialpolitisches Centralblatt, annual volume 1897, page 240.