Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 2 · 11 January 1901
4printed page
scan 4 of 16

Page 4. — “Die Welt” — No. 2.


Israel among the Nations.

By Max Nordau.*)

II.

Everything has long since been exactly described, and of late Anatole Leroy-Beaulieu also, in his work “Israel chez les Nations”, has faithfully set forth what the Jews have achieved in the field of science and of art. But the activity of the Jews in political fields has as yet received no illumination. Here and there mention is made of this activity, mostly inglorious and from the Jew-hostile side. The German Antisemite Paul Lagarde, in his “Deutschen Schriften”, inveighs against the franchise which the Jews possess, and opines that they will poison and disintegrate public life in Germany by their participation. Eduard v. Hartmann, the author of the “Philosophie des Unbewussten”, whose acuteness and the trenchancy of whose style have made him a name, asserts in his work “Das Judenthum in Gegenwart und Zukunft” that all Jews without exception belong to the Liberal party, and concludes therefrom that the Jews take part in party life not in favour of their fatherland but in the interest of their tribe, which naturally inclines much more to the religionless and new-fangled free-thought than to the Christian, patriotic Conservatism, whose roots reach deep down into the ultimate purposes of existence, into the life and into the immemorial history of the people.

I will not enter more closely upon the folly of the accusation that all Jews are free-thinking. It is exactly as though one were to come forward against the Jews with the charge that they “one and all strive to send their children to school”, or that they are “one and all averse to drunkenness”. But the assertion of Eduard v. Hartmann is in itself incorrect. Unhappily one cannot say any such thing of the Jews, which could certainly redound only to their honour. Most rich Jews are not liberal but conservative, some even thorough-going reactionaries; and Eduard v. Hartmann knows well that two baptised Jews, Leo and Stahl, were the founders of the orthodox party of the Prussian Conservatives, that it was they who breathed into this party spirit of their spirit, marked out for it its direction, gave it a political and philosophical system, and set it upon the foundation on which it has now stood these fifty years. And to this day the spirit of these two Jews prevails among the Prussian Conservatives. In the same way the baptised Jew Disraeli rejuvenated the party of the Tories in England and conveyed to it new vital force.

In reality the Jew — apart from individual exceptions, of which I shall yet come to speak — is by no means active in political affairs in his quality as a Jew. Among the lands in which the Jews possess civic rights there is not a single one that has its Jewish vote after the pattern of the German or the Irish vote in America. The Jews who are partakers of the franchise belong all of them to the second category mentioned before: to that which does not wish to be recognised and remarked in the land. These people guard themselves anxiously against undertaking anything that might be fitted to draw attention upon them. They do not join themselves together, they found no Jewish electoral committees, they show themselves in no wise assiduous to make their power felt in the electoral struggle. Nay,

even there, where they would be in a position to bring one of their brothers through, they prefer to elect a Christian, and only now and then do they venture to approach one of the parties that stands in need of their help with the shy, humble request that a Jewish candidate be set up in a constituency where no Jews dwell. The East End of London is the only place where the Jews have had the courage to send a Jew into Parliament. In single cities of Europe it has even come to pass that many Jews gave their votes for well-known Antisemites.

By this timid shyness and faint-heartedness they wish to demonstrate before their neighbours how null and meaningless their Judaism has become to them, and how un-Jewishly they already feel. If public opinion is inclined to Antisemitism, the Jew must, according to the theory of assimilation, himself become an Antisemite. At the elections which took place in France in the year 1898 many Jews supported the French Nationalists and Antisemites, and the Jew Klotz cried down from the tribune that he could let himself be elected only upon the condition that all the electors should declare themselves against the revision of the Dreyfus trial. In Berlin the Jews might here and there have decided the elections in their own favour, but found not the courage to set up a candidate from their midst. The Socialists, who hitherto cannot be reckoned among the Antisemites, elected the Jew Singer; but among his electors there was not so much as a tenth part of Jews, and he was elected not as a Jew by Jews, but as a Socialist, in spite of his Judaism, by Christian Socialists. In Galicia the number of Jewish inhabitants amounts to 12 per cent. of the total population; their share in the elections ought accordingly to amount likewise to 12 per cent., but reaches only the height of 2·8 per cent. Only in Algiers is there a kind of Jewish vote; its results, however, are most unfavourable. The Decret Crémieux granted to the Jews of Algiers in the year 1870 the rights of French citizens, and among them the franchise. But these Jews had not yet made European civility their own, and were therefore not sufficiently prepared to make a reasonable use of their franchise; they followed accordingly, as a flock of sheep follows the bell-wether, their congregational elders, by whom they were misused in furtherance of their own selfish ends. These drove a trade with the election; whoever paid more was put up as candidate, and the Jewish electors gave him their votes for 5—10 francs. Thus the parties to which the Jewish vote did damage became rabidly antisemitic, not through the fault of the Jews, but through the baseness of the rich, who offered voting-cattle for sale — and the end of the animosities and frictions will presumably be the abolition of the Decret Crémieux. As is well known, the Jews are wholly guiltless therein. The blame falls only upon the circumstances of the time. The Jews were not ripe for the attainment of the franchise, and when they obtained it, the high and mighty great ones fell upon it, who are greedy only after dominion, ambition and gain. These fattened themselves upon the fat morsel, and the Jewish mass must now bear the cost.

Wherever and whenever the Jews have been in possession of political rights, never did they know how to use them to their own advantage; on the contrary, they often worked directly into the hands of their adversaries. They did this because they hoped by such submissiveness to meet the evil rumours, and to make manifest before all the world that they exercise their civic right dutifully not as Jews, but as children of the land.

And the Jewish deputies are still worse than their electors, and stand behind them yet in Jewish consciousness. To anything else are they sooner found ready,


*) From the Hebrew year-book (Sefer Haschanah) published by N. Sokolow. Translated by Moriz Zobel.