Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 50 · 13 December 1901
19scan
of 52

The Commercial Future of Palestine.

By Israel Zangwill.

(Address delivered at the meeting of the Article Club at London on the 20th of November 1901.*)

My Lord Suffield, Your Excellencies, Gentlemen! Notwithstanding the friendly words under which I have just been blushing, I am sure that upon some among you the thought that the commercial future of Palestine should be raised to the subject of a debate falls quite as disagreeably as upon others the reflection of hearing this theme struck up by a professional purveyor of intellectual wares. Commerce, however, is not necessarily divorced from the imagination. I am by no means thinking here of business advertisements in word and picture. Doubtless the ordinary routine of business lays claim in a very slight degree to the faculty of fancy, but the creation of new fields of business demands it quite decidedly. "The commercial future of Palestine," writes

*) Cf. in the previous number, "English Society and Zionism."

We add the following concerning the Club and the assembly:

At the London Article Club a dinner took place on the 20th of November, after which Israel Zangwill spoke upon the commercial future of Palestine and upon Zionism. Lord Suffield, President of the Club, conducted the assembly.

The Article Club belongs among the most distinguished of the newly founded associations of London. It embraces the foremost men of the English colonial and financial world. Its meetings occupy themselves with the burning questions of public life in the commercial and especially in the colonial field. Often the first announcements of new ideas proceed from here. Many a speech is straightway carried forth into the whole world and awakens a thousandfold echo. England's politicians often seize the opportunity of laying their ideas here for the first time before a forum of men of authority.

It bears witness to the far-reaching effect of our movement that this association invited Israel Zangwill to speak, upon the first evening which it arranged in this season, upon the future of Palestine, which is the future of the Jewish people. It points once more to the fact that the foremost circles of English society concede to Zionism the position that is its due.

The meeting shaped itself into a brilliant triumph of our idea.

There were present, among others: Lord Suffield, President of the Article Club, who took the chair; further, Admiral Freemantle, General Charles W. Wilson, Archdeacon Sinclair, the author Hall Caine, Sir William Robinson, ex-Governor of Hongkong, J. H. Turner, Agent-General for British Columbia, A. Dobson, Agent-General for Tasmania, H. B. Lefroy, Agent-General for West Australia, His Excellency Dr. Milicevic, Royal Servian Minister of State, Chevalier G. Shaddik, Agent-General for Venezuela, Major Thirlwall, Vicomte de la Chapelle, Baronet Sir George Cornwall, Captain Melville Boynton, George Bernard Shaw (one of the most eminent members of the social-political Fabian Club), Laurence Cowen, Secretary of the Article Club, Sir Henry Morton Stanley (the famous African traveller), F. A. Dunsford, Mayor of Southampton, Sir Philipp Magnus, Colonel Goldsmid, Chief Rabbi Dr. M. Gaster, Salomon I. Solomon, Herbert Bentwich, Arthur Cohen, Counsel of the Cambridge University, John Cutler, Professor at Kings College in London, Alderman Sir George Hussey.

Lord Suffield's Introductory Words.

Before the chairman gave Mr. Zangwill the word, he said: "Not our session alone, and the rooms in which we sit this time, are new, but new also is the subject of our discussion to-day, and I am convinced that it will interest the members of this commercial Club. Mr. Zangwill has assuredly no need to be first introduced to an audience of Englishmen, but it does appear to me necessary to set forth the grounds why he in particular has been entrusted with the report upon this subject. It is a theme of which I do not know much, although it stands without doubt in connection with the Zionist movement, of which we have all heard, a movement which aims at a revival of the Holy Land through the ancient people which for nineteen centuries has preserved the dream of returning to that land. With this royal dream I have always sympathised (although I really know it only in its outlines), without having hitherto made myself sufficiently familiar with the practical means which are necessary to the transformation of this vision into reality. Mr. Zangwill will without doubt enlighten us fully upon this point, and I hereby invite him with confidence to open the debate."

to me Mr. Augustine Birell; "I hope that Palestine has none such." Without doubt many of you cherish an inward sympathy with this sentiment of Mr. Birell's, and since I have personally tasted the charm of life under tents, since I have seen Laban drive his sheep afield as he did four thousand years ago, since I have watched Rebecca as she tripped from the well with the pitcher upon her shoulder, since I have offered upon breast and brow the oriental greeting to Arab sheiks gliding slowly past upon camels or horses, since I have wandered through the fallen cities and the desert, which is as dead as the moon — I can comprehend the desire to see this primitive historical work, the cradle of religion, preserved unaltered. Mr. Birell fears without doubt that Jeremiah will leave off his lamentations and busy himself with the building of cheap tenement houses. That we must risk; for if, as half the world believes, Palestine goes forward to a glorious future, that future cannot possibly dispense with an industrial basis. Elijah was fed by the ravens, but the bread which they brought him must after all have been baked by somebody, and we know the habits of ravens. Nothing in Holy Writ justifies the assumption that the Holy Land would be one and the same thing with a lazy land. The holy Sabbath itself is dependent upon the six working days.

And Palestine is not merely a land of dreams. In these picturesque ruins the people have to dwell. And these ruins are not, as one imagines, the ruins of a primitive pastoral region, but the ruins of a great state of culture. To restore the roads would mean to restore the great Roman roads of the second century after Christ. The researches of the Society for the Exploration of Palestine have shown us the old Jerusalem, "magnificent with its palaces, its gardens, its citadel, its fortress, its courts and its country houses," as it bids two millions of guests welcome at the Feast of the Passover. And it is not only the Roman Jerusalem that lies beneath the present soil; there are three Jewish Jerusalems besides the Herodian, the Byzantine, the Saracenic, and the Jerusalem of the Knights of the Order of St. John. The Society has through its researches and excavations brought proofs of the enormous population, of the fruitfulness and the wealth of Palestine, and of the greatness of cities which until then were regarded as small and insignificant. When Jesus wandered over the hills and valleys of Galilee, he passed not through a rustic world. "The land," says the late Walter Besant, "was thickly peopled, there were schools in every town; there was there a well-to-do society, there was a Romanising group; there was a Judaising group; everywhere there were rabbis, merchants, heads of the hundreds, legionaries, townsmen and peasants." It was a land that even Rome could not easily hold. The great Jewish leader Bar Kochba did in fact win back the kingdom for a time, and in order to put down his rising the Roman commander-in-chief (the Kitchener) Julius Severus was recalled by Hadrian from the putting down of the less dangerous rising of the wild Britons painted with woad. But many centuries earlier, when Rome itself was an obscure village, Isaiah arraigned his people for its luxury.

It is no primitive pastoral people whose ladies are scourged by Isaiah because they "walk with outstretched necks and wanton eyes, with mincing steps and with tinkling feet." Peasants have no such changeable suits of apparel, the mantles and the wimples, the hairpins, mirrors and fine linen, hoods and veils. Even from the standpoint of a pastoral people Palestine is no longer the land "where milk and honey flow." "Consider only the lilies," said Jesus, and in truth there are still wonderful wild flowers and stretches of remarkable fruitfulness. But where are the beautiful orchards which Josephus mentions round about Caesarea? Buried they lie three hundred feet deep beneath the sand-dunes. Where are the olive trees of the Mount of Olives? Jericho, the land of palms, has not a single palm more, and there is no more balm in Gilead. The artificial irrigation works, for Palestine with its few rivers is for the greatest part upon the Be-