Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 45 · 8 November 1901
6printed page
scan 6 of 16

Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 45.

(continued from page 5)

…that "the whole land" were to be overspread with a network of plantation companies. How many tracts of land there are, after all, which cannot be employed for yield-bearing plantations, but can be used only as fields, pasture-land, forest, etc.

So much as regards the correction of the false statements. But as concerns the Oppenheimer ideas, which are set forth publicly by Simonson more correctly than our own expositions, they appear to us in their theoretical part as extraordinarily important. Without doubt they are ideas which deserve full consideration in the Jewish colonization of Palestine. Their practical application, however, in the manner in which Simonson proposes it, recalls unhappily all too much the now vanished times of the Rothschild administration, where likewise the colonists laboured as day-labourers under an independent and responsible direction of experts and administrators, whereby the results now universally lamented were attained. Evidently Oppenheimer's proposals have to do with a class of men fairly far advanced morally and intellectually, which is able also to overcome all the frictions that the formation of a society entails. We doubt, however, whether this is already now the case here in Palestine.

But, as has been said, the Oppenheimer theories do nevertheless well deserve to be thoroughly studied and applied, though only in part, mutatis mutandis, to the conditions here.

Jaffa, the 16th October 1901.

A Blood Accusation against the Jews of Zakynthos in the Year 1712.

Most Jewish periodicals which are published by Jews for Jews are wont to practise a kind of hunting-sport after utterances of non-Jews concerning Judaism. If they ferret out somewhere a well-meaning-sounding pronouncement, they are full of praise and thanks for the certificate of good conduct; and if "the other" expresses himself unfavourably, they cannot do enough in the way of refutations and endeavours at defence. In the end the thing becomes tedious to the calm and considerate reader, whom only real instruction concerning Judaism can satisfy. Our forefathers, who lived in a still greater Golus than we, disdained to set up in their belletristic and still more in their scientific labours the vain praise of the non-Jews as something especially worth striving after; for they felt themselves to be Jews and were sufficient unto themselves in the judgment of the world. It is in truth also far too ridiculous to lay great weight upon the opinions of such people as have as a rule acquired only a superficial, insufficient knowledge of the history and the stories of the Jews, and who therefore have only subjective feelings, grounded upon inadequate acquaintance with the matter, to bring forward. And it matters nothing in this if the good man be otherwise a specialist in some field or other, and in possession of well-endowed posts, high dignities and distinctions, and of a great influence resulting therefrom. The trivial principle that one is called to treat publicly only of that wherein one is an expert does not hold good nowadays, as it would almost appear, with regard to the Jews in particular just as little as, say, with regard to women in general.

Because I know and abhor this modern mischief, I avoid, as a National Jew, in intercourse with writers and scholars who are not Jews, every occasion that might lead to discussions which I hold to be unworthy. Love I seek not where none is shown me; but respect I procure for myself by my honest work. Therefore I get on, after a fashion, in intercourse with Christian colleagues no worse than in that with my co-religionists. Of prejudices and preconceptions the men of no confession are free, and therefore I take them as they are; yet it does rejoice me when here and there I meet with one whom one may hear report of Jews without having to swallow vexation.

Such an unprejudiced reporter is, for example, Bernhard Schmidt, professor at the (Catholic) University in Freiburg i. B. Nearly 40 years ago he published an excellent, much-cited work upon the popular life of the modern Greeks, which he supplemented in a thankworthy manner by a slenderer little book, appearing two years since, upon "The Island of Zakynthos. Things Experienced and Investigated" (Freiburg, at Ernst Fehsenfeld's). Herein he tells also of the Jews of this island. His communications deserve reproduction, not merely because they are kept purely objective, but also because they teach what lamentable fruits superstition may ripen. Why should we conceal from ourselves that a great part of the population among whom we live stands no less under the spell of the blood-superstition than do those of Zakynthos, and that it shrinks back from excesses such as those which Schmidt depicts out of the past of the island of Zakynthos only from an anxious fear of the penal consequences? The primal ground of the superstition is in part laid bare by the report. It is, to be sure, by no means new to us, this ground; but one must recall it repeatedly to memory in order not to forget it, for thereby many a one may govern himself. We thereby learn to know our opponents, their movements and their tactics, more exactly. The chief fault of the Jews I believe I must discern in this, that they have too soon forgotten their history of suffering. In the middle and in the third quarter of the XIXth century they let themselves be deceived by a success which led them forth out of the crooked ghetto. Into freedom? Certainly, but yet only into that outside the other ghetto, in which the Christians lived on, intellectually and socially confined. Whoever wished to make himself at home in the Christian ghetto could for the most part carry it through only by surrendering his Judaism. The Jews of assimilation or of amalgamation, the apes of non-Jewish externals, were bound to become the butt of the mockery and scorn of the Christians, and to fan anew their smouldering hatred. History shows us that in the end the real Jews had to pay the reckoning for the pushing forwardness of the half-Jews, the still-Jews too, the parade-Jews, and of those who would rather not be recognized. The occurrences of the very latest years in Western Galicia, Bohemia, Moravia and West Prussia prove clearly that we Jews may by no means yet trust the peace, and must praise ourselves happy if a catastrophe which breaks over us runs its course less gruesomely than was that of which Prof. Schmidt gives us tidings, as follows.

"The number of the Israelites amounted (in the year 1862) to about 200 souls. Even under the English protectorate they had not yet attained their civil equality with the Christians. They could indeed acquire immovable property since the constitution of 1817, but were excluded from all offices. Only the union of the Septinsular State with the Greek kingdom has brought them the enjoyment of all political rights. Their language is the Greek. With the exception of a few rich families, they dwell together, even now, in a particular quarter of the town. The origin of this ghetto dates from the year 1712 and was the consequence of a rising against the Jews on account of a ritual murder alleged to have been committed by them. A detailed report hereupon, which is taken from the manuscript chronicle of Barbianis, lies before us in the introduction of a book published by S. Ch. Raphtanis at Zakynthos in 1861, which under the general title Τὰ ἰουδαϊκά contains writings of various authors against Judaism. On Palm Sunday of the said year 1712 a five-year-old Christian boy disappeared and could not, in spite of all the efforts of his parents and of the police, be found. On the afternoon of Holy Saturday there was found outside the town, upon the strand, the corpse of a boy washed ashore by the waves of the sea, which showed wounds upon head, hands and feet. It was exposed in a church of the town, and the above-mentioned parents recognized in it their lost child. The wounds upon the corpse excited the suspicion of the multitude, which, in accordance with a popular opinion spread throughout the whole Orient, believed it beheld in them the tokens of a crucifixion performed by the Jews. Meanwhile the physician who had been called in declared that the child had met its death by drowning, and it was buried. Then an occurrence in itself harmless, namely the chastisement of a Christian boy by an Israelite at whom the former had thrown a stone, brought the existing ferment to open outbreak. The excited people stormed up to the citadel and demanded with cries from the Venetian governor the strict punishment of the Jews. The latter suffered himself to be determined by the raging of the multitude to order the reopening of the scarcely closed grave, and charged four physicians with the examination of the corpse. The report says that it was in fact established that the hands and feet of the dead boy had been pierced through. Now the fury of the people knew no bounds any more. Without awaiting the result of the judicial investigation ordered by the governor, it fell upon the houses of the Israelites, who at that time dwelt scattered about the town