Page 8 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 35
(continued from page 7)
…finished result is at hand, communication cannot be made upon every single step. One must simply have confidence in the Actions Committee and must not give up the hope that at last the great goal will after all be attained. (Lively applause.) The only thing to be found fault with is that the organisation is too loose and that the agitation is still far too much dependent upon individual persons and upon accidents. The speaker gives in this respect various suggestions. In particular the press might be employed as a means of agitation. Furthermore propaganda should be made by means of Jargon pamphlets, and the Jewish gymnastic societies should be furthered. As against the remarks of Mozkin, Dr. Menczel observes that one may never injure the religious feelings, since at this time only their national religion holds the Jews together. But neither should the Rabbis be for ever drawing this question into discussion. In conclusion he declared himself completely satisfied with the achievements of the Actions Committee. (Lively applause.)
Loewy (Blackburn) remarks, by way of explanation, that he had earlier spoken only in his own name and in the name of his electors, but not in the name of the English Zionists.
Dr. Herzl (received with jubilant applause): This year too we have no cause to complain of too great a measure of criticism, perhaps because we have not yet laid the final result before you. When this shall once have happened, then assuredly criticism also will not be lacking. The Actions Committee has not to render account of the effects which it has achieved. The question is only whether we have worked enough. The mere maintenance of so widely extended a movement, the continual intercourse with the correspondents in the whole world, signifies an enormous complex of labour. (Lively assent.) The Actions Committee has no more than you give it, and can also give you no more than you have given it. The richer and the more capable of action you make the Actions Committee, the more will it do; the more means you send us, the more shall we expend, for we will spare nothing of that which you send us. (Lively applause and clapping of hands.) All that comes in from the movement is employed for its extension and its strengthening. (Lively applause.)
The speaker thereupon replies to the wishes and complaints brought forward by the previous speakers with regard to the agitation, and declares that as a matter of course the suggestions expressed will be taken into consideration so far as possible, and that everything will be attempted to procure an entrance for Zionism into those lands also in which it is hitherto still unknown. Likewise the encouragement of the gymnastic and teachers' societies will as a matter of course claim the fullest attention of the Actions Committee.
Rabbi Landau has made it a reproach to the Actions Committee that it has thrown the so-called culture question into the Zionist movement and has aroused a suspicion. I can on this occasion only repeat to the Congress what we have said clearly enough from this place from the first moment: In that which we do and in that which we leave undone there is contained for no one any ground for suspicion. We would, however, guard ourselves against this, that under the title of suspicion being aroused there should continually be demanded such assurances as go beyond the goal and have for their content no longer the apprehension, but perhaps the contrary thereof. We endanger no one in his religious sentiments, but we would also most urgently beg that this apprehension, which has an agitatory character, be at last eliminated from our movement. (Lively applause and clapping of hands.) He to whom the declarations which we have given in this direction in so definite a manner do not suffice, has either no confidence in us or he wants something else. (Renewed applause.) This something else, however, seems to me far more indefinite and far more fitted to arouse suspicion than that which we do and that which we say. We have always said, and we repeat it, that for us the Zionist movement is a national rallying-point for all. (Stormy applause and clapping of hands.) We prescribe to nobody, but we would also urgently beg that the pretext of feeling oneself alarmed be from now on let fall, and that men content themselves with what we have so often said: By the culture question it is not meant that anybody is to be prejudiced in his religious feelings.
This declaration which I have now given is, it is to be hoped, clear enough; content yourselves with it. (Lively applause and clapping of hands.) Instead of expending your acuteness and your energy, after a tiresome old habit of our Ghetto life, upon unfruitful things, expend them rather there where our movement can have an advantage from it. (Stormy applause.) Keep present to yourselves what our present task is! The task of us delegates, of us members of the Actions Committee, and of those most distant members of our great union who now, 3000 miles away, follow our discussions with strained expectation — this task is to achieve the readiness of the Jewish people for historical opportunities, or let us say: for a definite historical opportunity, which will arise from the concurrence of various circumstances and which will make it possible to obtain the legally secured settlement of our people in Palestine. That is our task and nothing else. (Stormy applause and clapping of hands.)
A word that has become trivial says: "If thou wilt have peace, prepare thyself for war." If we would attain that which lies at the deepest bottom of our heart, we must nevertheless prepare ourselves for it in a rational manner. Let us not lose ourselves in quarrels and let us seek no wranglings among ourselves, but bethink yourselves that, when the day shall come whereon we shall step before you with the communication, "We are ready!" and you shall ask, "Are you ready too?" you might easily have lost the precious time in idle talk. (Stormy applause and clapping of hands.) If we have not brought you the success, we have brought you our labours, and if you are satisfied with the works of the Actions Committee, you will find the form for it in your vote. (Lively applause.) In now closing the speech in defence of the Actions Committee, I would address yet one demand to the Congress. And it is this, that you exert yourselves in the most earnest manner, while you are still together in the Congress and in the committees, and especially in the Finance Committee, to place at the disposal of the Actions Committee the requisites for the coming year, which will, it is to be hoped, be greater than they were this year. For we can offer good work only if you also put the Committee in a position to satisfy that which you demand of it, and rightly demand. (Stormy applause, waving of handkerchiefs in the hall and in the gallery.)
Dr. Wilenski (Russia) moves that this speech, which signifies a deed, be immediately put into print and distributed in the Congress. (Stormy applause and clapping of hands.)
Dr. Kaufmann (Germany) makes the motion to grant the Actions Committee its discharge and to express to it, as well as especially to its President Dr. Herzl, thanks for its zealous and approved activity. (Stormy, long-continued applause and clapping of hands.)
Reischer (London) puts the question whether the discharge should be granted before the assignment of the balance-sheet to the Finance Committee.
Dr. Herzl replies thereto that, having regard to this question, he must insist that the treasurer's report be first transmitted to the Finance Committee, and persists in this his view, although the delegates Dr. Herbst and Rosenbaum hold such a proceeding to be contrary to the rules of business and declare it unworthy of the Congress to set even the slightest doubt upon the cash management of the Actions Committee. (Lively applause and clapping of hands.)
Dr. Bragin (Russia) makes the motion that no resolution be adopted in this matter, since from the report laid before them one can come to no conclusion.
Dr. Herzl moves that the vote be taken at first only upon the question of the discharge with respect to the general portion of the report, and that the treasurer's report be assigned to the Finance Committee. This motion is rejected, and thereupon the discharge is granted amid stormy acclamation.
Dr. Herzl declares that this was not, as it were, an enthusiastic vote, for the accounts were examined by the auditors for days together. Only he believed that the Actions Committee could not offer enough opportunity to have its accounts examined.
The secretary of the Credentials Committee, Lozinski, thereupon renders the report upon the manner and