Die Welt · Vol. IV, No. 35 · 31 August 1900
10printed page
scan 10 of 16

Page 10. — "Die Welt" — No. 35.

Slouchz (Paris) thereupon reads out, amid applause, a letter addressed to him by Bernard Lazare, who regrets that he is prevented by family circumstances from attending this year's Congress. He (Lazare) would gladly have spoken upon the intellectual and economic elevation of the Jewish people, and holds that we ought as soon as possible to enter upon an effective and practical activity. In particular the Actions Committee should take the initiative towards a great movement in the interest of the Roumanian Jews. An inactivity in this matter would be laid to the charge of the Actions Committee just as here the inactivity of the "Alliance Israélite Universelle" is a crime. (Lively applause.)

At 1 o'clock the forenoon sitting is thereupon closed.

Afternoon Sitting.

In the afternoon sitting, which was opened by President Dr. Herzl shortly after 4 o'clock, the debate upon agitation and organisation is continued.

Rabbi Barischansky takes the Russian rabbis under his protection against the reproach of hostility to culture. The culture which is gained through Hebrew study, and in particular through the Talmud, richly outweighs every other culture. (Lively applause.)

Delegate Schachtel (Breslau) brings forward several wishes of the German national groups with regard to organisation and agitation; especially upon agitation through the press more weight ought to be laid.

Dr. Menczel, as reporter of the Agitation Committee, lays before the Congress the outlines, settled in that committee, of the proposals for amending the organisation statute. The question of organisation is the cardinal question of the present Congress. It is chiefly a matter of establishing at last a firm basis of the organisation. Up to now men have not been quite clear whether the society or the group of a hundred (shekel group) is the lowest stage. The former cannot embrace all who are of Zionist mind, while the latter is far too loose an association. One must strive so far as possible to make of the two a firmly compacted whole. That can be done in two ways.

All societies would have, in the first place, to stipulate in their statutes that every member of a Zionist society is bound to pay the shekel. Then every society would have to be bound, beside its ordinary list of members, to draw up and carefully to keep a register of all shekel-payers to be found in its town (rayon or district). A cadastre is to be established which shall give us information as to how many partisans we dispose of. The grouping of the shekel-payers into electoral groups would have to be effected on the part of the Provincial Committees, which have to notify the central bureau thereof. To the remaining provisions of the organisation statute one might on the whole adhere. (Lively applause.)

Mr. Joseph Cowen (London) gives a retrospect of the activity of the "English Zionist Federation," from which the great extension of the Zionist movement in England appears.

Dr. Wahrhaftig (Galicia) moves, in the name of the Agitation Committee, that the following addition be taken up into Chap. III. of the organisation statute: "Against every election which contradicts the statute adopted by the Congress, the Actions Committee, or in a given case the bureau of the Congress, has ex officio to raise protest and to lay the whole act of election before the Credentials Committee for examination." A second motion of the Credentials Committee runs: "The Congress elects from its own midst a permanent committee of four members and two substitutes. To this committee the Congress secretary for the time being belongs. At a place and upon a day to be agreed upon before the Congress, the Actions Committee has to lay all the mandates before the members of the committee for examination. Upon the ground of the report rendered by this committee the Congress gives its decision without debate. The Actions Committee has to take care that persons against whose election protests have come in shall receive no seat in the Congress so long as their mandate is held to be contested.

Dr. Friedemann (Berlin) associates himself with the view of Dr. Bodenheimer that the Congress should sit only every two years. The Congress is a magnificent means of demonstration, whose effect, however, is blunted by too frequent use. On the other hand, the central committees of all countries should yearly send a number of deputies to an assembly. Against a continual change of the place of the Congress, however, the speaker must declare himself.

Dr. Schur (Galicia) would make it the duty of every local group to pay over to the national groups at least as many shekels as it numbers members. In this way persons who do not pay the shekel cannot belong to the Zionist associations. Further, every Zionist should be bound in the course of a year to bring at least one Jew to the Zionist cause. (Lively applause.) Finally, the Zionist societies should take care that in all places where there are Zionists the girls and women be organised into societies. (Stormy applause.)

Dr. Nordau (stormily acclaimed) recalls that, though it be the task of the Congress to provide for the future of the Jewish people, it may nevertheless not close itself against the present and the demands which the present makes upon it. Jewish misery in its most heart-breaking form is besieging the doors of the Congress hall. In moving words Nordau depicts, after the London papers, scenes of misery which are said to have taken place among the Roumanian Jews wandering through this city. Two of these wanderers are said to have died of hunger in the streets of London. He appeals to the members of the Congress to do something for the alleviation of this frightful misery. It should not be possible to say that 400 Jews had been together for four days and had deliberated upon Jewish affairs, while, as it were before their eyes and separated from them only by the thickness of a house wall, unhappy wandering Jews perished miserably. Do all of you, cries Nordau with a voice trembling with emotion, what you can; give what you have; give, give, give! (The assembly, which had listened to Nordau's words with deep emotion, bestows stormy applause upon Nordau at the close of his address, and under the impression of his words the ladies of the Congress arrange a collection among the members of the Congress, which yields more than 85 pounds sterling for the poor Roumanian Jews.)

Aschkenazi (France) moves that every delegate qualified thereto should place himself voluntarily at the disposal of the Agitation Commission for 14 days every year.

Prof. Dr. Gottheil suggests that in every country a provincial union of the Zionist societies — similar to the English and American "Federation" — should be formed. The Actions Committee should enter into communication only with those societies which belong to such a union.

Goitein (Frankfort-on-Main) takes up a position against Mozkin's exposition of yesterday. The rabbis have in their own way stood up for Zionism. Dr. Gaster, for example, has brought Sir Francis Montefiore to Zionism; that too is a considerable gain. With the proposals of Dr. Bodenheimer the speaker declares himself in agreement, save as regards the courts of honour. For the rest, it should be left to the Actions Committee to decide when it will convoke a Congress. (Applause.)

Dr. Schlaposchnikoff (Charkow) declares himself against the too frequent alteration of the organisation statute. The scheme resolved upon in the previous year has not even yet been properly carried through, and already alterations are to be made in it. If men are dissatisfied with existing conditions, the statute is by no means to blame for it, but rather the Actions Committee, which did not always hold itself exactly to the statute. As against Prof. Dr. Gottheil, he declares himself against the compulsory creation of provincial unions. The Zionists must in every country have the free right to form groups at their pleasure. He likewise declares in favour of the Congress taking place only every second year.

Scheinkin (Russia) proposes, for a more intensive agitation, that pamphlets and writings upon Palestine be circulated on a more extended scale than hitherto, that lectures upon Palestine be held, and that delegates be sent to Palestine by the societies, who upon their return should report upon conditions in Palestine. (Lively applause.)

Mrs. Prof. Gottheil reports upon the already mentioned result of the collection.

Dr. Menczel declares himself against the Congress taking place from now on only every two years. Neither can he assent to the suggestion made by Dr. Schur with regard to the payment of the shekel. In agreement with Dr. Bodenheimer he finally brings forward the following resolutions:

  1. The organisation statute of last year is on the whole accepted anew, but shall be so