Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 6 · 7 February 1902
2printed page
scan 2 of 16
Facsimile · scan 2 of 16
Scan of p. 2
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 2 — "Die Welt" — No. 6

(continued from page 1)

…beginning with matters at home before I pass on to the great meeting abroad.

Our December meeting was decried as a childish affair, and as one that degrades Judaism, because there was singing at it, and there was a banner and a phonograph. Assuredly our gentlemen critics had never before been at a political meeting. They need only have gone to Chesterfield¹) or merely to the anti-Semitic meeting in the People's Palace²). And as regards my speaking into the phonograph, for which a Jewish priest reviled me most especially, I must set this very conscientious man right: I never spoke into a phonograph; indeed, I expressly refused to speak into a phonograph, although at bottom I should have no cause for shame had I spoken into a phonograph. I should only have to be ashamed if I were a phonograph that reproduces only such thoughts as others have funnelled into it. Not the singing in a crammed East End synagogue, but rather an empty West End synagogue, in which the singing is done only by paid cantors and hired choir-boys, is what I hold to be a degradation of Judaism. I should also like to remind my honoured critic that even in our none too cheerful Judaism there is, as Koheleth says, a time to rejoice. Yes, even in the synagogue itself, in the solemn synagogue, on "Simchas Thora," rejoicing over the receiving of the Torah with flags and sweetmeats and quite other childish things is enjoined. Zionism, now, is the rejoicing of Israel, a kind of "Simchas Zion," as there is a "Simchas Thora."

I shall not speak much about Zionism this evening, for I have found a more eloquent defender of Zionism: the "Jewish Chronicle" of twenty years ago. When the late Laurence Oliphant³) — blessed be his name — had drawn up his plan for the colonisation of Palestine, the "Jewish Chronicle," in its number of the 9th of January 1880, wrote as follows: "The rich Jews form only a small part of our brethren. Of those who are prosperous and contented there are comparatively few among us. The latter would perhaps be disinclined to leave their quiet and luxurious homes in order to seek and to find a new land and a new civilisation. But those who are oppressed and unhappy yearn ardently for the advantages which a re-consolidated nationality would give them... It is oppression and not prosperity that will lead us back into our 'Holy Land.' It cannot be denied that at no time in our more recent history have so many forces as now been at work which aim at our restoration...

The project of Mr. Laurence Oliphant, which we gave in detail in our last number, contains the most practical and the best plan ever put forward... The matter is a purely commercial and administrative speculation, and the unsentimental nature of its character is a guarantee of the practicability of this plan... At present the one thing needful which we ask of our brethren, and which our brethren are also able to do, is the possession of capital, which they may give us not as a gift but as an investment to be remunerated. And this is in no wise an even remotely improper way of appealing to our feelings. We can place some of our protégés, our brethren in Palestine, in a position where they can help themselves, and at the same time teach them the industry which leads to the regeneration of the nation... We have been an agricultural people, and we shall become one again. A nation always begins by producing food, and then, as it advances, it passes on to manufacture. It would be a great elevation of the Jewish character in the eyes of the whole world if the Jews should prove themselves fit to administer a colony in order and harmony under the present lawless conditions of the Ottoman Government. It would be a peaceful triumph, worthy of the days of the Messiah, when all shall live in peace...

Without being in a position to promise Mr. Oliphant our full support until we are in possession of all the administrative details and have knowledge of the character of those persons to whom the local administration is to be entrusted, we can already to-day go so far as to say that his project, among all the others that have been drawn up down to the present, commends itself of its own accord to the earnest consideration of all sincere and true Jews. Mr. Oliphant is evidently a freethinker; he has no religious motives... He is a politician who wishes to carry a theory into practice, and nothing else. But the least of us may be the instrument of Providence, and the least religious may be guided to good by the hand of God. Heaven grant that a man of great intelligence, though of slight faith, may become the forerunner of the Messiah, who according to our tradition will be only a man of wonderful intelligence and strength, of great influence and wonderful organisation. Exceptionally, higher, spiritual qualities may also not be the result of divine inspiration... To wait for a directly visible miracle in order not to support a work that leads to the great goal is to be like children who are not strong enough to break the paternal leading-strings and to support their father in his work, and who rely upon him alone to give them their daily bread."

Ladies and gentlemen! Can the case of Dr. Herzl and the Basle Programme be better set forth than in these few words of the "Jewish Chronicle"?

Six months later the same paper returned once more, in an extremely sympathetic manner, to the same subject, and pointed out that it was to be ascribed solely to the Sultan's opposition to every reform that Mr. Oliphant had still not obtained the "Charter."

But now that 22 years have elapsed, and the position of the Jews in Europe has become rather worse than better, and there is danger that Palestine will be snatched away by strangers; now that the necessary capital is abundantly at hand in the bequest of Baron Hirsch, and the Sultan's opposition has vanished — what has now become of the "Jewish Chronicle"? Why is the "Jewish Chronicle" of to-day, instead of going hand in hand with this great endeavour for the liberation of our race, infinitely less sympathetic to our, the Zionist, cause than "The Daily Chronicle" or the "Daily News" or the "Daily Telegraph"? Is it because the rich Jews are against us? They misunderstand our position, just as they misunderstand their own. For John Burns has already put the question in the English Parliament whether the restriction of alien immigration will also be extended to Park Lane⁴).

When I last spoke to you, I alluded to the sentiments of some of our opponents, which I described as atheistic. This gave rise to contradiction. It was urged that they merely recognise the hard facts of the universe, that victory in this world falls not to sentiment but to material power. If this be the ground of their attitude, then I withdraw the charge of atheism, with all apologies to Giordano Bruno and the other great atheists who lived and suffered for the freedom of thought