Page 12. — "Die Welt" — No. 21.
(continued from page 11)
…our own salvation lie in the help which we bring them? In America they are not liked, and now are we not even to strive that they may be able to go elsewhere? — Rev. B. Leventhal spoke in the same sense in the Hebrew tongue. The closing word was had by a Christian Zionist, James Orr. In his very warm address the speaker regretted that Zionism does not find among the Jews that support which it deserves. Zionism, he said, is the fulfilment of the prophetic promises, and he believes that the ideal foretold by the prophet will be fulfilled.
Review of Periodicals.
The "Jüdische Chronik," edited by our fellow-partisan Dr. Adolf Kurrein, enters with its May number upon the seventh year of its existence. On this occasion it brings a retrospect of its activity.
In the "Hameliz" and in "Hazefirah," Rabbi S. J. Rabinowitz of Sopotkin continues to publish the expressions of opinion which have reached him from orthodox rabbis in favour of Zionism.
The Berlin "Conservative Correspondenz" turns in a sharp article against the changes of name among the Jews which have of late been gaining the upper hand. In the press as well as in Christian bourgeois circles there already prevails a strong excitement at the readiness with which the Governments meet such petitions. Men ask whether then every bearer of a Christian name is really defenceless against a Schmul, Levi, Cohn, etc., suddenly transforming himself into his namesake. The paper demands that before the sanctioning of a change of name a public notice be issued to the lawful bearers of the names in question, in order to ascertain their consent.
"American Hebrew" of the 4th of May contains a noteworthy utterance of Professor Gottheil upon the founding, suggested from various quarters, of a Jewish relief fund for the sufferers in India. Prof. Gottheil asks the proposers why then it has not occurred to them to create a Jewish relief fund for the suffering Jews in Bessarabia, where a famine of the same kind rages as in India, or for the Jewish earth-workers in Boryslaw, or for the unemployed diamond-cutters in Amsterdam. Further, it might well be known that in Galicia 5000 Jews yearly fall a prey to death by starvation...
In the same paper we find, under the title "Zionism, its Purpose and its Aim," a larger treatise by Mrs. Benjamin Davis. In this essay the origin and the history of the development of the movement are set forth in an instructive manner.
In an excellent essay in the "Echo Sioniste," J. Caleb turns against the impatience with which in many circles the Charter is called for. This urging springs from the same state of mind which once, several thousand years ago, brought to those waiting at Mount Sinai a golden calf instead of the tables of the Law of Moses. Let us see to it that we too do not, in precipitate impatience, procure ourselves a new golden calf instead of the Charter. The author shows how the ideas originally laid down in the "Judenstaat" have, in the light of the discussions of three Congresses at which representatives of Jewry from all stages of culture were present, become clarified and modified, and have led Zionism into the path of assiduous, purposeful, but cautious creative work. The Jewish distress in many lands is indeed an insupportable one, but it would be to throw out the child with the bath if in precipitate haste one were to plunge Zionism into dangerous adventures and set the whole future of the people at stake. It must not be forgotten that those upon whom the delicate diplomatic tasks have fallen could accomplish their work far more easily if they had behind them, in the face of the world, the honest demand of millions. But are we then already so far advanced? Our Zionism (the author declines to call it the political, because the cultural and the so-called practical are contained in it as well) has, besides the diplomatic, many other preparatory labours to carry through.
The World of Books.
Yearbook for Jewish History and Literature. Published by the Union of Societies for Jewish History and Literature in Germany. Third volume. Berlin, Albert Katz. 1900. 8º.
"For I have been a man, and that means to be a fighter." Doubly and trebly must a man fight if he is a Jew. From the host of enthusiastic champions for Judaism are recruited — with the exception of the Privy Church Councillor Prof. Carl Siegfried, who contributed "the episode of Jewish Hellenism in the post-exilic development of Judaism" — the contributors to the Yearbook that lies before us. The pièce de resistance is Hermann Cohen's excellent, deeply thought-out treatise: "Love and Justice in the Concepts God and Man." Attention cannot be drawn to it emphatically enough. We will make a little anthology from it. The author points to the fundamental difficulty which lies in the foundation of the Christian doctrine of redemption for the true, sincere concept of the neighbour. "No man cometh unto the Father but by me," it is said in the Gospel of John 14, 6. In this word lies the difference in the significance of the love of one's neighbour between Judaism and Christianity. Redemption is, according to the Gospel, conditioned by mediation. Without redemption, however, there is no blessedness. A share in eternal life which was not mediated at least by faith in the idea of Christ can be conceded by no doctrinal conception and by no historical view of Christianity. Thus the concept of man, in so far as he is religiously defined by the concept of blessedness, is dependent upon faith in the Christian idea of God. Above this determination there towers the naive word of the Old Covenant concerning the fatherly love of God. Judaism is more tolerant, more comprehensive; it is universalistic. The God of Judaism is love. Love is His essence. And this His essence we make our own, in that we practise His essence. The love of man alone unites with God. With the concept of God itself and absolutely, redemption is posited. — The Talmud has deepened the idea of the love of one's enemy by a concept which is fitted to render possible the psychological removal of enmity. This is the concept of "groundless hatred." This groundless hatred does not signify, say, a particular variety of hatred to which well-grounded hatred would stand opposed. Rather is hatred in general and in itself designated as groundless. That is the most exalted and most holy judgment which can be pronounced upon this sad and unhappy aberration of the mind. There is no ground for hatred. Every apparent ground is an error. Man is created to love. And when he hates, his existence becomes vain. It is only satanic dialectic which holds out to him the right to hate. The law which teaches: "Eye for eye, tooth for tooth," the lex talionis, signifies satisfaction by an appropriate compensation. The members of the body are to be judged each according to its functional performance and estimated for the compensation. The compensation of the eye for the eye, the compensation of the tooth for the tooth. In injuries which have confinement to bed for their consequence there must also, as the verses (2 B. M. 18, 19) declare, be compensation for the loss of time, and besides this the healing is made a legal duty. "These verses alone make it absolutely contrary to sense that eye for eye could signify retaliation in the strict sense. For then the first injured party would have to make good to the second his loss of time; and since he too will presumably become bedridden, would have also to procure him the physician and to pay the costs of the cure. Thus the judgment would go beyond even that of the wise Daniel."
