Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 40 · 4 October 1901
3printed page
scan 3 of 16
Facsimile · scan 3 of 16
Scan of p. 3
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 40 — "Die Welt" — Page 3

Colonisation Proposals.*)

A critical comparison by Dr. E. Simonson, Schöneberg. (Conclusion.)

We have hitherto left undiscussed the question how, according to Oppenheimer, the lender of the money is to be reimbursed without the growth of the colony being thereby arrested. After what has already been set forth we need now waste no more words upon it. First, the security of the capital lent: since the lender places at the disposal of the co-operative society that is to be formed nothing but the requisite landed property, the necessary stock and working capital, only the cash capital can from the outset be regarded as imperilled in the event of a failure of the undertaking, inasmuch as land and stock, through the labours performed upon them, can fall back to the owner only increased and not diminished in value. For the further security of the working capital there is to be deposited for the lender a guarantee fund to the amount of one year's interest upon the total loan, in trustee securities, forfeited at the moment when the co-operative society fails to meet its obligations, as security for losses that might arise in the event of a failure at the moment of collapse. This guarantee fund is formed out of the business profits which fall to the individual members at the end of the year, after deduction of the charges, over and above the daily wage customary in the place. Finally, the security of the movable capital is still further strengthened by the fact that the lender is accorded a decisive participation in the choice of the directing expert and in the financial management.

As gain for the lender there is provided:

  1. An interest of 3% upon the whole of the advances for the acquisition of land, for stock and for the working fund.

  2. A founder's profit of 300,000 francs, likewise bearing interest at 3%, but only from the sixth year after the taking over.

  3. The whole of the advances, including the founder's profit, are to be redeemed according to an amortisation plan to be agreed upon.

  4. a 1 per cent. tax upon all profits acquired by the members of the co-operative society (handicraftsmen and manufacturers included) upon their own area through productive economic activity, according to the books of the co-operative bank, or else according to the result of the official assessment for taxation.

Upon these calculations of the chances of gain we need not enter in detail, if only because they are drawn up for German conditions and would therefore in any case require expert recasting at many points. Here, however, it may well suffice to have shown that the advances lent for the experiment are, even in the event of failure, imperilled at most to a minute fraction. And that at least would seem to follow from the above considerations with a probability bordering upon certainty.

The Ica possesses in Galilee connected tracts of land large enough not only for the first experiment, but, in the event of success, for extensions and for new undertakings of the same kind. The objection raised from that quarter, that the experiment would in the event of failure cost a million francs, cannot, as we have seen, be maintained.

We live in a time in which the fundamental ideas of land reform have already won so much


*) In the portion of my essay "Colonisation Proposals" contained in No. 30, on p. 3, 2nd column, 7th line, "the form of the" is to be struck out, and instead it should read "to the old," etc. Further, in line 8 "land legislation" instead of "land-culture legislation," and in line 22 "deferring" instead of "deferrable."

power that the public conscience can no longer dispose of them shortly with mockery and silence. We have seen the power of these ideas at work when the president of the League of German Land Reformers, A. Damaschke, in his pamphlet "Cameroon or Kiaochow?" called out to the head of the German colonial administration, v. Buchka, who had delivered the colonial soil over to the speculators: "You must go from your place, Herr v. Buchka!" — a call which very soon fulfilled itself. We have seen how in Kiaochow, under the direction of Admiral v. Tirpitz, and probably upon the direct initiative of the German Emperor, the land legislation was so framed that a large share of the rising ground-rent remains at all times secured to the community. We have further seen only lately how even the Prussian Government, in face of the housing distress, could not forbear to direct the municipalities to the provisions of the Civil Code concerning the right of building lease. In such case the Ica too will not in the long run be able to dismiss out of hand as a Utopia the settlement co-operative of Oppenheimer, the most conservative of all land reformers.

Within the compass of this paper the details of the organisation could only be touched upon, and many an objection and question will still press upon the well-informed reader, for the answering of which I can only refer him to the study of Oppenheimer's books*) upon the subject. — Only upon two possible objections should I like in conclusion to enter, objections which lie near at hand for one acquainted with the conditions, and which were also made to me on the occasion of an oral discussion of these matters by a gentleman standing near to the Ica, to whom expert knowledge of the relevant conditions cannot be denied.

The first objection is this, that with the low prices of land in Palestine the ground-rent has by no means the great significance that it has in Germany. The handicraftsman, it is said, can in Jaffa, the dearest soil in Palestine, likewise obtain land for a dwelling-house at a low price. To this it is to be replied: in the co-operative colony he is to be given not only the room in which to work, but also a market of purchasing power in which to turn his work to account. With the interlocking of all the factors, as we have described it, a population of 3000 souls embracing all ranks will find upon the 30 hectares of our co-operative land an existence worthy of men and independent. It cannot fail that, in the event of success, the number of these colonies must soon increase. With the success of the plan we shall have transformed cheap arable land into urban dwelling land and industrial land. Even though under present conditions the ground-rent is not of preponderant significance, yet the price of the soil would soon, in the hands of a watchful speculative class, shoot upward, quite as elsewhere, with rising economic prosperity, if it were not precisely withdrawn from such speculation. A small foretaste of the increment rent to be expected is, however, already given us to-day by the conditions in the colonies near Jaffa. There the day-labourers complain that they live "as dear as in Paris." For a single room they must pay their masters, the colonists, 15 francs rent. The rent for a family dwelling they cannot afford at all, and are therefore compelled to lodge wife and children in Jaffa, where they visit them only on the Sabbath.**)

The second objection is this: With our human-


*) "The Settlement Co-operative"; shorter and suited for an introduction: "Free Land in Germany."

**) It would lead too far here to refute the apprehension that the spread of the system might be frustrated by the neighbouring land in private possession becoming an object of speculation. Upon this let him who takes an interest in the matter consult Oppenheimer's writings.