Page 10 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 32
The first bureau of the French Zionist Federation has constituted itself as follows:
President: Dr. Alexander Marmorek; Vice-President: Herr Jacobsohn; Secretary: Herr Schereschewsky; Treasurer: Herr Arnstamm.
Upon the tasks of the new Federation a contributor to the "Echo Sioniste", signing himself with the cipher J. D., expresses himself in the following manner:
"A twofold task falls to the French Zionist Federation. Besides the winning of the native French Jews to Zionism, which is to form the chief purpose of the Federation, yet another goal beckons to it, possibly a more modest one, but at all events no less noble and no less worthy to be striven for. There exists in Paris a Jewish proletariat of 20,000 souls, consisting for the greater part of Russian and Roumanian Jews. They are poor workmen who have fled from the persecutions to which they were exposed in their homeland and have sought refuge under a friendlier sky. This mass of people knows neither the language nor the manners of the country it inhabits, and lives on in profound ignorance. The few among them who have attempted to penetrate into the circles of the French workmen found before them, unhappily, a state of things wholly unintelligible to them, a social development whose preliminary stages and original grounds are entirely unknown to them. Carried away by the fine but hollow catchwords of the parties, they were not able, as the proletariat of the West is able, to sift the chaff from the wheat. And so it came about that they ran themselves fast in bizarre ideas, lulled themselves in dazzling illusions and chased after theoretical castles in the air. That they have nevertheless for the most part remained within the bounds of reason they owe solely to the inherited soundness of Jewish sense.
To this proletariat, then, the new French Federation must turn; its education devolves upon her. She is to give it the instruction it lacks. She has here a great work to accomplish — a Zionist work and a human work. A human work, in that she teaches these people to know their true rights and their true duties and imparts to them the fundamental notions of modern civilisation which they lack. But a Zionist work, in that she shows these Jews their true position in the world, in that she sets their true situation plainly before them, in that she awakens in them the feeling of their twofold proletarianism, as Jews and as workmen. And when the Zionist thought then lays hold of these simple souls, untouched by the corruption of modern life, it will bring forth the fairest fruits.
That is the twofold task which the French Zionist Federation has to fulfil. It is a giant's task, yes indeed; but by courage and perseverance — qualities which no Zionist can do without — we shall attain the goal. And so we call to these first champions from the bottom of our hearts: Good courage and the best of success!"
A Rescuer of Judaism.
In No. 27 of the "Gegenwart" a "Jewish German" who calls himself Juda Monens published an essay which he headed "Towards the Rescue of Judaism". He desires, as he sets forth in the essay, to "save" Judaism by a reform which is to remove from it everything "un-German" that "unworldly rabbis" have carried into it. In No. 30 of the "Gegenwart" this plan of rescue now undergoes a trenchant dissection at the hands of our fellow-Zionist L. Estermann of Neubrandenburg. Our readers will assuredly thank us if we here quote verbatim some passages from Herr Estermann's ingenious exposition.
"The cure which Herr Juda Monens would take in hand upon a Judaism that in his opinion is grievously sick seems to me a true and proper Dr. Eisenbart cure" — so Herr Estermann begins.
"Benedictus Levita, against whom Herr Juda Monens's article is directed, agrees with him that Judaism presents a grievously sick body. But he has at least not the ambition to cure a disease whose aetiology and pathologico-anatomical basis are unknown to him. The alarming outward symptoms that offer themselves to his layman's eye move his compassion, and he holds it advisable to end by one short and vigorous coup de grâce the long-drawn torments of the creature apparently given over to death. Not so Herr Juda Monens. It does not so much as occur to him to give the patient up. A little operation, which he performs cito tuto et jucunde, will quickly remove the at bottom quite harmless complaint. He merely strikes off the patient's head, and offers every guarantee that he will never again be plagued with toothache.
Herr Juda Monens appears hitherto to have troubled himself precious little about Judaism; otherwise he must have known that the remedy he proposes is precisely fitted to bring about the very effect which Herr Benedictus Levita, whom he combats, aims at by his opposite suggestion.
He must have known that his proposals of reform for Judaism do not possess even the charm of novelty; that in the capital of the Empire, for example, a Jewish Reform congregation with exactly the same programme has existed for decades past; but that precisely within this congregation the number of those who have their children baptised betimes is, relatively and absolutely, the greatest.
In two places Herr Juda Monens lays stress upon his belonging to the younger generation. That shall be believed of him without more ado; but the psychology of that generation he knows ill. The reasons he assigns for the younger generation's turning away from the Jewish religion may hold good for his own person; in generalising them he does the younger generation an injustice.
According to Herr Juda Monens the objective investigator arrives at the result: "The Jewish religion, as it is now practised, is antipathetic to us for this reason, that it does not stand in harmony with German feeling."
That is, to put it mildly, a nonsense, and the emphasis laid upon Germanism here, as in several other passages of the article, is completely out of place. I am quite willing to believe Herr Juda Monens his German feelings, and I should believe them still more if he paraded them less obtrusively. But the German feeling of the Jews has nothing whatever to do with the turning away of the Jewish youth from religion. Such a thing one may write now and again in a leading article of the "Mittheilungen des Vereines zur Abwehr des Antisemitismus", but then one does not also lay claim to being an "objective investigator". For otherwise the augurs smile all too ironically.
The turning away of the younger generation from religion is indeed an undeniable fact, but by no means characteristic of the Jewish youth alone. We observe this phenomenon in the younger generation of the whole civilised world. The achievements of natural science in the last decades have deeply shaken the foundation of all religions, and modern man has as little devotion for the simple Lord's Prayer as for the psychologically more complicated Jewish grace after meat, which Herr Juda Monens sets before us as a deterrent example in a scandalously bad translation.