Die Welt · Vol. II, No. 35 · 2 September 1898
22printed page
scan 30 of 40

Page 22. — "Die Welt" — No. 35.

Motzkin declares himself in favour of the bank's not restricting its activity to Palestine and Syria alone. He then moves that not only bankers be elected to the bank committee that is to be chosen.

Dr. Menczel moves that the bank extend its activity in the Orient only to those countries which stand in commercial relations with Syria and Palestine.

Dr. Farbstein declares himself against the financial instrument of Zionism being built up upon shares. He declares himself further in favour of the founding of the bank being postponed to a later date.

Berger declares himself in favour of the well-considered draft of the bank commission.

Schauer declares that no one will be able to reproach him with not loving the people. Nevertheless he must declare himself against the application of the co-operative principle to the founding of the bank; there is no danger that the bank could be used to carry on unworthy business, that would be against the principles of Zionism.

Kohan-Bernstein declares himself in favour of the draft of the bank committee, pointing out that the names of our leaders, from whom the founding of the bank proceeds, are our warrant that the undertaking will be conducted for the good of the Jewish people and of Zionism. By the adoption of the draft, confidence must be expressed in our leaders and chiefly in Dr. Herzl.

Syrkin declares himself in favour of the co-operative principle in the bank question.

Dr. Salz declares that he is an adherent of the bank, and that he wishes it may come into being as soon as possible. Yet he declares himself against § 2 of the resolution proposed by the Bank Conference. He is against the bank's engaging provisionally in profitable undertakings. He is for the striking out of this paragraph. The speaker further takes exception to the expression "Orient" in § 1 of the resolution. He moves in its place Palestine and Syria. The word "provisionally" in § 2 does not seem to him sufficiently defined.

The motion is made for the election of general speakers for and against the draft.

As general speaker against, Mr. Bambus is elected; as general speaker for, Dr. Alexander Marmorek. Mr. Willy Bambus expresses his full confidence in the bank committee. He moves, however, that final resolutions be postponed to a later occasion. Mr. Alexander Marmorek, as general speaker for, observes that even the minority is not in principle against the Colonial Bank. He thereupon rejects Syrkin's misgivings. The speaker then turns against the objections of Dr. Salz. The bank would certainly never engage in unworthy business: it would be very unpractical to let so large a sum of money lie in the coffer as dead capital. The speaker refutes the misgivings with regard to the expression Orient in point 1) of the draft, and declares himself against assigning to the bank a narrowly limited field of work, such as is contained in the motion: "Palestine and Syria." This would be a great mistake from the business point of view. It is not opportune to draw out the founding of the bank at length. The bank is a necessity and must be realised as soon as possible. Delay means damage. The founding of the bank is a test of the strength of Zionism. He declares himself for the adoption of the project.

President: The gentlemen who have spoken before, and who elected Mr. Marmorek, desire that into paragraph 1 of § 1 there come: "especially in Palestine and Syria." Likewise in the 2nd paragraph: "especially in Palestine and Syria." I observe that a whole series of motions has approximately the same content. In Mr. Bambus's case too it is a question of Palestine. I will not have the motions read out.

Reporter Doctor Bodenheimer: The Bank Conference has arrived at the conviction that it is impossible for it to found the bank if it be not, first, in a position to propose a committee, and secondly, to lay down guiding principles. The committee must be in a position to know how far its responsibility extends. The bank committee which you will elect is responsible to the Congress, and what it now does, it will do with the consciousness that the responsibility is a great and a heavy one. The speaker appeals to the authority of experts who have expressed their full approbation of the draft of the bank, and reads out documents relating thereto.

A number of inquiries follow.

Then the vote is taken upon the first resolution of the Bank Conference. It is adopted unanimously. As additions to the list of persons in the second resolution several names are proposed, among them Bodenheimer and Mister Bentwich. Both declare that they must decline on account of being overburdened with professional business. For the rest, the President declares that according to the draft a co-optation is admissible and that wide latitude is left for the enlargement of the commission.

The vote en bloc is taken upon the second resolution.

The second resolution is adopted by all votes against 6.

Mr. D. Wolffsohn, the chairman of the bank committee, informs all those who have addressed inquiries to it that he will not be in a position to answer inquiries until after the lapse of 14 days; these have come in in such great number that their perusal and business-like dispatch will require at least that time.

(Close of the sitting.)

* * *

(Evening sitting.)

The President opens the sitting and reads out the further correspondence hitherto arranged. Thereupon the colonisation debate is continued. Mr. E. W. Rabbinowitsch of London receives the floor. He demands the reading of the motions of the Colonisation Commission.

After Dr. Minz has complied with this demand, Mr. Rabbinowitsch continues his speech. He welcomes the resolution of the commission in the warmest manner. The colonisation associations devote their whole sympathy to the Congress. The two tendencies in Zionism have agreed very amicably at the Congress. The fusion of the colonisation associations with the Zionists of purely political observance he nevertheless holds to be premature. Only when the Actions Committee shall have won successes in the matter of colonisation can the colonisation associations give up their separate, waiting position. After him Mr. Seph takes the floor. He speaks in Russian, but then, at the wish of the assembly, continues in German. He turns in a very energetic manner against colonisation without the guarantee of public rights. But he will very gladly see an autonomous community in another land, because that can only be of use to Zionism.

Dr. Menczel (Czernowitz) turns against the old practical colonisation. The political programme is far more congenial to the people.

Bambus takes exception to the expression smuggling, which Dr. Menczel has used. Only mass immigration is forbidden. Bambus comes forward in the sharpest manner for colonisation and infiltration. Nor is it true that mismanagement on the part of the officials takes place. He brings examples of this. Colonisation is for us a very valuable