Die Welt · Vol. IV, No. 13 · 30 March 1900
2printed page
scan 2 of 16

Page 2 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 13

(continued from page 1)

…sets before itself the extermination of the Jews, more radically than was ever yet attempted; for already the negroes are being stirred up, that the hunted quarry may be left no refuge, no refuge whatever. The hatred of the Jews, which formerly blazed up a few times in every century and spent its fury in massacres, has become a chronic disease which makes itself felt at every hour. The surmise lies near at hand that the phenomena of discomfort in the life of the people, which are traced back to the penetration of the Jews into State and society, have very little indeed to do with the Jews; that they are rather mere consequential evils of freedom of movement, of the participation of the masses in political life, of the extension of political rights — consequential evils which, moreover, hardly come into consideration beside the blessings of these innovations. But the discomfort is there, and the blame for it is, after the manner of children and of peoples, laid upon a single scapegoat, the Jews. The privileged classes, whose privileges were depreciated by the liberation of the lower, lent their aid to the seduction of the people.

They hoped to be able to transform the aversion to the Jews into an aversion to all freedom, and thereby to bring about a return to the old bondage. One circumstance came to their help herein. The Jews, who owed to the modern age their deliverance out of the walls of the Ghetto, naturally proved themselves everywhere ardent adherents of modern ideas, and are even now to be found in the foremost ranks of those who would sweep away all that has grown up and set in its place an unspeakably blissful new order. Whoever still has within him any feeling for the good old things must needs bear a grudge against these fanatics of progress with their burning zeal. I will not inquire whether somewhat more reserve on the part of the Jews, at least during the first hundred years after the emancipation, would not have been wiser and more advantageous for them. Temperament, too, is something given, and one cannot demand of hundreds of thousands that they should all order their lives according to a superior insight. Other bad habits, consequential evils of a thousand years of exclusively mercantile occupation, I do not mention. For I would not discuss the causes of the hatred of the Jews, but only answer the question whether we in Europe should have an advantage from it if we succeeded in ridding ourselves of a portion of our Jews.

The struggles between the old time and the new must be fought out; a return to the rigid ordinances of the Middle Ages is excluded. The whole people lays claim to its share in the goods of culture and in the yield of the State. But the struggles for its right should, in the interest of order and of the protection of the goods of culture, be passed through without catastrophes, without convulsions and deliriums, from compromise to compromise. What at the goal may appear as revolution must upon the way have remained always only evolution. To that end we must ward off all inflammatory irritations and prevent blood-poisonings. The existence of a Jewish question amid the emancipation struggles of the century is such an inflammatory irritation, and bears within it the danger of a blood-poisoning. There is no longer any honest discussion between the petty-bourgeois and peasant classes of the people and the metropolitan industrial ones. The agrarian and the guildsman revile the merchant and the manufacturer as Jews or as bondsmen of the Jews; the freedom which trade and traffic require is stigmatised as Jew-freedom. The equalisation between town and country will accomplish itself far more easily if the — in the bad sense — conservative classes do not upon the Jewish point find ever new incitement to bitterness, the liberal and progressive classes not a fetter and a weakening in it. It is therefore the interest of a moderately progressive policy, one that prevents both dammings-up and burstings of dams, to eliminate the Jewish question so far as possible from the party struggle.

But the constantly goaded hatred of the Jews is also, in its reaction upon the Jews themselves, disadvantageous, if not dangerous, for the State. A small percentage of the Jews, the rich and the powerful, who have something to lose, become from fear of the mob reliable props of order; but they in turn discredit the parties of order by their timorously nervous manner, inclined to exaggerations. The adversary's catchword is not slow to appear; it runs: "Against Junkers and Jews," by which of course the great Jews are meant. Conservative property is thrown into one pot with what is surely the least popular portion of the population, the great capitalists of Bourse and bank. But by far the greatest portion of the intelligent and relatively propertyless Jews is thrust into the camp of the wholly radical parties and furnishes these with considerable agitatorial and organising forces. The Jew, who has lived through so many disappointments, sets his last hope precisely upon a total overthrow of all that exists, upon the radical abolition of all privileges, upon the most complete possible carrying through of that equality which socialism promises. The Jewish cerebral man, who as such ought properly to resist the democratic levelling, becomes against his nature a fanatical apostle of equality, and runs to excess, like all men who do not stand upon their own firm feet. Herein is to be discerned the greatest danger for the European populations. Movements which are not to be stayed are excessively accelerated, and thereby the danger of ruinous reverses is conjured up. What might accomplish itself quietly in centuries is to be forced in decades. Catastrophes are then not to be avoided at all.

It is therefore a quite particular interest of a conservative statecraft to open an outlet for these ferments. From an emigration into other oversea or European States there is not much to be hoped, since everywhere the point of saturation with digestible Jewish intelligence has already been reached, and the great reservoir in the East, with its Jews incapable of assimilation or remote from it, is still overflowing. That reservoir has always been styled the misfortune of the Jews, because those who escaped from it hung upon the coat-tails of their advanced western kinsmen and hindered these from complete assimilation. Now it seems as though Providence had preserved precisely this reservoir for its own particular purposes. Only those East-European Jews, still wholly inaccessible to European culture and living faithfully in their traditions, could furnish the bulk of the colonists who would bring the old land of home again to flower and would make it attractive also for those kinsmen who live in an older culture. The small band of amalgamated Jews is unable to draw the bulk after it into European culture; conversely, however, the bulk, so soon as it had once settled itself comfortably, could draw over to itself those western Jews who are not yet wholly amalgamated and who take no joy in their life, thereby winning for itself bearers of culture and relieving Europe.