Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 1 · 4 January 1901
3printed page
scan 3 of 16

No. 1 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3

(continued from page 2)

...cial procedure gains in exactness and the juridical "investigation of the truth" seeks to secure itself by scientific supports, forensic medicine has gained in importance, and plays in particular an important part in the ritual-murder trials. As proof may serve the considerable influence which the depositions of the forensic physicians exercised in the trials of Xanten (1892) and Polna (1899—1900).

During the first Polna trial men saw with astonishment physicians step up to the bar who, in the name of "science," attested that in the neighbourhood of the corpse of Agnes Hruza there had not been found the quantity of blood which one must otherwise have found. It was easy to draw a conclusion therefrom, and the advocate of the private parties to the suit, the famous Baxa, did so likewise, saying that the blood which had not been found had been used by the Jews. The opinion of the physicians rested only upon negative factors and upon premises which have long since been thrown overboard by science. Does it not then appear, in view of the ruthless hatred which pursues us everywhere, positively necessary — when the accusation of a "ritual murder" is raised against us, when there are further to be found in civilised Europe people who believe in it, and scholars who support this belief with all the might of their anti-Semitic competence — does it not then appear necessary, and to answer to a social need, to take up the question of ritual murder from the scientific standpoint, in order to lay bare the enormous errors which may be committed by the experts, and to establish scientifically the rules of conduct which, in a recurring case, an expert would have to observe in order to find out the truth? . . .

After the young doctor had concluded the dissertation, he was most heartily congratulated by the college of professors "on account of his useful and timely contribution to forensic medicine."

The distinction "very good" (très bien) proves how well the Commission of the Faculty knew how to appreciate the great care with which our fellow-partisan wrote down his thesis, his critical understanding and the correctness of his conclusions. It is but just that we should congratulate our friend upon his courage, which he showed by choosing for his dissertation, in our time and amid this anti-Jewish current, precisely a theme whose matter touches the Jews deeply.

Although the dissertation of Marcus is a purely scientific one, we nevertheless advise all our friends to read it. It contains a short historical survey and a quantity of interesting details which have reference to the ritual murder."


Israel among the Nations.

By Max Nordau.*)

I.

Everyone who has a clear eye sees plainly that at the end of the nineteenth century there is no civilised polity which has not its "Jewish question." The question expresses itself in manifold shapes. Its best-known and strongest expression is anti-Semitism. It is a mere phrase when one says that anti-Semitism is "the shame of the century." So the noble Frederick III. named it. But whoever loves to go to the bottom of phenomena will find no satisfaction in this fine turn of speech, and will seek to fathom the cause of anti-Semitism, its hidden roots.

The enemies of the Jews carry the explanation in their mouths: the Jews are hated on account of their wickednesses. This assertion, however, cannot stand before criticism. These people deceive themselves: first they rebel against their own feeling, but then they seek pretexts in order to justify this feeling of theirs and to quiet their conscience.

It is an old story. Often a man does something evil,

*) From the Hebrew year-book (Sefer Haschanah) edited by N. Sokolow. Translated by Moriz Zobel.

without much reflection, led merely by an unreasoning impulse. Afterwards he devises for himself all manner of grounds of justification, that he may not stand before himself as a villain. The popular tongue has long since characterised this human habit by the proverb: "When one wishes to drown the dog, one says that he is mad." The Jews are not hated on account of their wickednesses; rather do men strive to impute wickednesses to them because they are hated. The statistical data which are collected in all countries — and that not by Jews, but frequently by their adversaries — bear witness in favour of the Jews. Even there, the statistical figures tell us, where the Jews are subjected to restrictive exceptional laws, and might therefore easily use the evasion that their sufferings lame their power of resistance, that want and misery press them down to the level of the ancient Helots — even there the number of criminals among them is not so great as the number of the remaining criminals. And if those people were not ranged among the criminals who in their professional activity make themselves guilty of transgressions of the law, such as bankrupts and the perpetrators of other commercial dishonesties, whose number among the Jews is necessarily greater than elsewhere, — if these were not counted in, then the contingent which the Jews furnish to the criminal class would be vanishingly small. The worst and most abominable crimes, such as murder, unchastity and robbery, occur among the Jews exceedingly seldom. All the marks which the statisticians attribute to a people that stands upon a high level of morality are found in them. The number of premature deaths is small, the number of marriages extraordinarily great among the Jews. In the universities and the secondary schools their number is very high, notwithstanding that hindrances are laid in the way of their admission. Where, then, does the assertion find a support that this class of citizens is morally corrupt, while we yet see that it obeys the laws of the land, of society and of morality, and strives after knowledge and culture in a far higher degree than any other? Or is the guilt of the Jews perhaps this, that the rich among them make a parade of their riches? Granted, though not conceded, that the Jewish upstart is more ostentatious than other parvenus, what follows therefrom? Surely only this, that his taste is little refined, that his behaviour has no polish of the world, and that it is right to close the aristocratic social clubs against him, should he have a mind to force his way into them. But what has that to do with the withdrawal of the rights of man and of the citizen, with the oppressions and persecutions of every kind to which the Jews are exposed?

Another word which the enemies of the Jews constantly carry in their mouths is that anti-Semitism is as old as the Jewish people; therefore the Jews must surely bear the guilt, from of old and at the present time also, of the feeling of hatred which stirs against them in all places. Now it is indeed true that hatred is the evil genius which accompanies the Jews upon all their wanderings; but this circumstance in no way speaks against them, since we see that every people in every age finds another pretext and another form for its hatred. The ancient Romans accused the Jews of worshipping an ass-headed idol; they were then regarded as subverters, as enemies of the order of the State. The Syrians and the Hellenists hated the Jews because these refused to do homage to the Olympian gods, perhaps also because in the Alexandrian age they pronounced the Greek tongue in a strange fashion and with an intonation that sounded unlovely to the Greek ear. In the first period of the