No. 41. — "Die Welt" — Page 7.
(continued from page 6)
… at the disposal of a national-Jewish artists' evening shortly to be held in Berlin.
*
We shall return to the artistic significance of Josef Israels in a detailed appreciation, and hope before long to be able to report, in another connection also, upon an important exhibition of his national-Jewish sheets.
A Jewish Students' Day.
We reported in our last number upon the Jewish Students' Day which takes place on the 15th of October at Lemberg (in the hall of the society "Jad Charuzim", Bernsteingasse). In contrast with earlier Galician students' days, the Zionist students have this time invited those of other opinions also to take part in the deliberations. The practical points of the order of the day, too, are so chosen that non-Zionists as well might co-operate in the actions resolved upon. We approve this principle, which is fitted, beside the natural union through the idea, to create a working union of all who stand upon the ground of a living Judaism, and thus indirectly to further the cause of Zionism also. In our view, however, one thing is here to be observed: that the common labour must be animated by the will to the independent development of the Jewish people, if it is to bring forth achievements of value in the deeper sense.
Of the reports something good may already now be said: they are chosen practically and specially enough not to give occasion to a pathetic-phraseological "exchange of opinions". It is concrete themes that are set for discussion, and it is to be wished that their debate may lead to positive, sober, practicable resolutions. It deserves recognition that the special subjects stand upon the order of the day before the general ones — a procedure doubtless to be ascribed to a praiseworthy curbing of youthful exuberance.
Upon the several questions of the conference we shall return in connection with the report of the proceedings. Organisations for the cultivation of Jewish knowledge, for bodily elevation (gymnastics and sport), a Jewish students' home — these are good and fair tasks. The discussion, too, of more general problems which are bound up with the situation of the Jewish youth and its relation to those of other nationalities should yield fruitful points of view.
We wish our friends a worthy course and a lasting success for their undertaking.
*
Upon point I) of the order of the day of the Jewish Students' Day we receive from Mr. Jacob Thon, student, in Lemberg the following lines:
Under the title "A Society for Jewish Learning" I published in May, in our Polish party organ "Wschod", an article in which I wished to give the initiative towards the founding of a Jewish scientific society among our academic youth. I there occupied myself chiefly with establishing the right of such an institution to exist and the necessity for it, while upon the practical execution and the form which it should take I scarcely entered at all. I mentioned only in passing that the society should embrace the Jewish academic youth of all Austria. At this offence might perhaps at once be taken: that it were ridiculous to wish to unite the Jewish academic youth of all Austria and to cultivate Jewish learning at a distance, and that the thought were thus from the outset a mistaken one. I will now confess that for the beginning I renounce with a light heart so wide a dimension of the society, that in the work for its realisation I confine myself merely to Lemberg, and that I shall be exceedingly glad if the work succeeds with us here. Yet I am of opinion that the mere publication of the plan might bring some profit to those colleagues who do not read Polish.
In the first place I should not wish the nature of such a society to be rated too high. I do not mean that the youth should there found a Jewish science, or even intensively develop further one already in being and maintain it at a worthy height. That might indeed come at some later day; for the beginning one would have to content oneself with far less. Our youth shall cultivate Jewish learning, first of all for its own sake: it shall learn to know its people, how it was in its earliest years of childhood, what path its later development has taken and how it looks now, in order to know how it may and will yet look. Only in this way, by sinking itself in the soul of the people, in the spirit of Judaism, can the Zionist youth confirm its sense of belonging together and give to its conviction a deeper and firmer basis. But neither should the youth of other opinions, however it may desire to bring about the solution of the Jewish question, shrink back from this. Upon this very road it should seek the scientific foundation of its solution and, if it does not find it, be honest enough to seek a better one. In any case these elements too cannot deny that through the investigation of Judaism they further their own self-knowledge in a considerable degree. However they may be minded towards Judaism, they cannot disown their actual Jewish descent: if they would analyse their own being more closely, they must learn to know Judaism.
The work shall be a work of the masses, which should offer to the most gifted as well as to the great multitude of middling gifts an opportunity of contributing their mite. Since a science which has for its object a whole people in every direction of its former and its present existence is boundless, every man, to whatever branch of knowledge he may otherwise devote himself, finds here the possibility of attaching himself in fitting fashion to Jewish studies. Every Zionist in particular would have the duty of rendering, in such form, the spiritual national tax.
It is a field wide enough to procure for the jurist, the physician, the philosopher, the technician, the theologian, the historian of literature and of art sufficient opportunity for work.
What a wide task, for example, has the jurist: to investigate the legal conditions under which the Jews lived throughout the whole Diaspora, and likewise to gather exact data upon the present economic, social and legal circumstances of the Jews. These are, after all, only things which in the first place demand diligent study of the sources, which might then be excellently turned to account.
The medical men would have much to say upon the racial purity of the Jews, and would have to establish scientifically the deviations in their physiological structure (of which people speak), their hereditary diseases and so forth.
The share of the Jews in the cultures of foreign peoples would surely be for many an exceedingly fruitful and stimulating theme.
The lion's share of the work would of course fall to the theologians — to them, who already pursue Jewish learning by profession and who are the only ones to whom Hebrew sources are accessible.
Let us then begin with little things, but also only begin. For I see growing out of the at first insignificant school exercises ever deeper and more successful works, and at last excellent achievements arising as well.
If we find among our seniors, among whom there are after all representatives of every branch of knowledge, teachers and leaders (and I hope we shall find them), then let them help us at the work; if not, we shall work ourselves.
But the work of the masses will shape itself into a true national work.
Amsterdam Letter.
A fine life we lead, we Dutch Jews. When we have money, a magnificent one. When we have none, we go about our occupation among the people and earn our livelihood and, quite incidentally, a few expressions such as dirty Jew or Jewish swindler. Has anybody ever fallen sick of it? How then could Dr. Isidore Hen, our comrade in opinion, write last year that much, nay very much, in Holland was not good for the Jews? The Jewish great ones protested with all the strength of their bodies — out of prudence. Somebody might in the end believe it, and in a spirit of enterprise demand of the Kahal chiefs that they should do better. And these are really already doing all that is humanly possible to them. There is even Jewish instruction. The teacher does indeed receive, in the
