No. 46 — "Die Welt" — Page 7
(continued from page 6)
…and morality or humanity. With these scanty ruins of religion the rabbis make their parade, and know, as it seems, not at all that with them one cannot coax a dog from behind the stove, and that precisely this, their religious poverty, is the cause of their empty synagogues, and at the same time the cause of the ever-spreading falling away from Judaism. Whoever of his religion, be he Christian or Jew, has kept over only the few fragments is always in danger of losing these too, because these two are not yet capable of producing a religious life, leave the heart cold, and are felt by the understanding only as superfluous ballast. If these two dogmas, unity of God and humanity, were the end of religious development, the peoples of Europe would have attained this goal already in the last century, for then lived the great enlighteners, to whom our modern rabbis are far from being able to hold a candle, and from whom indeed they first borrowed their ideas, in order to disorganize the old Jewish religion and to transform it into a watery Reform Judaism.
Remarkable! The Christian religion has overcome the Voltaire-Rousseau-Diderot-Leibnizian enlightenment without harm, and has remained strong and mighty over hearts and minds; German Judaism, on the other hand, has not been able to withstand the Mendelssohnian enlightenment-mongering, but has let itself be infected and ruined by it, and the German rabbis of to-day are the genuine, if also very petty, epigones of the Mendelssohnian reform-mongering; and these rabbis would persuade themselves and their weak-believing co-religionists that they might one day yet win the world for their Reform Judaism, that this is their mission! Hundreds of considerable Jews have had themselves and their children baptized in the nineteenth century and have been lost to Judaism for ever; but let one name so much as a single Christian of name who has become a Jew! That does not exist in our century. Rather a Mohammedan or a Buddhist or a Spiritist or anything else — only not a Jew; that would indeed be nothing at all: so think the children of our century. Therefore let the mission-rabbis bury their mission-idea, for it was and is a still-birth which, save they themselves, no man holds capable of life. The Christians mock at the mission-idea of the rabbis as at a monstrous birth of the frenzied vanity of boastful pulpit orators; and the Jews, who let themselves long enough be lulled and quieted with these flatteries, are now having their eyes opened too, and they perceive that behind these showy speeches, repeated on every festival day, there is nothing real after all, and that, in spite of their exalted mission, they remain nevertheless the Jews hated and despised by all, whom everybody would gladly be rid of.
It is very sensible of the Zionists that frankly and freely and without fear of the rabbis they lay bare the hollowness of the rabbis' pretensions and protest against the mission-idea, because it has already done Judaism monstrous harm. Countless Jews it has supported in their strivings after assimilation and has justified that striving. If they laid aside their Jewish nationality, their Jewish manners and customs as rapidly and as completely as possible, so that the Jew might by no means be seen in them, then they fancied they were acting precisely in the spirit and sense of the mission of Judaism; for to that end were they scattered among the peoples, to assimilate and amalgamate themselves with them and so to win them for their mission-ideas! If in Germany Jewish thinking, feeling and willing has rapidly dwindled away, so that it scarcely seems able to be awakened any more, then the assimilation-rabbis with their mission-idea are to blame for it.
So far the Zionists are right with their protest and their polemic against the mission- and assimilation-rabbis. But they overshoot the mark and put themselves in the wrong when some of them deny and disavow the whole mission-idea in general, the divine mission and task of the Jewish people towards mankind. That the Jewish people will surely not let be offered to it. Were the question addressed to the Jewish people whether it be the chosen people, which has a divine task and a divine calling among the peoples of the earth or not, then the whole Jewish people would answer this question out of its innermost heart and its deepest conviction with a mighty yes, in the consciousness that it spoke in the sense and spirit of all its wise men of all times from Mosche down to this day, and that whoever loves his people may not lay a finger upon this idea!
The majority of the Zionists also stand upon this standpoint, even if they perhaps do not conceive their hopes and expectations of the future precisely in a definite manner as a "mission"; but they all believe nevertheless that the establishment of a Jewish State in Palestine would be of high significance and of blessed effects for the whole East, for the relations of the three continents which meet there, and thereby for the whole of mankind. If, then, Palestine belongs to the Jews, then they have there also a mission reaching beyond the borders of their land, that is to say, a calling and a task for mankind.
If now the Zionists place the mission in the future and make it essentially dependent upon the possession of Palestine, but are also of the view and conviction that the influence and the operation of the Jewish people upon the other peoples will then and from there be more salutary and more blessed, then the German mission-rabbis will at least not be able to urge much against it, that the mission of the Jews comes to its validity chiefly and in effective wise only in the future. If soberly and honestly they survey the situation and the conditions in the camp of Israel and those of the other peoples, and thoroughly weigh the course of things hitherto, then they will have to admit that in the present the Jewish people fulfils in no wise as yet the mission ascribed to it by them, and that consequently their mission-idea too is rather only an ideal of the future.
The chief difference between the rabbis and the Zionists will accordingly have to be placed in this, that the rabbis are of the view: 1. that scattered Israel in the Golus — which is not to be conceived as Golus at all, that is, as captivity and homelessness — has a mission to fulfil; and 2. that this mission is an essentially religious-moral one, which has nothing to do with nationality and politics, wherefore the Jews might give up everything only not religion — whereas the Zionists set up the assertion: 1. that the Jewish people must first possess home and independence again as a nation before it can work blessedly upon other peoples; and 2. that this mission is pre-eminently and chiefly a cultural and moral one. All the remaining operations, for example the religious also, must be left undetermined and left to the future development.
(To be continued.)
An Anti-Zionist.
By Dr. S. Werner.
When we Zionists consider the host of our opponents, we can often take no joy in the combat. One gladly confronts the chivalrous and honourable opponent. One salutes him too respectfully before the passage of arms begins. Whether one conquers or is overcome, one knows that both are equally honourable. It is otherwise when one has to do with an insidious opponent. There is no open combat then. Then one is struck at with poisoned weapons, and as the prize of the combat there beckons to us at most the consciousness of having fought honourably even in this unequal combat.
To-day I cannot salute my opponent.
The publisher of the "Oesterreichische Wochenschrift," Herr Dr. Bloch, has for some time taken pleasure in an anti-Zionist pose. That would be no misfortune. I even