No. 35. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3.
(continued from page 2)
. . . bring us words out of which the soul of those facts will speak to us.
And it will bring us yet much else, and great things. Out of the organisations newly formed in several countries new points of view will arise for the centralisation also. The questions of the raising, which were sketched in London, will be discussed in their full significance as one of the most necessary roads to our goal, and in the whole manifoldness of their problems. The entry of the Jewish Colonial Bank into business life, the formation of the National Fund, will stand in the front rank of the discussion. Upon these and some other points we shall communicate something in the coming numbers, which may give occasion for suggestion and for exchange of opinion.
We look forward to the fifth Congress with proud confidence. We mean to do everything to shape it into a working festival of labour, of the spirit and of beauty . . . . . .
Like mountain fires our Congresses blaze up in the heavy night of the Exile. We gaze into the rich streaming play of flame, moved to our inmost depths. And the blessed dream of a dawn begins softly to stir its wings. B.
The Zionism of the Western Jews.
By Max Nordau.*)
It is clear that Zionism cannot mean the same thing to the Jew of the West as to the Jew of the East. We have never been blind to this fact. We have always emphasised it since our first stepping forth into public life. But not all of us have always kept it present to their minds. Hence certain errors in the propaganda, which must necessarily cause ill-feeling, indignation, disappointment, discouragement.
For our brethren in the East Zionism simply means everything, the whole of life, the individual as well as the national, the material as well as the moral. It is reinstatement in human dignity and redemption out of slavery. It is the daily bread and the honour of manhood. It is the key to culture and the bridge to the great highroad of progress. For the Jews in Russia, Roumania, Galicia, and doubtless in Persia too, the question presents itself simply thus: "Will you starve? Will you go to ruin in filth and misery? Will you be treated worse than the dear cattle? Will you be more deeply despised than the inmates of the penitentiaries? Very well, then remain what you are, sink ever deeper into your morass, do not bestir yourselves, do not strive, make no exertion. Do you, on the other hand, wish to be freed from your distress? Do you wish to attain the rights of man and of the citizen? Do you wish to be placed in the same economic, political and moral conditions under which all other civilised peoples fight out their necessary struggle for existence? Then join yourselves to Zionism, strengthen it by your adherence, raise it to a political and economic power that must be reckoned with. You will certainly not attain the goal on the instant, but the mere hope and the active preparation of your future destinies will on the instant lighten your present misery."
To the Jews of the West one obviously cannot speak in this manner. They feel profoundly ill at ease, but they will not come to clearness concerning the causes of their discomfort. Antisemitism at present embitters their life a little, but they console themselves with the thought that it is a rapidly passing phenomenon. In all the countries of the West
*) From the latest number of the Berlin "Israelitische Rundschau".
there arise counsellors well disposed toward Jewry, who recommend to it an infallible remedy against the evil disease of the time, antisemitism. In Germany the worthy Benedictus Levita proposes to the Jews that they have their children baptised, should this method of treatment be inconvenient for the grown people in their own case. In France the learned S. Reinach advises the Jews, in a Jewish communal paper that is supported by the Consistory, to eat pork, which is considerably cheaper than the flesh of ritually slaughtered ruminants. In this way they would be able to bear the competition of the Christian workmen under more favourable conditions; they would work themselves up out of their present poverty into prosperity; but well-to-do Jews would have nothing to suffer from antisemitism. This the author of that profound instruction, a twentyfold millionaire, knows, namely, from his own experience. In England Simon and Claude Montegue preach a progressive development of the Jewish faith into a pure theism and ethism, which must necessarily make it the world-religion of all the cultivated and enlightened, whereby every antagonism, every difference between Jews and Christians would vanish of itself; and in America the Reform rabbis are setting about the carrying out of this clever programme. In Italy, finally, the matter is taken in hand practically, with a renunciation of all theorising. There mixed marriage passes for the right and gratifying solution of the Jewish question, and in the so-called "good" families it has become downright a principle to marry the children to Christians only.
All these remedies, though differing from one another and more or less pretentious, have this one thing in common, that they strive after the dissolution of Jewry.
What can Zionism offer to such Jews as feel their Jewishness at the least a burden, frequently a disgrace, and think of their parents and forefathers only in order to be vexed with them, because they were not so sensible as to have themselves baptised thirty or three hundred years ago, and by this loving forethought to remove the antisemitic thorns from their path of life? The interchange of speech between Zionism and them takes about this course:
"Zionism is the only means of preserving Jewry."
"That is precisely what we reproach it with. We do not wish Jewry to be preserved; we wish it to disappear."
"Zionism guarantees to the Jewish people a national future and dignity."
"Nonsense. There is no Jewish people, only a Jewish religion, and of that we think nothing. We are vexed enough over our Jewish past and present, and now we are to have a Jewish future as well? No, thank you! National dignity? Is the trade in old trousers to become an ideal content of life; is Mauscheln to attain the gentility of the guardsman's snarl; are flat feet and a crooked nose to be the epitome of manly beauty? In such a transvaluation of values we do not believe, nor do we in the least desire it. But of other national traits than those mentioned we know nothing in Jewry — at any rate the comic papers, the music-hall songs, the suburban farces and the Dresden picture-sheets, from which we draw our knowledge of Jewry, have spoken to us of none."
"Zionism makes out of the Jewish helots full men and full citizens."
"That we already are in law, and we shall be so socially as well, so soon as we have but stripped off our Jewishness so completely, or so skilfully con-