Die Welt · Vol. IV, No. 24 · 15 June 1900
3printed page
scan 3 of 16
Facsimile · scan 3 of 16
Scan of p. 3
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 24. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3.

(continued from page 2)

… much. But we know best how false this imputation is. In calm confidence in our own strength we are wholly wanting.

Our new muscular Jews have not yet regained the heroism of the forefathers, who in great numbers thronged into the arena to take part in the games of combat and to measure themselves with the trained Hellenic athletes and the powerful Northern barbarians. But morally they stand even to-day higher than those; for the old Jewish circus-fighters were ashamed of their Judaism and sought by means of a surgical artifice to conceal the sign of the Covenant, as we know from the rebukes of the indignant Rabbis, while the members of the club "Bar Kochba" avow their stock aloud and freely.

May the Jewish gymnastic club blossom and prosper and become a model zealously imitated at all the centres of Jewish life!


Subordination.

By Dr. J. Rülf of Bonn.

There is a word which has as yet found no admission into the lexicon of Zionism: subordination of the individual interest to the general interest; subordination of the private will to the collective will; subordination of personal opinions and inclinations to the settled aims and endeavours of the party; subordination of one's own highly esteemed person to the chosen and appointed leaders and guides of the Zionist community and confederacy. So long, however, as this subordination is wanting, the danger exists that all our endeavours run out into the sand, that the body so hardly held together dissolve and fly asunder into atoms. What does it help us that in our conviction we are and remain Zionists — for whoever has taken the Zionist idea into himself and made it a matter of the heart never again gets free of it — it is only a community working together as one which is able to open up the paths, so very hard of access, to the lofty goal.

It is an immemorial fault of our brethren in race that they are unable to subordinate themselves, that each one will stubbornly walk his own way, remain his own master, carry through his own will. Already that mighty man of God who led the children of Israel out of the slavery of Egypt in order to bring them to the land where milk and honey flows complains continually of the "am ksché ôref," the stiff-necked people, so hard to guide and to lead. And who knows whether, were he to descend again to-day to redeem his people from the modern slavery and to conduct them to the same goal, he would not, just as then, involuntarily cry out from a deeply wounded soul: "Yet a little, and they will stone me!"

Yet this stubbornness is by no means the worst of it; it has also its good side. That faithful perseverance, that endurance, that courage in bearing and unbending will over against every assault of hostile or of alluring demands — qualities which pledge the duration of our people and our faith for eternity — have their firm roots in this stubbornness.

But our teacher and leader Moses had his trouble and his burden not only with stubbornness, but also with malice. This malice was embodied in the company of Korah, which, according to the report of Holy Scripture, goaded on by envy, presumption and conceit, sought to disturb the great national work. Yes, that is a very evil thing, when one has to contend against such children of Belial; and that these will one day vanish from the earth and from the community of the people is not to be thought of; they neither die out nor die away: "And the sons of Korah died not. Ubnê Korach lô mêsu."

That this generation of the Korahites will ever find entry into the Zionist community and gain influence therein we do not fear. The noble and living national feeling which called this community into life, the high and desirable aims which it has set itself, will preserve it therefrom. We have in any case enough to bear already in the insubordination called forth by the lack of subordination. But subordination is the first condition for the continuance of every associated body whatsoever.

Say yourselves! Can you conceive of any State, any corporation, any fellowship, any commune, any society without subordination? The very entrance into and membership of such a community signifies subordination; this is self-limitation and the surrender of the individual personality to the commonwealth, as also compliance and respect towards the central direction; for such a central direction there must likewise be, in which the will and the purpose of the association, framed in a definite programme, comes to expression. A community may set itself a definite purpose, may also provide itself accordingly with legal prescriptions; but to bring these to execution, as also to help the community over all the vicissitudes of life, to employ situations and facts skilfully to its advantage — in a word, to conduct its business with political and diplomatic address — that it cannot do itself, but only the central direction.

Men speak so much of the democratic principle; and Zionism too, when it directs its attention to a founding of a State, cannot conceive the future Jewish State otherwise than under the full and unrestricted validity of democracy. What, then, is democracy — surely not anarchy? No, precisely the contrary! In no constitution of a State is subordination so comprehensive, so powerful and so universally valid as in democracy; a far more perfect one than in the State of wholly unrestricted absolutism. In the latter subordination is a compelled one. How it stands with the subordination of individuals in such a polity withdraws itself from all observation; where compulsion rules, there can be no more talk of subordination at all. Only in the democratic constitution of a State is subordination a general and a voluntary one.

If you cannot subordinate yourselves, then speak no more of a founding of a State. What would you do with a State without subordination and without a supreme direction? You will perhaps say: very well! Only, one may surely not wish to silence us; one cannot surely demand of us the sacrifice of the intellect! — No, certainly not! Speak as urgently as it pleases you, assert your opinion and conviction with the greatest decision. But once the resolution of the majority has determined what shall be aim and purpose, what law, programme, statute, as also who and what the executive central and supreme direction shall be, then you have to submit and to subordinate yourselves and with the greatest readiness to place yourselves with your whole strength at the disposal of the direction of the association. So party discipline demands. And this subordination is the highest and fairest expression of human freedom, at bottom its proper and only expression. What, then, is freedom? — With freedom, of one's own freedom, to