Page 2. — "Die Welt" — No. 37.
(continued from page 1)
…“Zionism strives to create for the Jewish people a home in Palestine secured under public law”, there were arguments of such force and weight, so palpable and, for the discerning, so indubitably sure, that they could withstand the strictest scientific rigour — quite apart from the fact that they were worked up in truly scientific form in books and writings. Only when, with the development, the questions of the second and third rank began to make themselves felt, did the want appear — if not of general, yet of detailed knowledge of the matters. The Zionist Congresses, it is true — there is still lacking the comprehensive work which should sift the material, in part very valuable, laid down in the protocols — brought us a considerable increase of Zionist knowledge. In the Zionist journals, too, the attempt at a scientific treatment of some matter or other was not seldom made. But the book-literature has lagged behind. A glance at the Zionist bibliography teaches us that, after fine scientific beginnings, the popular pamphlet of enlightenment and belles-lettres now dominate. And yet, if anywhere, one ought to find scientific character first in our books, in which alone there is room for serious fulness of treatment.
But if the scientific further development of Zionism does not keep even pace with its outward progress, that is a state of things which may well be excused in view of the pressing labours of the first years, which was perhaps even unavoidable, but which we may no longer suffer to continue now, in these times of gathering. In the earliest times it was, moreover, chiefly a matter of upholding our cardinal doctrine, for which we had sufficient armoury. Now, however, the subsidiary questions of Zionism demand of us answer and solution, which we may not refuse.
By practical examples one will best perceive that the demand for scientific deepening is more than exaggerated pedantry.
We choose questions belonging to different domains of Zionism: say that of the most suitable method of colonisation, that of intellectual elevation, that of the political activity of the Jews. They are questions which in the course of the years have pressed themselves upon us with natural necessity, and whose settlement we may not go out of our way to avoid. Here and there individuals have in truth attempted the settlement, setting about the subject with greater or lesser friendliness. In doing so it happened that upon the same point opinions were uttered which are wholly opposed to one another. Some, for instance, hold a political activity of the Jews to be disadvantageous; others plead for it warmly. The opposition of views would now be no fault, if science came after it; if there followed a comprehensive work, a serious, trustworthy examination of the arguments and a positive decision by those called to it, which should exclude unjustified divergence of opinion, or still worse conditions — obscurity and distraction within our own camp. Nay, it goes even further: in certain domains no activity whatever can be unfolded — unless the undertaker take upon himself an irresponsible risk — so long as Zionist science has not marked out the ways for it; thus, to choose an example, in the domain of “economic elevation” . . . .
The examples and the arguments for the necessity of a scientific Zionism might be multiplied. That seems to us not needful. But it does seem to us needful, in the face of the Fifth Congress, to raise aloud the demand for scientific character.
What kind of union one should choose, what outward form one should give to scientific research, whether it should consist of corresponding members of all countries, whether it should be a permanent commission united in one place, what name it would have to bear — a Zionist Academy, say, or another — that appears not so important, and may be discussed later. But the recognition of the necessity of scientific character should govern the Congress. There, precisely, there will be distinguished men and eminent scholars; it is for them to take the first steps. In scientific Zionism every following Congress will then find its chief support. To the Congress the well-weighed word is conveyed, and it would have to have it turned into deed. Science and life would there come splendidly together.
A survey of the most important matters which we have to master teaches us the greatness, but also the necessity, of the scientific tasks. In what follows we would give only modest indications, laying claim neither to completeness nor to system, of what above all appears worth knowing. Accordingly the domain of Zionism might be divided according to the following points of view:
-
I. Zionism (in its first and most essential constituent) as a movement for a home.
-
- The present situation of the Jews.
- a) Economic, social, cultural situation.
- b) Statistics thereon.
- c) The nature of the Jewish distress.
- d) The nature of Antisemitism.
-
- Catastrophes and (individual) emigration.
-
- a) The question of colonisation.
- b) The colonisations hitherto.
- c) Methods of colonisation.
-
- a) The constitution of Palestine: I. Flora, II. Fauna, III. Climate, IV. Bases for industrial, manufacturing and commercial undertakings.
- b) The (constitutional, international and private-law) questions of the securing of the home under public law.
- c) Questions of colonial policy.
-
-
II. Development and history of Zionism.
-
III. The organisation of the political Zionists.
- a) Structure.
- b) Propaganda.
- c) Funds.
-
IV. Zionism as a view of life.
-
V. Zionism in its (active and passive) relation to Jewry.
- a) The questions of physical, economic and intellectual elevation.
- b) The Jewish relief societies.
- c) The Jewish communities and institutions.
-
VI. Zionism in its (active and passive) relation to non-Jews.
- a) Activity in political life.
- b) " " social life.
- c) " " cultural life.
-
VII. Zionism in its relation to the questions that move the age.
In the following articles we shall attempt to enter more closely upon the scheme itself and upon individual special questions. (To be continued.)
