No. 48 — "Die Welt" — Page 5.
They demanded a right, not a favour. They promised nothing beyond this, that they would respect the law and be faithful citizens of the fatherland, and no other promise was demanded of them. A gift bestowed and received upon such terms honours the giver as much as the receiver.
Even the great Napoleon came to regret the justice done to the Jews without humiliating restriction, and he required of the Sanhedrin which he summoned to Paris in 1806 that it should give marriage between Jews and Christians free course and remove from the prayers and usages every reference to Zion and to national reunion — in other words, that the Jews should abandon their belief in the Messiah, renounce their national hope, destroy their distinctive character, in short commit national suicide. He did nothing other than what all the mediaeval popes and kings had done who called upon the Jews to go over to Christianity. The only difference is that Napoleon was less brutal in form, and, to be sure, less open as well. His command did not run: "Baptism or death!" but, more mildly: "The sacrifice of all that is essential in Judaism, or the loss of your rights!" To him, the son of the Revolution, the iron centraliser, religion mattered less than the unification of all his subjects.
The Sanhedrin behaved contemptibly. It did not dare to say to the Emperor: "We can neither pledge ourselves in principle to the mixed marriage which must lead to our dissolution in the majority of our Christian countrymen, nor will we tear out of our hearts the hope of national rebirth which through the centuries has upheld us in bondage and persecution." But neither did it dare to say to the Jewish people in France: "Cast thy Judaism from thee; the French freedom thou takest in exchange for it is better." It therefore played the diplomatist on both sides and deceived both. It gave Napoleon ambiguous answers which the Emperor was able to understand as a renunciation of the Messianic faith, of the hope of Zion and of all distinctiveness, although they were probably not so meant, and it sought to maintain among French Jewry the notion that it had preserved their Judaism, while in fact it surrendered it.
The fathers had been joyful confessors before the rack and the stake. The sons no longer dared to be so before the prospect of a slight restriction of the civic rights they had exercised for fifteen years — a restriction which would at most have wounded their vanity a little, or, let us say, their self-esteem. Were the seventy-one Sanhedrists rotten characters? That one may not assert offhand. One must rather believe that inwardly they had already fallen away from Judaism, and that for the merely more comfortable persistence in outward inherited habits they were no longer willing to bring any sacrifice, not even a small one.
The conduct of the Napoleonic Sanhedrin has become the model for Western Jewry. From that time onward it strove after political equality of rights, not that in the better legal position it might develop and maintain itself more freely as Jews, but that it might divest itself of its Judaism.
Napoleon I. knew perfectly well at what he was aiming when he laid his conditions before the Sanhedrin. His penetration saw that the passing over of the Jews to the religion of the State was only a question of time, if they looked for no national resurrection any longer and mingled their blood with the blood of their Christian neighbours. The Sanhedrin apparently did not measure this inevitable consequence of the abandonment of the unassailable ramparts of Judaism, either because it was short-sighted or because it deliberately made no use of its logical faculties. Perhaps, however, the Sanhedrin foresaw the consequences of its resolutions just as Napoleon did, and desired them just as he did. The human soul is an intricate structure whose flowing forms are not easily caught in clear mathematical formulæ. It would seem that for a Jew to whom his Judaism is of no concern the simplest thing would be to have himself baptised. But it is precisely the simplest thing that man does most seldom; and the inwardly lapsed Jew, for all his indifference towards Judaism, would rather — out of convenience, mental indolence, weakness of will, and perhaps also out of some remnant of piety towards the memory of his fathers and towards the impressions of his own youth — strip Judaism from himself quite gradually, as it were imperceptibly and painlessly, than throw it off at a stroke.
The German, the Austrian, the Hungarian Jews stood, consciously or unconsciously, upon the standpoint of the Napoleonic Sanhedrin when in humbly whimpering petitions to princes, ministries and popular assemblies they implored their political emancipation.
The train of thought of all these documents, which now belong to history and which I cannot read without everything within me turning over, is about this: We Jews are no nationality; we are exactly what you are; we neither wish nor hope ever to become a people again; we will lay aside our faults, we will endeavour to become your equals in education also and like you in manners; we ask you only to permit us still to abide by our faith and for the rest to recognise us as citizens of the State; you shall see that we shall prove ourselves worthy of this high distinction.
Not one of these petitions for emancipation, so far as they were accessible to me, contains even the faintest reference to our thousand years of suffering; from none of them sounds the weakest echo of the dying prayers of our blood-witnesses. The Jews did not manfully demand that the old and frightful wrong done to them should in some measure be made good; by their cautious silence upon this point, by their submissive insistence upon their "honest strivings after education," their "progress," their resolve "zealously to pursue the path once entered upon," they implicitly conceded that the accusations of the enemies of the Jews had a certain foundation; and the plain promise to amend carried within it the admission that they had deserved the ill-usage of the past.
"That was diplomacy." No. That was want of dignity. That was miserable beggary. "Ought the Jews then to have blustered defiantly? They would merely have been called insolent, and nothing would have been granted."
Defiance was not needed. A calm pride sufficed. Proudly they should have said: "Do you not think that the shame of persecuting and oppressing a guiltless minority has lasted long enough? Do you not yet perceive that you give yourselves a certificate of barbarism when for the sake of our faith and our descent you withhold from us our natural rights? Does your conscience not yet stir? Does it not bid you atone for the misdeeds which your fathers committed against