Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 1 · 3 January 1902
4printed page
scan 4 of 16

Page 4. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 1.

(continued from page 3)

…ought to send in. The speaker would ask, too, that not even the appearance of a misunderstanding between Western and Eastern Jews be allowed to arise among us. We should bear in mind that for the Russian Jews the days of the Congress are the highest holidays of the year, and should be disturbed by nothing.

Del. Syrkin, in sonorous Hebrew, rejects the possibility that geography could produce differences among the Jews. Zionism knows no localities, no class, no factions. Unity is its strength.

Dr. Bodenheimer repudiates the charge of glossing made by Dr. Jeremias, and states that, in accordance with the resolution of earlier Congresses, the Zionists of Germany had set about conquering the representative bodies of the communities, in which they are having the desired success, although in the communities of the Protest Rabbis they have to fight amid committed enemies of Zion.

Del. Pazmanik, as reporter for the Swiss national group, states that Zionism may expect help from the Government of Switzerland, as a free country, and that he is officially authorised to make this declaration. In Switzerland there are three kinds of Jews: Russian Jews, Swiss Jews, and Russian-Jewish students. Zionism has found particular currency in Baden, Zurich and Biel, in which last place the whole community is avowedly Zionist. Among the classes of the student body, that of Berne works most ably. The speaker recommends that the humanitarian-Zionist standpoint be adopted in agitation among the Swiss Jews, and points to the numerous cases in which humanitarian Zionists have become able political Zionists.

Del. Awinowitzki declares that the report of the Actions Committee is made up of the report of the inner A.-C. and those of the societies. He asks that in the next report an exact line be drawn between these two fields, and that the report be sent to the delegates a month before the Congress.

As no further speakers are entered, the President of the Actions Committee, Dr. Herzl, takes the floor to answer all questions and complaints:

Gentlemen! The A.-C. has awaited with the greatest attention the criticism which the Congress would pass upon its performance, and I must say we are disappointed. You have handled us less severely than we expected, and the reproaches you have made us, if there are any, are so moderate that we have no occasion to make you counter-reproaches — for the Congress ought to consist in the reciprocity of the reproaches we make one another. We must on no account be satisfied with one another! If we do not answer this mild mood with an equally mild judgment of the activity of the national groups, you must allow it to the A.-C.'s credit and consider in what situation we find ourselves. Our movement does not grow strong by what the A.-C. does; its strengthening can lie only with the societies which are forming everywhere, and there we have had occasion to be somewhat less satisfied than some have been with the A.-C.; and it is a characteristic of our Congresses that, while under the report of the A.-C. every subject is discussed, under every other item the A.-C. is discussed.

The arrangement of our order of the day shows us that we are conscious of the capacity of our movement for improvement — for example, in the matter of organisation. There it will be most in place for the A.-C. to take the offensive. For if the various wishes for the strengthening of our movement are to be fulfilled, we must go back to the root. I believe that that will also be the place to speak of such questions as the dispute in Roumania, and to provide for the future that the ground for such disputes disappears. Dr. S. Rappaport has had wishes and complaints regarding the educational and literary activity of the A.-C. We shall have occasion to speak of schools, since we shall show that we have carried out the instructions of the Congress by subsidies to such and other institutions of culture. Delegates Abrahamsohn and Reichenthal have spoken of shortcomings in Hungary. I would mention that Dr. Marmorek and I were in Budapest in order to win the circles there for Zionism. I observe, however, that it lies in the nature of our present movement that organisations form everywhere, and when they have shown themselves capable of life and seek affiliation, we gladly support them. Support into thin air we cannot give.

Dr. Weizmann has missed the darker sides in our report; it is the business of the Opposition in the Congress to find such. You must draw our attention to what is bad. We surely cannot be more oppositional than the Opposition. As a matter of course all suggestions, now and later, will be received and dealt with as attentively as the A.-C. has always striven to do. If a friendly mood prevails here, it is because it is known that we always exert ourselves to bring the proposals and resolutions of the Congress as near to reality as possible. Del. Bergen has missed in the A.-C.'s report of its stewardship its report as Board of Supervision over the Bank. I believe the place for that is under the next item of the order of the day. The A.-C. gives no report of administration because it is not an administrative body. The A.-C. has only to say No to the transactions of the Bank when it believes it ought to refuse. We have no occasion to report more than that the Bank is properly administered and holds first-class securities for its money, and further that we are not merely nominal supervisors but constantly inspect the books of the company. Delegate Wortsmann has spoken of the salaried appointment of the A.-C. As you know, this motion is right in principle and has already been brought in at earlier Congresses. But the A.-C. still takes the standpoint it took then: we do not believe it compatible with the position of a member of the A.-C. to accept payment. A time will come, it is to be hoped, in which the A.-C. will allow itself to be salaried, and I shall be very glad when that moment arrives; but — then I shall no longer be on the A.-C. None the less, I am very greedy and ask for a great deal of money for the A.-C., over the use of which you yourselves shall decide. Give the A.-C. more money, so that it can do ever more, and send it, not that it may be saved, but that it may be scattered abroad to fructify the soil we are tilling. (Lively applause.)

On the motion of Delegate Dr. Malz, thanks and confidence are thereupon expressed to the A.-C., and the report is approved.

Speech of Dr. Max Nordau.

(Delivered in the Morning Session of the Fourth Day.)

Honoured Assembly!

"Knowledge is strength." Is that always true? I fear it sometimes makes weak as well, for it discourages. Who knows whether our forefathers would have clung, with the tenacious fidelity which constitutes their imperishable glory in history, to their faith and their national tradition, had they been able to survey the situation of their people completely. But they had, I