Page 2. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 46.
(continued from page 1)
…of the millions of Jews of the East, and even of those of Austria-Hungary, where the Jews partake of all political and civil rights, is unbearable enough to call forth a movement of emigration. The Russian massacres not only did not call forth the movement, as is widely assumed, but even disorganised it, since they compelled the Jews to leave in masses, and without previous preparation, the lands in which they suffered.
In consequence of this the Jews saw themselves forced to flee to England, America, Australia, South Africa in order to obtain work, since they could not emigrate to Palestine, where nothing was prepared for so numerous an emigration. An emigration taking place under such circumstances was more disastrous than the massacres themselves. It was a veritable catastrophe! It was necessary to combat at once the dispersion of the people, whose dangers were foreseen by the intellectual élite of the people.
The Palestinophile movement, which, as we have seen, existed before 1881, thereafter organised itself systematically. And there were in fact brought about, by the ardent and understanding propaganda of the writers Dr. Pinsker, Lilienblum, Rosenfeld, Lewanda, by the congresses of Warsaw, Vilna, Kattowitz, Odessa, which took place in the years 1887 to 1890, further by the founding of the Odessa Committee, by the emigration of the Jewish student youth from Russia — in a word, by the whole Palestine movement — the centralisation of the scattered efforts of the Jews in favour of the colonisation of Palestine.
The origin and the deeper explanation of all Jewish movements which have had Palestine for their goal is to be found in the historical situation of Israel since the loss of its independence, in the situation of an unavowed nationality without territory, without autonomy, a nationality which is scattered among all the nations and which nevertheless possesses the firm will not to let its strong and peculiar individuality be absorbed by the overwhelming nations.
The general laws of history make no distinction between the Jews and the other nations; that, therefore, holds good for them which is true of the other nations. An elementary law of history declares that every human community which is characterised from the standpoint of race, of religion, of language, or which has merely economic or social interests of its own, must, in order to move in conditions of at least relative freedom, be mistress of its own destinies; that it must itself remodel the laws which regulate its existence; that it must be autonomous and independent. For a nation there is no normal existence without a politically independent territory; that has been sufficiently proved by history, and why should that which holds good for the Irish, the Armenians, the Poles, the Czechs not hold true for the Jews?
Since the exile of the Jews from their fatherland, their sufferings, their wandering life, their roaming from land to land, the confiscation of their goods, the tortures of the Inquisition, the massacres of Chmielnicki, the forced baptisms, the most frightful accusations, the hatred and the contempt of which they are everywhere the object — all these superhuman sufferings, which to-day still hold economically for the majority of the Jews and morally for the generality of them, have one single cause, namely: the Jews form a nation without an autonomous territory, which in consequence depends upon the interests and the caprices of its masters. For the misfortune of the Jews is not the existence of anti-Semitism, but the great ease with which every anti-Semite can convert his feelings into deeds. The French chauvinists may perhaps be opponents of the English, of the Germans; the Russian chauvinists may just as well be opponents of the Swedes or the Turks; the German Conservatives may be opponents of the French. Their malignant feelings are, however, not able to express themselves in deeds which could in any way touch the object of their hatred. It is an impotent rage, which is fettered by the mutual independence of the nations.
With the Jews the very contrary is the case. Their conditions of existence, their public and private rights, the inviolability of their home, the education and the religion of their children, the honour of their women, nay, even their life itself, depend upon the will of their masters. And these masters are the governments and the peoples beneath whose yoke the Jewish people suffers and well-nigh perishes.
In Russia, Roumania, Morocco, nay, even in Austria and Germany, any fable about the alleged ritual murder, put forth by some enterprising anti-Semite, or an economic crisis, a social grievance, suffices to call forth riots, incendiarism, massacres, of which the unhappy Jewish population is the victim.
In France the Dreyfus affair has sufficiently proved that the contempt, the latent hatred of the people against the Jews, is always ready to break forth under any pretext whatever, which it is easy for the anti-Semite by trade to bring forward; it is indeed truly beyond doubt that a Catholic who had actually committed treason could never have produced so much hatred against the Catholics as an alleged Jewish traitor has produced against the Jews.
And in spite of all the assertions to the contrary of the assimilated Jews, anti-Semitism has deep roots in all classes of the French nation, in the army just as much as in the teaching profession. It will be said that the reactionary parties are those which foster anti-Semitism, while all the progressive parties are its opponents. Against this the Jews may urge that in our day the reactionary parties are the most numerous and the most powerful in the whole world, and even in civilised countries such as France and Germany. These parties are of a stubborn vitality.
But besides this rejoinder there is yet another argument which is of great weight. The progressive parties combat anti-Semitism only upon the condition that the Jews let themselves be assimilated, that they let themselves be absorbed by the nations in whose midst they live. That they disappear as a collective individuality. In a word: the Philo-Semites differ from the anti-Semites only in their method. The anti-Semites say: We shall persecute the Jews, make life impossible for them, until their complete extirpation. Whereupon the Philo-Semites answer: By your violent measures you will attain the opposite result; the Jewish soul is only strengthened by the sufferings to which it is exposed; the Jews had in the past enemies more malignant and more powerful than you are. These enemies achieved nothing further than that they burned some thousands of Jews, drove out some hundreds of thousands, persecuted some millions. The Jews, however, always remained erect. Nay, by an irony of fate they are most numerous in those very lands where they are most persecuted. Consequently the final aim has not been attained; therefore another tactic must be employed: We must grant them everything, civil and political rights, even a show of respect, but on the condition that they slowly forget their language, their religion, their solidarity, nay, even their past. The Jewish nationality must be dissolved by the warmth of sympathy, stifled by the force of a long and deadly embrace.
That is the thesis of the Liberals, like Anatole Leroy-Beaulieu, and of the Radicals, like Naquet. In a word: the anti-Semites desire the death of the Jews out of hatred, the Philo-Semites the same out of pity, out of humanity. A Jew proud of the glorious past of his people, who admires the heroism of the millions of Russian, Roumanian, Galician, Moroccan, Persian Jews who, for their moral independence, for their freedom of conscience, courageously endure the physical and moral sufferings which upon them the organised hatred of the Russian, the savage baseness
