No. 34 — "Die Welt" — Page 5
And what is achieved with these 30 millions, which represent the minimum of what is required? This simply is achieved: that the Roumanian Jews starve to death in America three months later instead of three months earlier in Europe. And whence are even these 30 millions to come? By appeals and collections such a sum is not to be procured, nor anything approaching it. The permanent charitable institutions of the Jewish communities have no surpluses, and as a rule scarcely suffice for the daily demands that are brought before them. The Alliance Israélite Universelle has no millions to distribute. The Jewish Colonization Association — the Ica, as it is called for short — has these 30 millions, and doubtless eight or nine times as much besides; but it is of opinion that it has no right to lay hands upon its capital, and that it may distribute only a part of its yearly interest; and in principle I can only concur, although there are, to be sure, catastrophes which sweep away all principles. What then? I see it coming. First francs will be distributed, then centimes, so long as they hold out; and then one day it will be declared with a shrug of the shoulders: "We have nothing more, we can do nothing more for you; look to yourselves."
My friend the chairman, Dr. Herzl (lively applause and clapping of hands), has just said it, and I can only repeat it — as indeed repetitions will be unavoidable in the reports upon the condition of the Jewish people: we are driving with Niagara swiftness towards a bankruptcy of official Jewry which will be so terrible that I close my eyes in horror, so as not to see it one moment sooner than I absolutely must.
Let not the great men of the Jewish communities come to us with the wretched excuse: "The Roumanian catastrophe finds us unprepared, because we could not foresee it." We should otherwise be obliged to answer them brutally, as Dr. Herzl did before: That is not true! For three years we have warned you unceasingly; for three years we have been killing ourselves with exertions to make the condition of the Jewish people intelligible to you, to show you the dangers that threaten it, to preach to you the one means which makes an effectual defence against this danger possible. But you have not heard us, or have not chosen to hear. (Lively applause.)
What name do you deserve, if you, into whose hands the Jewish people has trustfully laid the guardianship of its interests, nay, the defence of its life — what name do you deserve if you have not thought the speeches and writings of the Zionists worthy of your high attention? And what name do you deserve if you know them and have nevertheless laughed our warnings to scorn and cast them to the winds? Your blind, fanatical enmity against Zionism has brought about the present situation. (Assent on all sides.) Why, then, did we become Zionists? Out of some mystical longing for Zion? Most of us know themselves free of that. (Lively applause.) We became Zionists because the distress of the Jewish people grips us at the heart, because we see with deep affliction that the logic of circumstances must lead inevitably to a rapid aggravation of this distress, nay, to sudden and violent catastrophes, and because the most strenuous, the most painful reflection let us discern again and again but one way out of the straits: the acquisition of a home for the persecuted Jewish millions, secured under public law. (Tempestuous and ever-renewed applause and clapping of hands.)
How wholly different would the situation be to-day if we could say to our Roumanian brethren: "Come! here is the land that awaits you, as a mother awaits her returning sons." (Renewed tempestuous applause and clapping of hands.) No despairing wandering to and fro, no hopeless and anxious seeking, but a joyful marching forward towards a certain goal! And how wholly different would the situation be to-day if the wandering Roumanian Jews found everywhere a firm Jewish national organisation, which would equip them at home for the departure, advise and guide them upon the way, receive and instruct them in the new land! Why have we not this land, why have we not this organisation? Through whose fault? Through yours, through yours alone! Had you these three years past employed according to our counsel the millions which you are now spending — I cannot put it otherwise: flinging away — you would to-day have the land that would be ready to receive the wandering Jews. (Lively applause and clapping of hands.) And had you, with your old, vigorous, but incoherent, but ossified communal organisation, strengthened the beginnings of a general organisation of the Jewish people which we have created amid the most appalling difficulties, the Jewish people would to-day be a living organism, able of its own strength to defend effectually every one of its imperilled members. (Lively applause.) But you have preferred to favour with your millions the endeavours to calumniate, and if possible to strangle, Zionism, and to frustrate our own laborious work of organisation. Therefore the Roumanian catastrophe finds you unprepared to-day; therefore you now offer the pitiable spectacle of old men grown childish, who in face of a conflagration or a flood stare palsied and whimpering at the horrors that break in upon them.
But to all Jews who still have a Jewish heart, and who have nevertheless suffered themselves to be incited against Zionism and turn their backs upon it out of misunderstanding or from other motives which I will not here discuss — to all such Jews I cry: "Bethink yourselves! Lay to heart the lesson of the Roumanian catastrophe! We tell you with bleeding hearts: this is only a beginning! Worse will come! Much worse! What will you do when, after the 270,000 Roumanian Jews, the 780,000 Galician Jews set out upon their wanderings, and when the Russian millions too are set in motion? When a sea of howling and famished human beings shall beat against your own thresholds? I know that there is a means of turning this danger from your dwellings: the closing of the frontiers of the land against the immigration of foreign Jews, pressure upon foreign governments to hold their Jews back by force within the country. I assume, to your honour, that you do not set your hope upon this means. (Applause.)
But if this means is not to be employed, what else have you besides? What plan? What thought? You have nothing, nothing. Therefore we call to you once more in love: "Open your eyes to your responsibility! Be men! A desperate people, even when it cannot help itself, has still strength enough to individuals