Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 6 · 7 February 1902
7printed page
scan 7 of 16
Facsimile · scan 7 of 16
Scan of p. 7
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 6 — "Die Welt" — Page 7.

(continued from page 6)

…of our Bible? The failure of the Rothschild incubation proves nothing against a natural birth. To think that after eighteen hundred years of waiting the moment has at last come when the possibility of resettling Palestine with Jews exists; to think that the millions for colonisation were really bequeathed to his people by a great philanthropist — and to let the whole lie fallow now, is appalling!

Dr. Gaster defends the Association against charges which I did not make. What charges did I make, then, at all? I did not even blame it for giving Zionism nothing of its superfluity. What reproach did I utter? I thought it unjust that the trustees — when, at a critical period of Jewish history, a Jew was received by the ruler of Palestine, and had said enough at the Maccabean Society to open up the possibility of fruitful activity for the sterile millions of Baron Hirsch — did not officially invite Dr. Herzl to a conference. We often hear it said: "If Dr. Herzl has something up his sleeve, why does he not bring it out?" But what statesman makes his confidential negotiations known to the general public? Dr. Gaster said: "When the way is paved, I think financial support will not be withheld from us." I do not know on what authority he bases this assertion. Certainly Mr. Montefiore did not contradict it, but Dr. Gaster has contradicted himself since then. For last Saturday he made a speech in an altogether different sense. But the Grand Rabbin of France, Zadoc Kahn, another of the trustees, said last year at a public meeting: "When the idea of a Jewish State is realised, the 'Ica' will supply it with all the elements necessary for its existence."

"For its existence?" Why not for its coming into being? "When the way is paved" — truly, when the way is paved the "Ica" will place a carriage at our disposal. But I think we shall then rather go on foot. Now the money could be of use. Their good intentions are useless. We know what road is paved with good intentions. Its name is not Palestine. The road to Palestine is paved only with gold. To put it in a few words, as the "Jewish Chronicle" did in the early days, in the days of Laurence Oliphant, it is capital that is required — capital, which, as that paper satirically remarked at the time, is the one requisite quality that our brethren possess. What the "Ica" does with the money instead, how the "Ica" helps to rescue Israel, we have already seen. Do they really know what to do with their money? Have they ever spent the income? How much do they spend? What does it cost to crack nuts? The only thing we know they have spent was a million in death-duties; this was made known through the press. We know, too, that they enjoy the glory of having paid two Viennese advocates the largest bill of costs, namely 800 000 Kronen. I am happy that the "Jewish Chronicle" agrees with me that it ought at least to publish a balance-sheet annually.

In the year 1900 we had the lamentable immigration of unhappy Roumanians, and the "Ica" is still earnestly at work settling them here and there. But these Roumanian Jews were not beggars. They were men of strength and intellectual capacity. Of those who passed through the Poor Jews' Shelter there were 194 master carpenters, 87 smiths, 91 joiners, 30 weavers, 9 farmers, etc. They were the very labour force that is so needful in new colonies. Now, we hear, some of them are employed in the coal and iron mines of Cape Breton and Newfoundland. Had the millions of Baron Hirsch been well employed, these Roumanians, instead of being received with dejection, would have been welcomed most heartily, and a Jewish colony would have stood ready to receive them. Large parts of the territory of the "Ica" are still not brought under cultivation. Why, then, the delay?

"The 'Ica' is not a charity bureau," said Mr. Zadok Kahn, when he was asked to support the starving workmen of Palestine. Quite right! The "Ica" is not a charity bureau. For that very reason I remind the Jewish Colonization Association of its task, which is to create Jewish colonies. Its millions ought to be applied to the recovery of Palestine, as British millions, and Jewish millions too, were applied to the recovery of Egypt. Egypt pays, and Palestine will pay likewise. Yes, I believe that we shall no longer need the support of the "Ica" from the moment it obtains the Charter for us — the Charter which is expressly mentioned in its statutes.

What Mr. Zadok Kahn calls "the elements which are necessary for the existence of the Jewish State" will come of themselves. You need only read the history of any new American town — the rush of the colonists, the parcelling out of the building lots in a brief span of time — to perceive how the opening of a crown land in Palestine to Jewish capital and Jewish labour would of itself attract that capital and that labour. The present unhappy colonies of the "Ica" would be the first to profit by the general rise in values, by the proverbial "unearned increment." That is the work by which the colonies could be made to pay — not by letting their superfluous workmen starve outside Palestine.

When Dr. Gaster returned to the charge last Saturday, he asked: "Have Zionists a right to attack the trustees, who follow certain prescribed regulations and discharge by law the function of a trust?" But, ladies and gentlemen, my citations prove sufficiently that if there is anything at all of doubtful legality in the operations of the "Ica," it is not the expenditure in Palestine, but the endless expenditure on those undertakings, some of which do not stand even in indirect connection with the purposes of colonisation. When country-folk in Russia are on the point of dying of starvation, the "Ica" helps them over the crisis; but when they are dying of starvation in Palestine, then we are informed that the "Ica" is not a charity bureau; at most it could help them to leave Palestine. Dr. Gaster says there is no difference between the begging of a nation and the begging of an individual. Begging? The money was bequeathed to the Jewish nation, and it demands its lawful due. Dr. Gaster does not like sharp, bitter discussions; but arguments are not bitterness. I have tried to learn Dr. Gaster's own sentiments at the Jewish Lads' Brigade Dinner last Wednesday: "The best fencers are those who know how to hit straight from the shoulder." If ever I made a fighting speech for Zion, it was at our last meeting in this hall, when Dr. Gaster presided, whereas the speech on account of which he disowned me was delivered at Basle, hundreds of miles away from here. Surely our old champion, our great orator, cannot have the wish himself with the old official group, which already criticism, this social weapon of defence, as a crime re-