No. 42 — "Die Welt" — Page 9
(continued from page 8)
…the statement of the Minister serve, which Hofrath Kareis communicated to the assembly.
The Minister of Education had expressed himself in the following manner: He could not deny that circumstances and conditions might arise, individual cases in which confessional classes proved a necessity. But these were only isolated cases. Against any attempt to erect this decree into a rule he, as Minister of Education, would have to set himself. (Applause.)
After Hofrath Kareis, Architect Oskar Marmorek took the floor and delivered the following address:
Esteemed Assembly!
A few days ago I heard an anecdote which you, my honoured gentlemen, will permit me to relate: Czar Alexander II. once visited a pleasure-palace which but rarely housed the imperial family. There he saw a sentry posted before a meadow; but he could not explain to himself the reason for this watch. He asked the adjutant, the adjutant the Court Marshal, he the Captain of the Castle, but none could give an answer. This only excited the Emperor's curiosity the more, and he gave orders that inquiry be made why this meadow was guarded. The following state of affairs came to light: the Empress Catherine II. had likewise once spent a few days at this pleasure-palace and had discovered upon the meadow in question a violet which pleased her so well that she gave orders for a sentry to be posted, so that the little flower should not be trodden down. The flower has long since withered, the Empress has long since died; decade upon decade has gone by: but ever anew the guard was mounted before the meadow.
The Jews are like this sentry. The Constitution, which in its day they helped to win, is riddled in a thousand places, and though it still subsists de jure, de facto it has long been nothing more than a scrap of paper in which no one any longer believes … Yet the Jews still stand sentry before the Constitution.
The interconfessional school has long been mere empty sound and has given place to the clerical school, but the Jews will not give up the fiction that it still exists. Like Shylock upon his bond, they appeal to the law that has been violated … and yet not even the eminently acute and brilliant exposition of Deputy Dr. Ofner was needed to know that.
But a law is living only when it lives in the mind of the people; where that resonance is lost, the law too is mere empty sound. The Christian people to-day will hear nothing of the interconfessional school (lively contradiction from a part of the assembly, applause from another side) … yes, my gentlemen, with your contradiction you do not argue out of the world the fact that our non-Jewish fellow-citizens in their majority accept the actual clearing away of the last remnant of the interconfessional school quite calmly, without any agitation, that they even greet it with joy; and the protest meetings of which Herr Hofrath Kareis spoke were nothing else than very thinly attended meetings of certain so-called liberal societies in which the Jews form the majority.
That is the saddest thing in the sad situation of the Jews, that they are indignant less over the wrong committed against them than over the fact that the fiction into which they will at all costs live themselves — as though the equality of rights stipulated by law actually existed — has once again been done away with.
For more than 20 years the Jews have been systematically attacked along the whole line with the sharpest weapons and the most brutal means. But their chief care is not, say, to defend themselves manfully against the attack, but only to make the outer world believe that this attack is an isolated and passing one. The Jews are excluded from almost all fellowship with their Christian fellow-citizens, from clubs and societies, from public offices and posts of honour. So they form societies and clubs of their own, in which, however, they do not withdraw proudly upon themselves, but by means of a few, very few parade-Christians seek to create the appearance that a fellowship still subsists.
Only not Jewish. That is the watchword. Jewishness is felt positively as a disgrace. It is not that the children will have to suffer physically under the order of things established by the District School Board decree in question which is felt so painfully, but the circumstance that the Jewish children will as such be gathered together into separate classes.
We Zionists, or, more correctly said, since we are a national party in which all political opinions have their place, I and many of my fellow-partisans, are opponents of the confessional school, if by that is understood what ought rightly to be understood, the clerical-antisemitic school. But if by confessional school is understood a school in which the Jewish children are separated from the Christian, or more correctly the Aryan, that is to say the national school, then we see in it anything but a misfortune, and the less so as this in any case signifies an improvement upon the status created by the District School Board decree. The confessional school which at present exists in fact, though not yet in law, brings the Jews nothing but every possible annoyance. The real so-called confessional school, however, would at least have this one good in it, that in place of the antisemitic teachers now employed in the Jewish classes, ill-disposed towards their pupils, there would enter teachers of their own stock, well-disposed towards them. For us Zionists, Jewish and reactionary are by no means identical. On the contrary, we are convinced that the Jewish school will be more liberal than the present so-called interconfessional one, that it will bring up its pupils not in a narrow spirit, but in the spirit of true love of mankind — that love of mankind, to be sure, which, if it does not begin with itself, yet does not end with itself either (Lively applause.) — but above all in the Jewish spirit. (Lively applause.)
One speaker has thought fit to censure here the fact that in a Vienna school the teacher of religion advised the pupils not to attend school at Succoth. I do not know in what capacity this honoured speaker then addressed this assembly. To the question whether he was Jewish-national he answered a decided "No," and of religion he will hear nothing either; wherein, then, does his Judaism consist? (Cries: Very good! and lively applause.) Then he is an adherent of the theory that Judaism should perish as completely and as soon as possible in its present surroundings. What, then, has he to do in an assembly which is convoked to give expression to its indignation at the attacks suffered by Judaism, proceeding from the view that they must be repelled because Judaism must not perish. (So it is!)
We — I believe the great majority of those here assembled — still believe in the vital force of Judaism and are not ashamed to be Jews (lively applause), for this reason among others, that our Judaism is something natural, inborn, not to be put aside. We are of the opinion that we are inferior to no other nation (lively applause), and that which we admire in other peoples, the love of one's own people to the last breath, we will not neglect in ourselves either.
Therefore we should joyfully welcome the Jewish school, because it would foster the Jewish spirit in the rising generation. For in our conviction a great part of the blame for all that men permit themselves against the Jews lies in the want of Jewish self-consciousness, and to have caused that want is the great guilt of the Jewish representative bodies, of the Cultusgemeinden, and in no small part of the Vienna Cultusgemeinde as well.
Enter, my gentlemen, the session-hall of the Vienna Cultusgemeinde and read there the names of the former heads of the Community, and you will find with astonishment how many of these names belong to Judaism no longer. The Arnsteins, Eskeles, Pereiras, down to Herr Pollak von Borkenau … their descendants have all turned away from Judaism. But how can one expect of these men, who were unable to foster and preserve the Jewish spirit in their own houses, that they should strengthen it in the Jewish people! (Lively applause.) It is not enough — and quite particularly in the present heavy times through which the Jews are passing, and in which, in contrast to my esteemed previous speaker Dr. Fialla, I can discover no glimmer of light; it will grow much worse, but certainly not better — it is not enough in these times for the Jews that in the Cultus chamber there sit none but very honourable men who do their duty and — administer. These times and the peculiar conditions of the Jews demand more than mere fulfilment of duty and administration; they demand men who have courage and strength. Had the representatives of Judaism twenty years ago not taken the matter lightly, perhaps much would have been spared us. The gentlemen ought to have borne in mind that they represent 140,000 human beings, whom they should have gathered vigorously about them. But our Cultus representation believed it had done enough by presenting protests which wandered into the waste-paper basket, and by preaching ever anew patience and the speedy return of better times, although every day brought a fresh disappointment. — — To be sure, whence should the gentlemen know the actual conditions! The representatives of the Jewish people are really only representatives of a small part of them. Only he who pays 10 Gulden of Cultus tax is entitled to vote at the election of the representation of the Jewry. Thus it comes about that of the 140,000 Jews in Vienna only 12,000