Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 2 · 11 January 1901
2printed page
scan 2 of 16

Page 2. — “Die ✡ Welt” — No. 2.

(continued from page 1)

…important rights which the Porte grants to the Jews in Palestine by this Irade stand at most in remote relation to those securities in public law which political Zionism strives after.

But what emerges unambiguously from the new ordinance is this: that not only does the ill-humour of the Porte against the Jews and against Zionism, signalised by the “Polit. Corresp.”, not exist, but that precisely the contrary is true. The Porte stands in a very friendly attitude towards the Jews. What, in the face of this fact, clearly documented by the latest ordinance, could have moved the “Politische Correspondenz” to its Constantinople picture of sentiment remains inconceivable.

We are now curious whether the anti-Zionist papers, for which the report of the “Polit. Corresp.” was, according to the Viennese phrase, a “choice morsel”, will be loyal enough to correct the report and the commentaries attached to it in accordance with the new Turkish intelligence. The “Jewish Chronicle”, which has received the communication concerning the new ordinances both from Jerusalem and from Constantinople (“Important Privileges of the Porte”), has already gone before with a good example. To be sure, the “Jewish Chronicle” did not from the outset let itself be taken in by the report of the “Polit. Corresp.”

It will be very interesting to test the other anti-Zionist papers as to their loyalty and the honesty of their opposition.

The Jews' Night.

By Eli Samgar. (Berlin.)

On Thursday, the 27th of December 1900, some sixty men came together in the house of the Bne-Brith Lodges to deliberate upon the proposal of Professor Philippson — upon the German Judentag. And when, after five hours of deliberation, they went home, one saw that for the Jewry of Germany the day has not yet dawned, that the deep, black night of the — “enlightenment” of our leading men still darkens their minds. Our leading men! It was touching for the cool observer, but to the Jew who looks out with burning longing for the spring a strangling pain, to see the leaders of Israel at work. Those who, full of hope, full of Jewish pride, had wished to create the Judentag went home with bowed heads. That they had not expected, could not have expected. They saw, after all, so much young, sprouting life in Israel; they saw the students' unions, the Zion societies, the literary associations, the gymnastic movement — but the “leaders” in Israel they did not see. For resistance they had to be prepared. But for another kind! They thought of those who held it the easiest thing of all to do nothing whatever, so that the Jews might appear less dangerous to the Christians too — since they seemed not to exist. Many of these worthy men doubtless also said to themselves that nothing really significant, nothing positively redeeming, could be created in any case. Wherefore, then, the excitement? Yet others — one might call them optimistic pessimists, if they were fatalists out of indolence — they write and cry: It is appalling, all the misery about us, the social ignoring, the ruthlessness of the State, and appalling all the misery of the falling-away in our own ranks — but against that we simply can do nothing; we can only console ourselves, for in our religion, which has preserved us so long, there are unknown, indestructible forces which will bear Judaism out beyond the sorrow of all the ages.

Over objections of that kind the creators of the Judentag would surely have passed lightly. Nor did they lose heart; for they felt the strength within them to carry impetus into the sluggish, and into the Messiah-craving a joy in creation and a sense of the present. But for the goodly host of the reasonable, the real, the practical, who always and everywhere ask, “What good is that to me?” they had a sedative also. The Judentag was to create a comprehension of all existing Jewish organisations: of the literary societies, of the Union of Congregations, of the German Citizens of the Jewish Faith, and so forth. They were clear that they thereby declared — what we Zionists have always said — that all the institutions hitherto existing for the raising, nay, even for the mere preservation, of Judaism in Germany had proved themselves lame in the loins. In particular it had to be taken as an admission of impotence that it was precisely Professor Philippson who summoned the Judentag — Philippson, the chairman of the German-Israelitish Union of Congregations, that most important of Jewish organisational creations. But even with those timid ones who did not wish to betray their weakness, and with those malicious ones who would mock at the weakness openly shown, the arrangers hoped to be able to deal. They knew whom they really had to fear. When in No. 41 of the “Welt” (1900) I attempted to throw light, as a Zionist and a Jew of Germany, upon Philippson's suggestion, I wrote: “We must not forget that every advance which we make as Jews in Germany depends upon the overcoming of political Liberalism.” A Judentag would be an advance, even if it brought forth nothing positive, if it only created a forum from which we might lay our sorrow before the Government and before our Christian-German fellow-citizens. But this advance, millimetric as it might be, has been checked by the power which political Liberalism still has over the bent of mind of the leaders of German Israel.

The whole preliminary conference resembled a Liberal district meeting sitting in secret. Those gentlemen who long for a soft parliamentary seat one can still understand. Dr. Max Hirsch, too, need not excite us; he confesses openly that he indeed knows nothing of Judaism, but that he is against the Judentag because he would gladly represent all grievances in the Diet. Complaints from the ranks of the Jews, however, have never yet come before his eyes (in the form of petitions). But what was appalling, nay shattering — that was that of the 60 representatives more than 40 set their hope upon Herr Rickert and “our Christian friends”. Of God there was no speaking — for that there were too many Protest Rabbis present! The God of Israel is now Rickert. He is our hope, he is our banner, our shield and shelter in the roaring of the storm. Our song and singing is Rickert! And Rickert is against the Judentag. So, then, are we. Rickert says the Jews are doing well in Germany. Then we are doing well. Rickert says there is no difference between Germans and Jews. Then so it must be.

And after all, whither is that to lead if the Jews begin to have selfish desires — what is there a Freisinnige Vereinigung for in the